The Life Code Compliance Committee (Life CCC) has issued a formal warning to an unnamed life insurer that underpaid about $1.6 million across 66 income protection and death benefit claim, including back interest.
The benefits were calculated incorrectly when the claims were first paid. Most of the affected customers held policies the insurer had taken over from another insurer. The errors continued after the acquisition and were only detected after the insurer strengthened its compliance monitoring. The insurer then self-reported the breach to the committee.
The committee took into account the scale of the underpayments, the insurer’s response and its remediation before deciding a formal warning was the appropriate sanction.
Committee chair Jan McClelland (pictured) said insurers acquiring portfolios could not treat inherited products as someone else’s problem.
“When an insurer takes on a portfolio, it also takes on responsibility for understanding the benefits those policies provide and making sure customers receive them,” said McClelland.
She said the case showed the value of self-reporting combined with independent oversight, and that the insurer had moved quickly to remediate affected customers once the issue was found. She added that people claim at a time of financial or other distress and should receive every benefit they are entitled to when it is due.
The committee published the case without identifying the insurer, to encourage self-reporting and help other insurers learn from it.
The warning adds to a run of sanctions against life insurers this year. In June, the committee warned an insurer over 358 breaches of claims handling commitments, with some customers waiting more than eight months. In September, it warned another insurer over more than 10,000 breaches involving customer notices handled by an outsourced provider, as covered in what 10,000 breaches mean for clients. None of the insurers has been named.
Life insurance has seen repeated portfolio transfers over the past decade, leaving many older policies administered by insurers that did not design them. Legacy income protection contracts can carry benefit features, indexation terms and offset rules that differ from an insurer’s current products. Benefits are more likely to be miscalculated where the new owner’s systems were not built to handle those features.
For risk advisers, the case gives a practical reason to check claim payments on inherited policies against the original policy terms, especially for income protection. Because the insurer is unnamed, advisers cannot tell whether their own clients were among the 66. A client paid on a transferred policy, however, has grounds to ask for the calculation to be checked against the original wording.