SRG warns rollover renewals miss soft-market savings

Falling market rates do not reach every client automatically, the broker tells CFOs
SRG warns rollover renewals miss soft-market savings
SME
By Rod Bolivar
21 Nov 2026

Specialist Risk Group (SRG) has published a paper that warns Australian businesses which roll over their insurance renewals may see little or no premium reduction while the commercial insurance market falls 10-15%, and urges chief financial officers (CFOs) to start renewals 90 to 120 days before expiry.

Commercial insurance prices across most major lines have fallen since 2024, but SRG said a falling market rate “does not reach every client automatically”.

The broker launched in Australia in February 2026 with a mid-market focus, and it expects the soft market to continue over the next 12 months. It forecasts average cuts of about 11% for commercial property, 9% for public liability and 5% for financial and professional lines.

Actuarial firm Taylor Fry forecast the same reductions for commercial property and public liability in early October, along with a 5% fall for professional indemnity and D&O. For cyber, SRG expects rate reductions to be offset by 4% premium growth.

The fastest-rising line on the bill

In AMP’s Small Business Cost Pressure Index, insurance makes up 5% of a typical small business’s costs, level with electricity and interest. Its cost rose 51.7% between the March quarters of 2020 and 2026.

That rise outpaced fuel (37.6%), interest (36.3%), electricity (26.0%), rent (23.3%), other overheads (22.7%), other financial services (20.8%) and wages (20.3%), which make up half the index. AMP first published the figures on August 4, 2026, and its insurance measure draws on household price data.

Canstar’s survey of more than 2,000 small business owners ranked insurance third among cost pressures, behind energy and fuel. In a 2025 COSBOA and Commonwealth Bank study, about 45% of owners called it a significant pressure.

SRG said insurance often takes a larger share for mid-market firms carrying property, fleet, PI, D&O, cyber and trade credit cover.

SRG said insurance is too often “renewed on autopilot” because renewal comes once a year, often weeks before expiry, and many CFOs treat the premium as fixed. Cutting cover also feels risky, and no comparison site exists for a commercial program.

A longer runway to renewal

The aim, SRG said, is to pay less for the same or better protection. It called trimming limits or dropping covers “a false economy” because one uninsured claim can wipe out years of savings.

Its eight levers range from taking the program to market and checking declared values to improving wordings, calibrating deductibles within an agreed tolerance and asking how the broker is paid.

The paper’s sequence starts with three years of premium by policy, and the broker should approach several insurers, show the client every response and compare quotes on wording, limits and exclusions as well as price.

“In our experience, that is the single change that turns renewal from a formality into a saving,” SRG said of the longer lead time.

SRG is not alone in pushing an early start. Marsh’s 2026 Australian Insurance Market Update says businesses that engage early with insurers can negotiate better renewal terms and premiums.

Rollover clients on the wrong side of the cycle

According to SRG, exposure growth, claims history and program design still decide where a business lands. A straight rollover may therefore bring a small reduction or none.

Marsh’s figures carry the same caution. Pacific commercial insurance rates fell 12% in the third quarter of 2026, the 11th quarterly drop in a row, yet Marsh said significant exposure growth in casualty could still lead to smaller reductions or even premium increases.

Read more: Pacific rates fall 12%, but not every client gets the cut

Cuts also depend on risk. A veteran NSW broker has said reductions are flowing to claims-free commercial property accounts while catastrophe-exposed clients still struggle to buy capacity.

Pricing differs by account size too. Allianz said large-ticket commercial business kept softening while mid-market accounts held on to modest increases, which left its overall commercial renewal rates roughly flat.

Falling premiums also reduce the commission a brokerage earns on each policy, although the median brokerage in the 2026 Top Brokerages ranking for Australia and New Zealand still grew revenue 20.5% in the 12 months to May 31, 2026.

The broking rulebook changes on January 1, 2027. The new Insurance Brokers Code of Practice doubles the minimum renewal notice from 14 days to 28 and lets any client ask what their broker is paid, with the answer given in dollars.

SRG put the soft market down to profitable insurers, plentiful capital, easier reinsurance costs and higher investment returns. It added that “soft markets do not last” and cited the 2019-2023 hard market.

Brokers can list clients with insurance renewals due in the next 90 to 120 days, pull three years of premium by policy and refresh declared values, starting with straight rollovers, accounts with growing exposures or recent claims, catastrophe-exposed property and mid-market programs.

The 28-day notice and dollar disclosure on request apply from January 1, 2027, so renewal conversations can also cover broker pay.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB AU.