ASIC loses Freedom Insurance appeal

The decision clarified how conflicted remuneration laws apply to insurance sales incentives
ASIC loses Freedom Insurance appeal
INSURANCE NEWS
By Josh Recamara
16 Nov 2026

The Full Federal Court has rejected ASIC's attempt to overturn a ruling in favour of a former Freedom Insurance director, although its decision has clarified how conflicted remuneration laws apply to insurance sales incentives.

The appeal concerned Keith Cohen, a former director of the now-deregistered insurer, and incentive programmes operated by the Freedom Group between November 2017 and October 2018.

While the Full Court agreed with ASIC that the incentives constituted conflicted remuneration under the Corporations Act 2001, it upheld the earlier dismissal of proceedings against Cohen.

The distinction is important. A finding that a remuneration arrangement falls within the conflicted remuneration provisions does not, by itself, establish that an individual director was knowingly involved in a contravention or breached their directors' duties.

ASIC had argued that Cohen was knowingly involved in alleged breaches of the remuneration provisions and had failed to meet his obligations as a director.

The regulator's case also originally involved former Freedom Insurance consultant Robert Oayda. However, ASIC withdrew its appeal concerning Oayda by consent on December 19, 2025.

Sales targets and staff rewards

ASIC launched civil penalty proceedings against Cohen and Oayda in October 2021, alleging that incentive arrangements encouraged sales staff to prioritise policy sales over customers' interests.

The programmes included rewards such as trips to Bali for agents who achieved sales targets and a Vespa scooter for top performers.

The regulator argued that the arrangements breached conflicted remuneration provisions designed to prevent financial incentives from improperly influencing financial product advice.

The case had its origins in concerns raised about Freedom Insurance's sales practices during the Financial Services Royal Commission, where the company was examined as part of round six.

The Federal Court dismissed ASIC's claims against both individuals on October 16, 2025. ASIC subsequently lodged its appeal on November 11, with the Full Court hearing the matter on August 26 and 27, 2026.

The latest decision leaves the dismissal of the proceedings against Cohen intact, while establishing that the incentive arrangements fell within the statutory definition of conflicted remuneration.

Implications for insurance distribution

For insurers, licensees and intermediaries, the decision reinforces the need to consider how sales incentives operate and whether they could influence the financial product advice provided to retail clients.

Reward structures tied to sales volumes or targets can create regulatory concerns where they risk putting commercial outcomes ahead of customer interests.

However, the outcome should not be read as establishing automatic personal liability for directors whenever an organisation operates a conflicted remuneration arrangement. The court's decision to uphold the dismissal of the proceedings against Cohen highlights the distinction between the legal character of an incentive arrangement and the evidence required to establish an individual's liability.

The Freedom Group entered external administration in February 2020 and was subsequently deregistered, bringing another chapter of the company's regulatory history to a close.

The case remains relevant to the insurance industry as firms review how staff performance, sales targets and remuneration arrangements are structured and monitored.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB AU.