Insurance AI spend soars as measurable returns stay out of reach

Heavy investment in carrier technology is yet to translate into enterprise-wide performance
Insurance AI spend soars as measurable returns stay out of reach
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION
By Roxanne San Jose
20 Nov 2026

Nearly two-thirds of insurance chief executives plan to direct between 11% and 20% of their total budget to artificial intelligence over the next 12 months, yet just 1% say their organisation has already achieved a measurable return on that investment, according to the 2026 KPMG Global Insurance CEO Outlook, released November 19, 2026.

The survey draws on responses from 100 insurance CEOs across 12 markets, all leading organisations with annual revenues above $500 million. Some 82% identify AI as a top investment priority over the next three years. Despite that level of commitment, the gap between spend and demonstrated results is stark.

That gap is not unique to this survey. A 2026 Deloitte Canada analysis of the domestic market found that Canadian insurers have moved quickly to test and deploy AI across their businesses, but that value from individual use cases rarely compounds across the enterprise – what Deloitte describes as an “orchestration gap,” meaning the failure of isolated AI initiatives to build on one another and generate broader business performance.

Read more: Canadian insurance is behind on AI – but the disruption to brokers isn’t waiting

Earnings confidence rises despite slow AI returns

Against that backdrop, optimism about growth is running high. The share of insurance CEOs expecting annual earnings growth of 5% to 9.99% doubled year on year, rising from 15% in 2025 to 30% this year. Overall, 87% are confident in their own company’s growth prospects over the next three years, and 88% are confident in the broader industry’s outlook – both well ahead of their confidence in the global economy, which stands at 68%.

Expectations for AI returns are nonetheless shifting. Some 84% of respondents now expect to see results from AI investment within one to three years, up from 67% in 2025. At the same time, the cost of getting there is becoming harder to ignore: 48% cite implementation costs as a challenge, up from 37% last year.

Frank Pfaffenzeller, global head of Insurance at KPMG International, said the results point to a critical moment for the sector.

“Insurance CEOs have good reason to be confident about the opportunities ahead, with stronger earnings expectations pointing to continued growth potential across the sector. At the same time, for many organisations, significant investment in AI has yet to translate into measurable returns. The challenge now is to turn that investment and confidence into sustained performance,” Pfaffenzeller said.

Claims and underwriting take priority over distribution

The survey identifies where carriers expect technology to generate the most direct commercial value. Some 50% of respondents name claims transformation and automation as one of their three most significant drivers of value creation over the next three years. Underwriting and pricing optimisation follows at 49%, with policyholder experience and retention at 47%.

That prioritisation matters for the distribution channel. Carriers directing AI investment into underwriting and claims first – rather than broker-facing tools – creates a lag between where technology is being deployed and where brokers interact with it daily. The KPMG data confirms that pattern: operational transformation inside the carrier, not outward-facing distribution investment, is driving the technology agenda. For brokers assessing the technology their carrier partners are building, the 2026 Global 5-Star Technology and Software Providers report offers a broker-rated view of which platforms are delivering measurable impact.

While 77% of insurance CEOs surveyed say their organisations have made significant progress modernising their core operating models, just 3% consider themselves fully modernised across most core functions.

Matthew Smith, global lead of insurance strategy and transformation at KPMG International and partner at KPMG in the UK, said the gap between progress and completion reflects a sector still mid-way through a significant transition.

“Claims, underwriting and pricing are areas where better processes, technology and data can have a direct impact on efficiency, customer outcomes and performance. While insurers have made meaningful progress modernising their operating models, there is still considerable work ahead,” Smith said.

Read more: AI budget overruns leave Canadian brokers caught in the middle

Regulatory and workforce pressures compound the picture

Regulatory pressure ranks as the leading threat to growth among insurance CEOs, cited by 41% of respondents – significantly higher than the 26% recorded among CEOs across all sectors in the same survey. Cybersecurity and data security follow at 37%.

For Canadian carriers, that exposure is real and tightening. The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) has finalised its updated Guideline E-23 on model risk management, which takes effect May 1, 2027, and sets out how federally regulated insurers must govern the AI and machine learning models they deploy. Requirements from the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) and the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) add further layers of accountability at the provincial level.

Nearly three-quarters of respondents expect rising costs or inflationary pressures to affect their organisation’s performance over the next three years. On workforce, 52% of insurance CEOs cite skills gaps as a leading challenge, even as 86% expect headcount to grow and 83% are actively recruiting for AI and technology capabilities – up from 54% in 2025.

M&A remains active but more targeted

On deal activity, the survey points to a more selective approach. Some 52% of respondents now anticipate acquisitions with a moderate impact on their organisation, up from 40% in 2025, while the share expecting significant M&A impact has fallen from 50% to 36%. For carriers under pressure to close the AI returns gap, targeted acquisitions represent one route to acquiring the technology capability that organic investment has yet to deliver.

The KPMG findings describe an industry that is confident about where it is going but still working out how to get there – and spending heavily in the meantime.

Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB AU.