AI losses are hiding inside existing policies, Allianz Commercial warns

Confirmed AI claims understate true exposure as losses hide inside cyber, D&O and liability policies
AI losses are hiding inside existing policies, Allianz Commercial warns
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION
By Mark Rosanes
Nov 19, 2026

Allianz Commercial is warning that confirmed AI-related insurance losses significantly understate the true exposure. Most AI claims are absorbed into existing categories such as cyber, directors’ and officers’ (D&O) liability, product liability, or crime without being identified as AI losses at all, and that misclassification is masking a risk profile that is growing faster than current claims data suggests.

The report finds that confirmed AI-related insurance losses remain modest by current claims data, but that figure understates the exposure by a wide margin. Allianz Commercial says it is tracking AI-related claims with values in the millions of euros, and notes that individual cases it has observed could each produce total insurance industry losses in the region of US$100 million.

“Today’s apparently modest number of confirmed AI claims hides the true extent of exposures for businesses,” said Thomas Lillelund, chief executive officer of Allianz Commercial. “The loss scenarios already emerging show why business leaders should prioritize AI within governance and resilience planning.”

Incidents rising, lawsuits accelerating

The MIT AI Risk Initiative tracked 179 reported AI incidents in 2023. That figure reached 453 incidents recorded in 2025, based on data pulled as of October 7. That is a rise of more than 150% in two years, and the report notes the trajectory shows no sign of slowing.

Litigation is following the same curve. AI-related securities class action filings in the US stood at seven in 2023 and rose to 16 in 2025, according to Cornerstone Research. By end of August 2026, that figure had already reached 22, according to The D&O Diary. The most prominent driver is what Allianz Commercial calls AI washing, where companies overstate or misrepresent their AI capabilities in investor disclosures and face shareholder suits when results disappoint. The report notes confirmed D&O notifications in this category, with cases capable of reaching nine-figure loss totals.

Intellectual property exposure has also moved from theoretical to active. As of June 2026, 115 IP lawsuits had been filed against AI developers by artists, entertainment, and media companies, according to a copyright litigation tracker maintained by ChatGPT Is Eating the World.

Four ways AI generates a loss

The report introduces a framework for categorising AI losses that has direct implications at placement time. Direct AI loss occurs when the AI system itself causes harm through a wrong output, decision, or recommendation. AI-related loss arises from surrounding governance, legal, or reputational issues connected to AI, with D&O AI-washing claims as the clearest current example.

AI-accelerated loss covers cases where AI enables or scales malicious activity, including deepfake fraud and AI-enhanced cyberattacks. The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) attributed approximately US$893 million in AI-related cybercrime costs to US citizens in 2025, according to the report’s citation of the FBI’s 2025 Internet Crime Report.

Another category, AI-dependency loss, is the one most likely to arrive without warning. Here, the initial event is not caused by AI at all, but a business so reliant on AI-driven processes that it has no functional manual fallback suffers dramatically amplified losses when the system fails.

The report describes a large retailer whose AI-dependent supply chain ground to paper-based processes after a third-party technology outage, producing inventory imbalances, delays, and significant financial losses. “The primary loss driver is therefore not the outage itself, but the organisation’s dependency on AI-supported processes and the limited capability to operate effectively without them,” said Michael Daum, head of the AI Risk and Claims Center of Excellence at Allianz Commercial.

The coverage gap clients don’t know they have

The reason all of this lands directly with brokers is that most clients deploying AI do not have a clear answer to a basic question: which policy responds when something goes wrong? A 2026 RAND Corporation report on AI insurability found that carriers are split three ways on AI coverage, with a minority affirmatively covering AI losses, a growing number filing broad exclusions, and the majority remaining silent.

That silence is not a neutral position. When a policy says nothing about AI, coverage depends on how the claim is characterised after the loss, a determination that varies by carrier and line. Reviewing how each line in a client’s existing tower responds to the four AI loss categories the Allianz report identifies is a practical starting point before the next renewal.

The D&O market reflects this uncertainty. Insurers are closely monitoring AI-washing exposure but have largely stopped short of broad exclusions, leaving policy wording effectively silent on AI liability for most corporate clients. That position is expected to shift as claims accumulate.

What makes AI different from earlier emerging risk categories is the systemic dimension. Many AI systems run on the same large language models, training data, and cloud infrastructure, meaning a single flaw or outage could produce correlated losses across many businesses simultaneously. That concentration risk has no close equivalent in earlier technology-driven liability cycles.

At the same time, Allianz Commercial’s analysis finds that organisations using AI-driven detection tools carry materially lower breach costs, with early response capable of stopping a €20,000 cyber loss from becoming a €20 million one. Companies that invest in AI oversight and fallback planning carry a different risk profile from those that do not, and that distinction will increasingly show up in underwriting.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB ASIA.