Far out Friday: Five-year-old lands parents with $177k bill

One mother says she's been asked to pay up by an insurance firm after her son damaged an expensive sculpture

Far out Friday: Five-year-old lands parents with $177k bill

Insurance News

By Nicola Middlemiss

The ‘you-break-it-you-buy-it’ rule may be every parent’s worst nightmare but it’s one that could be about to come true for a US mother after her son knocked over an incredibly expensive sculpture.

Sarah Goodman was attending a wedding reception at a Kansas community centre when her five-year-old attempted to hug a mosaic bust but accidentally brought the artwork toppling down.

Fast-forward a few weeks and Goodman’s family received a letter from the community centre’s insurance company, informing them that they’re liable for the damage – all US$132,000 (AU$177K) of it.

“It’s clear accidents happen and this was an accident,” Goodman told local news outlet, the Kansas City Star. “I don’t want to diminish the value of their art but I can’t pay for that.”

The centre’s insurance firm suggested Goodman and her husband were not supervising their son closely enough and their “failure to monitor [the child] during this loss could be considered negligent.”

However, the family disagreed and said the valuable sculpture should have been better protected or displayed in a more appropriate area.

“It’s in the main walkway – not a separate room, not plexiglass, not protected, not held down,” said Goodman. “No-one would ever to expect that - to come into a place that kids are invited and have to worry about a US$132,000 piece of art falling on their child.”

A spokesman for Overland Park City said the city filed a claim with their insurance company, which then contacted the Goodman family.

“It will be up to the insurance companies to get this worked out,” he said.

 

 

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!