Steadfast Group shareholders vote next week on the scheme that would split Australasia’s largest insurance intermediary in two. Dragoneer Investment Group and Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co (KKR) would hold the broking network, and Amwins Group the underwriting agencies.
The commission that runs between those two businesses sits across the join. A network broker placing with a group-owned agency generates two commissions – one to the agent, one to the broker – and both currently land in the same consolidated result. From the scheduled completion date of December 22, they would not. What that does to the commercial terms themselves is not disclosed in the FY26 accounts and Steadfast declined to comment, citing a court ordered media blackout ahead of the shareholder vote on November 27.
Agency commission is the stream whose nature would change at any split. Broker commission does not change character in the same way. An insurer or agency pays a broker for placing business whoever owns either side.
Listen next: Steadfast’s Robert Kelly talks about 50 year career and industry issues
That holds for any placement a network broker makes with a group-owned agency, whether or not it runs through a formal facility. What facilities explain is the scale. On Dr Ian Enright’s account, the agency commission stream is why the model was built out as far as it was. Brokers placing through facilities are the ones with most riding on what the separation does to those arrangements. Sydney based Enright, founding chair of the Australian College of Insurance Studies (ACIS), traces the growth of facilities to that arrangement.
"The business model evolved from aggregating brokers to doing the same with agents of insurers," Enright said. "The model then combined those two models."
One piece of business can then produce three income streams, he said: a fee to the broker from the customer, and commissions from the insurer to both the broker and the agent.
"The last of these was traditionally much higher than the broker commission and that fact stimulated the development and growth of facilities," said Enright.
A facility is an arrangement under which insurers commit capacity to write classes of risk in advance, and the broker builds a placement offering around that capacity for a sector or client group. The United Kingdom’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) used that definition in the final report of its wholesale insurance broker market study in February 2019.
Inside a network the arrangement is layered. An underwriting agency holds authority delegated by an insurer to quote, bind and set wording within agreed limits, and Steadfast’s FY26 results presentation describes its agencies as designing specialised products for brokers inside and outside its network. A network broker quoting one of those products is not approaching an insurer and negotiating terms risk by risk. The terms already exist, the agency holds the pen, and the broker is placing with a manufacturer the group also owns.
No equivalent Australian data on facility economics has been published. Australian network distribution and the London wholesale market are not the same business, but the FCA produced the only detailed public numbers on what facilities pay. Remuneration rates on like-for-like policies were between 4 and 6 per cent higher through facilities than in the open market in 2016, and insurers put the additional commission at between 2.5 and 7.5 per cent. Facilities then accounted for about 8 per cent of London market gross written premium.
Steadfast holds equity in 20 underwriting agencies. They wrote $2.5 billion of gross written premium in the 2026 financial year and generated $260.8 million of underlying earnings before interest, tax and amortisation on net revenue of $519.5 million, according to the Steadfast FY26 results presentation lodged with the ASX in August. The same presentation records wholesale broker and agency commission expense paid to brokers of $296.5 million.
On the face of the accounts, that expense line is the one that crosses the new ownership boundary – though the presentation does not separate how much of it moved between the group’s own agencies and its own network brokers, which is the figure that would show what the split actually changes. Nor do the accounts show how those rates are set, or whether any distribution terms between the two businesses survive completion.
The presentation has a second gap of the same kind. It breaks the Australian network’s premium down by insurer – QBE took 14 per cent, CGU 13 per cent, and Allianz and Vero 10 per cent each – with a further 44 per cent sitting in one category covering various underwriting agencies, small insurers, Lloyd’s and other small brokers. It does not separate how much of that went to the group’s own agencies, the figure that would show how much network business they carry.
Steadfast’s 2025 results presentations state that all of its agencies are available to the entire intermediated market and none are exclusive to network brokers. The group also points to fixed commission rates on the Steadfast Client Trading Platform, the same for every insurer on it, although that platform is a quote comparison marketplace rather than a facility.
Enright nominated three developments. The first is whether the separated businesses become more or less profitable under new owners. The second is operational.
"Secondly, a facility is a complex business to operate - keeping different operations etc for each part of the facility. How will the split affect those operational matters?" he said.
The third goes to the conflict itself. "Thirdly, the structural potential for conflicts which might have the potential to be against a customer’s best interests will be negated, but what is the practical effect for customers of that?" said Enright.
Mike Abdallah, who retired in September 2026 as chief underwriting officer for Australia and the Asia Pacific at Liberty, warned that facilities had spread well beyond the SME market and that the model moves the client relationship away from the insurer.
Read next: American giants Amwins and Dragoneer circle Steadfast in $7.7 billion carve-up bid
"I am not a fan of these facilities generally, because you are less connected with the direct client and it is difficult to build a strong value proposition, which in turn means that you are more in the hands of the intermediary," he said.
His test was what happens when the market turns. "If the market turns abruptly for an unforeseen reason, how do we as an industry go back to our clients and say sorry, we’re following the market down and prices are going to have huge increases again."