Many more older Australians would cancel private health cover than the government expects, according to a survey commissioned by Members Health Fund Alliance.
The Ipsos survey of more than 2,000 policyholders found 12.1% of over-65s would cancel their cover if the rebate cut proceeds. Members Health says that compares with the government’s estimate of around 1.6%, and that the government has reintroduced its rebate legislation unchanged despite strong opposition from those affected.
Among over-65s who would not cancel, 12.2% said they would downgrade their cover, 8.9% would increase their excess or reduce benefits, and 11.3% would switch insurers in search of lower-cost options. Taken together with the 12.1% who would cancel outright, almost half of over-65s would change their arrangements, Members Health says.
Overall, 53.5% of respondents oppose the cut and 19.4% support it. Among those aged 65 and over, opposition rises to about 81.1%, and more than 40% would blame the federal government for resulting cost increases compared with around 21% blaming insurers.
Read more: Private health insurance reform triggers a cover conversation brokers are missing
Members Health chief executive Matthew Koce said the findings cast doubt on whether the government understood the likely effects on older Australians.
“When more than 80% of Australians aged 65 plus oppose it, Parliament is entitled to ask whether this policy is another one this government have got seriously wrong,” Koce said.
“This will hurt our most vulnerable in the community most likely to need healthcare. We are talking about grandparents who may be forced to give up cover because they can no longer afford it, leaving them more reliant on an already overwhelmed public health system. These are Australians who have done exactly what successive governments have encouraged them to do.”
Koce noted household budgets were already stretched ahead of Christmas and said the rebate cut would make private health insurance more expensive for all Australians.
The bill would remove age-based rebate tiers from April 1, 2027, setting the rebate by income alone. At the base income tier, rebates of 28.139% for ages 65 to 69 and 32.158% for 70 and over would fall to 24.118%.
The Senate voted 38-23 on October 14 to remove the bill from its agenda. Health minister Mark Butler reintroduced it the next day. The government expects to save about $3 billion for aged care, and a spokesperson said the change would make the rebate fairer and total membership would keep rising.
The Greens have set a condition for their support. “We have been clear with the Albanese Labor government for months now, we are happy to work with them to reduce the private health insurance rebate, but we will not punch down on pensioners to do that,” Greens leader David Shoebridge said.
Health department modelling released under freedom of information laws shows about 78,000 over-65s leaving private cover, against the government’s figure of 44,000.
Health funds were expected to lodge 2027 premium applications by mid-November, before the bill’s fate is settled. If it passes, older members would face the rebate cut and the annual premium rise on the same date. Private Healthcare Australia estimates a person aged 70 or over on Gold hospital cover would pay about $807 more a year once both apply.
Read next: Private health device costs leave $1.1 billion savings gap
For brokers advising older clients, the most time-sensitive issue is the April 1, 2027 date at which both the rebate cut and the annual premium rise would take effect simultaneously. That compresses the window for client conversations about whether current cover remains appropriate. Brokers working with over-65 clients should consider raising downgrades, excess options and switching possibilities during the current renewal cycle rather than waiting for the bill’s passage, given that premium applications have already been lodged with the rebate cut in prospect. Clients who have held private health cover through years of government encouragement are the demographic most likely to ask their broker what comes next.