Cyberattack tactics are outpacing what renewal forms ask

A documented shift in how ransomware gets in puts the coverage clients think they have at risk
Cyberattack tactics are outpacing what renewal forms ask
INSURANCE NEWS
By Roxanne San Jose
Nov 20, 2026

Cyber insurance renewal conversations have rested on a consistent assumption for several years: get multi-factor authentication (MFA) in place, and your insurer will look at you differently. That assumption is now a liability.

A quarterly threat report released in November 2026 by Beazley Security documented four distinct techniques attackers used systematically in Q3 to bypass MFA without ever breaking it. They waited for users to log in, then stole the active session. They generated device codes and had victims approve access through legitimate sign-in pages. They harvested session tokens using infostealer malware. And once inside a compromised account, they registered their own devices to retain access after credentials were reset.

“Attackers have learned to wait until the user signs in, then steal the session. MFA still matters, but it can’t protect a session that’s already been stolen,” said Josh Carolan, director of security research at Beazley Security.

Brokers advising clients on cyber insurance renewal preparation in Canada need to understand what this means for their clients’ attestations before the next renewal cycle, not after a claim is filed.

Read next: Canada’s cyber protection gap won’t close until insurers make it simpler to buy

The gap between attestation and actual coverage

Most cyber insurance applications still ask whether MFA is in place – not which type, or how completely it is deployed. A Centre for Cybersecurity Policy and Law paper published in October 2026, developed with contributions from industry participants including insurers and brokers, concluded that nearly every applicant now answers yes to MFA, and that underwriters need to start asking whether it is phishing-resistant, and on which accounts.

The gap between what a questionnaire records and what an attack actually encountered is a direct coverage risk. A client who attested to MFA on last year’s renewal application and then experienced a breach through an Adversary-in-the-Middle (AiTM) session hijack may find that attestation scrutinized during the claims process.

This is a live risk in Canada. The Canadian Centre for Cyber Security assessed in its Ransomware Threat Outlook 2025 to 2027 that ransomware incidents grew at an average of 26% per year from 2021 to 2024, and that ransomware will remain a significant threat to Canada over the next two years. In the 2024 to 2025 fiscal year, the Centre issued 336 pre-ransomware notifications to over 300 Canadian organizations, estimating economic savings of up to CA$18 million. The pipeline from compromised session to ransomware deployment is shortening, not lengthening.

Exploitation doubles as patch volumes overwhelm teams

MFA bypass is only part of the Q3 picture. The share of ransomware cases beginning with an exploited vulnerability doubled from 14% in Q2 to 28% in Q3, according to the Beazley Security report. Attackers moved away from front-door credential attacks toward internet-facing, self-hosted applications – build servers, analytics platforms, collaboration tools – that receive less patch management attention than operating systems and endpoint software.

The volume of publicly disclosed vulnerabilities reached approximately 37,000 in Q3, up nearly 80% over Q2, as vendors deployed AI tools to scan their own code. Most security teams cannot keep pace. In several cases, investigators found attackers locating cloud access keys on compromised servers and deploying ransomware through the victim’s own cloud infrastructure.

“At today’s volume, security teams simply cannot treat every vulnerability as equally urgent. Start with known exploited vulnerabilities and internet-facing applications, then prioritize systems that provide access to credentials, cloud infrastructure, or critical business operations,” said Alton Kizziah, CEO of Beazley Security.

For brokers preparing clients for renewal, patch management documentation has become as important a conversation as MFA. The sectors showing the highest ransomware frequency in Q3 were healthcare at 21% of investigated cases, Business Services at 18%, and Manufacturing and Distribution at 17%.

AI agents run a breach without human direction

The Q3 report contains the first publicly documented case of a breach conducted almost entirely by coordinated AI agents. Operating through a multi-agent harness across three servers, the agents deployed approximately 270 attack scripts, tried around a dozen known exploits, were stopped by MFA on credential attacks, then identified a vulnerability in a custom-built application, obtained a service account credential, moved laterally, and exfiltrated data.

“These agents use the same old tricks. They just find the unpatched server or the flat network faster than any human team, and they never get tired,” said Francisco Donoso, chief product and technology officer at Beazley Security.

Canada’s Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) addressed the broader risk class directly in its July 2026 bulletin on generative and agentic AI, noting these technologies “amplify the speed, scale, and automation of cyber and operational risks, driving a structural shift in the risk landscape and challenging existing risk management frameworks.” The bulletin builds on OSFI’s Guideline B-13 on Technology and Cyber Risk Management and applies to all federally regulated financial institutions in Canada, including insurers.

Cyber insurance premiums in Canada have been softening even as that risk picture has darkened. BOXX Insurance president Neal Jardine said publicly in November 2026 that premiums are falling even as AI makes attacks quicker and cheaper to launch – a disconnect brokers are well-placed to explain before the market corrects.

Read next: Cyber premiums are falling as AI drives risk higher, BOXX exec warns

The ClickFix timeline is worth raising in client conversations directly. Beazley Security found that ransomware deployment typically followed a ClickFix infection by two to three weeks. Clients without a tested incident response plan may be carrying an uninsured gap they do not know exists.

The full Beazley Security Quarterly Threat Report for Q3 2026 is available at beazley.security/insights/quarterly-threat-report-third-quarter-2026.

Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB ASIA.