Credit rating agency AM Best expects New Zealand’s insurance sector to see further mergers and acquisitions over the next decade as softer pricing, rising regulatory costs and the growing strategic value of distribution networks reshape the competitive landscape.
Credit rating agency AM Best expects the recent pace of dealmaking to continue in both domestic and international markets, senior director of analytics Victoria Ohorodnyk told an insurance market briefing in Auckland on Thursday.
The forecast follows several significant transactions involving New Zealand insurers, including Japanese insurer Daiichi Life Group's agreement in September to acquire Fidelity Life for approximately NZ$630 million through its subsidiary Partners Group Holdings, which already owns Partners Life.
The deal, expected to close between March and July 2027 subject to regulatory approval, will bring two established life insurers under common ownership. Daiichi's acquisition announcement identified Fidelity Life's adviser relationships and distribution networks as part of the transaction's strategic value.
In general insurance, Allianz Partners completed its acquisition of nib's Australian and New Zealand travel insurance businesses in September. The transaction included existing distribution arrangements, while nib retained a long-term agreement to distribute its branded travel insurance products.
Both transactions illustrate how insurance acquisitions can extend beyond underwriting portfolios to include established distribution channels and intermediary relationships.
The expected continuation of M&A comes as competition is already putting pressure on New Zealand insurers. In its September market update, Gallagher estimated that NZI and Vero together account for approximately 50% to 60% of the intermediated insurance market.
The brokerage also noted that both insurers reported weaker profitability in their latest financial results, reflecting softer market conditions and higher natural hazard claims. NZI's gross written premiums fell 11% in the 2026 financial year, equivalent to approximately NZ$200 million.
The figures highlight the pressure on established insurers to maintain profitability as competition increases, although AM Best has not directly linked these conditions to its forecast for further acquisitions.
In its latest non-life insurance assessment, AM Best maintained a stable outlook for the sector, noting that most insurers had recorded stable or declining premiums amid abundant reinsurance capacity and relatively favourable catastrophe conditions.
“High capacity, a benign catastrophe environment, and favourable reinsurance conditions have collectively boosted insurers’ risk appetites and fuelled market competition,” the agency said.
The Reserve Bank of New Zealand's November Financial Stability Report similarly found that commercial insurance premiums had softened as competition and international insurer participation increased.
However, pricing conditions remain uneven. Insurers are increasingly assessing natural hazard exposure at the individual-property level, meaning greater competition does not necessarily translate into cheaper or more readily available cover for higher-risk properties.
AM Best expects global reinsurance capacity to remain ample over the 12 months from September 2026, supporting continued competition despite softer reinsurance pricing. New Zealand remains heavily dependent on international reinsurers because of its relatively small market and significant exposure to natural catastrophes.
Life insurers face different pressures, with subdued premium growth and elevated health insurance claims costs. Nevertheless, AM Best expects profitability to remain broadly stable as earlier premium increases and other corrective measures begin to improve results.
Regulatory changes are also expected to add costs across the industry. By 15 November 2027, the Contracts of Insurance Act 2024 will introduce new disclosure requirements and obligations affecting insurers and intermediaries.
The Financial Markets Authority has confirmed that intermediaries will face specific duties relating to information passed between policyholders and insurers, alongside expanded regulatory oversight.
Insurers will also need to review existing practices and systems to comply with the legislation.
AM Best financial analyst Chee Yun described the reforms as “operationally intensive” for some insurers, but the agency expects them to strengthen market resilience over the longer term.