Marine insurance is moving from asset-level thinking to network-level thinking. Tom Hughes, head of marine underwriting at AXA XL in Australia, and Sameen Naveed, senior claims specialist for marine at AXA XL in Australia, argue that events such as the Suez Canal grounding of 2021, Red Sea attacks from late 2023, Panama Canal drought restrictions and the Baltimore bridge collapse in March 2024 share one lesson: a localised event now produces symptoms throughout the whole system. Their analysis shifts the discipline's focus from individual vessels and cargoes to the interdependent networks those assets depend on, and from paid claims to the near-misses that reveal vulnerability before it becomes loss.
Marine insurance has always followed shipping routes and cargo movements. Hughes says the nature of the risk has changed. 'These events reinforce an important reality: that some of today's most significant exposures do not arise from a single point of failure. They emerge from interdependency,' he says. The focus has shifted from any single vessel, cargo or port to the trade network as a whole. 'The risks shaping marine insurance [are] being increasingly affected by the interconnected systems that support global trade, such as supply chains, transport networks, logistics infrastructure and critical trade corridors,' Hughes says.
Vessels diverted around the Cape of Good Hope from late 2023 to avoid security threats, and transit times increased substantially. What began as a routing decision became a systemic problem. 'What initially appeared to be a routing issue quickly created broader challenges involving inventory shortages, increased freight costs, vessel congestion and downstream supply chain delays,' Hughes says. Cargo was rerouted, delayed and stranded as trade flows shifted. Exposure did not sit still. 'In modern supply chains, exposure often develops between origin and destination,' Hughes adds.
Accumulation risk used to attach to fixed locations: ports, warehouses and storage terminals. Hughes says that assumption has changed. 'The critical question is no longer simply where the asset is, but what it depends on and how disruption could cascade through the wider system,' he says. Concentrations build dynamically now, as cargo is redirected, vessels are delayed or supply chains adapt to disruption on the fly. AXA XL has brought underwriters, claims specialists, risk engineers, brokers and clients closer together in response. 'Understanding interconnected exposures provides more valuable insight than focusing solely on individual insured assets,' Hughes says. Accumulation can form anywhere along the route.
Water shortages have done more than slow ships. 'Water shortages and drought conditions have reduced canal transit capacity, creating delays, rerouting requirements and increased transportation costs. Such an issue would normally have been viewed as an operational concern for shipping companies. Today, its effects extend throughout global supply chains and into inventory strategies, production planning and contractual performance,' Hughes says. Geopolitical events affecting the Strait of Hormuz carry similar reach, with potential to influence global energy markets and broader commercial activity. 'In an increasingly interconnected environment, climate risks, geopolitical events and infrastructure constraints often interact rather than occur independently,' Hughes adds. These pressures are connected, not separate.
Naveed says the absence of a claim can be as instructive as its presence. 'Paid claims show only part of the picture. Some of the most useful insights have arisen from near-miss events where vulnerabilities were exposed but losses were ultimately avoided,' she says. The International Union of Marine Insurance (IUMI) claims database shows incurred cargo losses for 2024 totalled US$677 million, with an average loss of US$1.2 million. During the Red Sea disruption, many cargo interests avoided losses by acting early. 'We often observe that two organisations facing the same disruption experience different outcomes. The differentiator is rarely the event itself, rather the quality of contingency planning, operational visibility, decision-making and preparedness,' Naveed says.
Better data on where cargo sits changes what an insurer can do before something goes wrong. 'Understanding where cargo is moving, where values are accumulating and which trade lanes are under pressure allows insurers to have more meaningful conversations with brokers and their clients,' Hughes says. Real-time visibility shapes pricing too. 'Better visibility supports more informed pricing, stronger accumulation management and improved decision-making before disruption becomes loss,' he adds. The E2 Open Shipping Index shows average transit times from initial booking to clearing the final gate sat at 68 days in both Q2 2023 and Q1 2024, before easing to 58 days by Q1 2025. Prolonged congestion at that scale concentrates exposure across the network.
Supply chains are growing more complex. Geopolitical uncertainty remains high. Naveed points to what preparedness achieves from the claims side: 'From a claims perspective, it reduces the likelihood and severity of loss.' Hughes states the same dynamic from underwriting: 'From an underwriting perspective, resilience improves exposure quality.' His vision for the insurer's role is specific. 'It involves helping clients understand how risk moves through interconnected systems, identifying hidden accumulations and building resilience before disruption occurs. Success will depend upon combining underwriting expertise, claims insights, data analytics and practical risk advisory capabilities,' Hughes says. Further sponsored insurance industry reports covering related themes are available for brokers and risk professionals.
Tom Hughes: head of marine underwriting, AXA XL in Australia; focuses on interconnected trade network exposures and accumulation risk.
Sameen Naveed: senior claims specialist for marine, AXA XL in Australia; analyses near-miss events and preparedness outcomes across cargo disruptions.