Legal action against Air New Zealand over allegedly misleading passengers about their compensation rights has brought renewed attention to the relationship between airline reimbursement obligations and travel insurance, particularly when disrupted flights leave travellers facing additional expenses.
The Commerce Commission announced on Thursday that it would file charges against the airline under the Fair Trading Act, alleging it provided incorrect information about compensation for delays and cancellations within its control.
The case highlights a distinction that can affect travel insurance claims: some expenses arising from flight disruptions are legally recoverable from airlines, while others may fall under a traveller's insurance policy, depending on the cause of the disruption and the cover purchased.
Under New Zealand's Civil Aviation Act 2023, airlines are liable for reasonable losses caused by domestic flight disruptions within their control, including mechanical failures, crew sickness and operational problems. Reimbursement can cover meals, accommodation and alternative transport, up to the lesser of the proven loss or 10 times the ticket price.
Meanwhile, travel insurance may provide cover where airline compensation is unavailable, including disruptions caused by severe weather, subject to policy terms and exclusions. It may also respond to other eligible losses that airline reimbursement does not fully address.
The distinction matters when assessing claims, as passengers may need to establish the cause of a disruption, what compensation the airline has offered and whether any remaining expenses are covered by their policy. Insurers may also have rights to recover payments from responsible third parties, depending on the circumstances and policy provisions.
The commission alleges that Air New Zealand made statements suggesting compensation was capped below statutory limits and that certain expenses were ineligible for reimbursement. It believes the conduct may have occurred since January 2024.
“In our view, Air New Zealand made statements that led some passengers to incorrectly assume they weren’t entitled to compensation, and rejected legitimate reimbursement claims. Ultimately, we believe passengers missed out on money they were entitled to under the law,” commission deputy chair Anne Callinan said.
Consumer NZ chief executive Jon Duffy said passengers were particularly vulnerable because airlines were not required to proactively explain their compensation rights following disruptions.
"Because [in New Zealand] there's no mandatory requirement for airlines to disclose passengers rights to them when a disruption occurs there's ample opportunity for airlines to either mislead, sow confusion or omit to tell people what their rights are," Duffy told Checkpoint. He also called for stronger disclosure requirements, saying the government already had powers to require airlines to provide clearer information.
"New Zealand is actually an outlier in not doing this."
The issue extends beyond domestic travel. International passengers have separate protections under the Montreal Convention, which allows recovery of certain losses arising from delays, subject to liability limits and available defences.
New Zealand's Consumer Protection guidance advises passengers to seek reimbursement from airlines where appropriate and retain receipts, booking confirmations and communications. These records can also help establish eligibility under travel insurance policies, which generally do not allow travellers to recover the same loss twice.
The proceedings follow a similar enforcement case involving Jetstar, which was fined $2.25 million in 2025 for misleading passengers about their compensation rights. The airline also paid more than $1 million in compensation to thousands of affected customers following regulatory action.
Air New Zealand said it was disappointed by the decision to pursue court proceedings and maintained that it had cooperated with the investigation in good faith.
The airline said a voluntary review of more than 62,000 claims involving disruptions within its control identified errors in fewer than 1% of cases. It said affected customers had been contacted and the mistakes corrected, while internal guidance and staff training had been strengthened.
The allegations have yet to be determined by the court.