What happened: REST was ordered to run a pre-mediation registration process in a class action alleging it wrongfully charged inactive members for default income protection insurance
Who's involved: Retail Employees Superannuation Trust (REST) and a class of its inactive fund members
What's at stake: Compensation for insurance premiums deducted from approximately 950,000 inactive accounts, plus lost investment returns
Why it matters: The ruling shows courts will compel registration when a fund cannot even estimate the size of the class from its own records - a warning for trustees running default insurance
Where it stands: Ruled - parties to agree on notice terms; trial listed for October 4, 2027
A superannuation fund with roughly 950,000 inactive accounts cannot tell a court how many of those accounts belong to class members. That problem - an admission REST itself made - has now reshaped how this class action will run.
The Federal Court has ordered REST to conduct a pre-mediation registration process, requiring potential class members to come forward and identify themselves before mediation begins. The ruling, handed down on November 17, 2026, addressed a question that has divided Australian courts over the past four years: when should class members be made to register before a settlement is even on the table?
The underlying class action alleges that REST breached its obligations by continuing to charge inactive members for default income protection insurance - cover that, according to the claim, provided no benefit to members who were not working or already held insurance through another fund. The claim period runs from December 5, 2008, to June 30, 2019.
REST could identify its inactive members from its own records. The number was large: approximately 950,000. But being inactive was only the first criterion. To qualify as a class member, a person also had to fall into one of two categories: either they already held income protection insurance through another super fund, or they were unemployed or not receiving income during their inactive period.
REST told the court it had no way of knowing, from its own records, how many of those 950,000 people fell into either category. It could not estimate the group size. It could not estimate quantum. Without that information, it argued, mediation would be an exercise in guesswork.
The applicant pushed back, pointing to an actuary and a forensic accountant who said they could produce reasonable estimates using publicly available data. But the court gave that evidence little weight. The actuary had been asked for his opinion on October 7, 2026 - the same day he responded. He listed 13 public data sources he might draw on but did not explain what information they contained, what methodology he would use, or how any of it would yield an estimate of the specific member categories in dispute.
The court did not criticise the expert for the gap. He had been given no time. But the absence of any substantiating detail meant the applicant's alternative to registration remained, in the court's words, a bare "statement of confidence" with "complete lack of any substantiating detail."
The applicant also argued that pre-mediation registration rates in superannuation class actions tend to be low, making the exercise misleading. Drawing on data from two prior class actions, the applicant's solicitor said members are far more motivated to register when a settlement is already on the table.
The court was unpersuaded. In the first example cited, no call to register had been issued before settlement - making the comparison meaningless. In the second, the low initial registrations followed a notice that merely encouraged, rather than required, registration. Neither case resembled what REST proposed: a court-ordered process with a clear notice that unregistered members may be shut out of any future settlement.
The court acknowledged that a pre-mediation process would not capture every eligible member. But it found that a firm baseline of participation, combined with allowances for late registrants, would still leave the parties far better positioned than walking into mediation blind. Mediation, the court noted - drawing on the Victorian Court of Appeal's widely cited observation - is supposed to involve "rational bargaining between relatively well-informed parties," not a "game of bluff and bluster" conducted "in ignorance."
The ruling includes a detailed survey of nine contested pre-mediation registration applications decided since the Full Court's 2022 decision in Parkin v Boral Ltd. The pattern that emerges is clear: where a respondent's own records were sufficient to estimate exposure, courts declined registration. Where the group size or participation rate could not be reasonably estimated, courts ordered it. REST's case fell on the extreme end of that spectrum - the fund could not even reach the starting point of knowing its group size.
The court also confirmed that the applicant's opposition, while relevant, was not determinative. And it rejected the suggestion that a registration process amounts to a cynical attempt to minimise group participation, noting that the High Court had recognised that steps promoting a respondent's commercial interests in settlement can simultaneously promote group members' interests.
The parties must now agree on the terms of the registration notice. Under REST's proposal, notices would go out by late January 2027, with a registration deadline of April 23, 2027. The mediation is scheduled to begin by June 18, 2027. Trial is listed for October 4, 2027, with a four-week estimate.
One point remains open: the court questioned whether the settlement window specified in the notice should run all the way to the first day of trial, or close earlier - perhaps one month before trial, or when the mediator formally terminates the mediation. The parties were directed to confer on that issue.
For trustees and insurers still running default insurance arrangements across large member bases, the ruling is a pointed reminder: if your records cannot answer the most basic question a class action will ask - how many people are affected? - a court may order the answer to be found before you reach the negotiating table.