Almost three-quarters (72%) of home and motor insurance customers are concerned about identity fraud, according to research from Ageas UK, and 58% said experiencing identity theft would affect their mental health “a lot” or “a great deal”.
The YouGov survey of more than 2,000 UK home and motor insurance customers, published for Fraud Awareness Week, found wide concern about fraud but gaps in understanding how it works and what it costs.
Almost all respondents (96%) agree insurance fraud is a crime, and 87% recognise it makes insurance more expensive for everyone. But 80% said they know little or nothing about the legal consequences of committing it. More than half (57%) said greater awareness of those consequences would make them less likely to commit fraud.
“What this research shows is a mismatch between concern and understanding,” said Tom Quirke, chief underwriting officer at Ageas.
Quirke said insurers, brokers and industry bodies had a clear responsibility to make fraud easier to understand and to give people practical help to protect themselves.
Awareness of ghost broking, where fraudsters sell fake insurance policies while posing as legitimate providers, has risen from 18% to 27% in a year. But more than half (52%) of respondents still said they don’t know enough about it, making it the area where consumers feel least informed.
Ageas’s advice to consumers includes buying only from authorised insurers and brokers, which can be checked on the FCA firm checker, and being wary of high-pressure sales tactics and deals that seem too good to be true. It also advises protecting personal and financial details, including not letting a third party photograph a driving licence at the scene of an accident, and using verified insurer contact details rather than sponsored search results when making a claim.
Ageas said it uses advanced analytics, AI and specialist fraud detection tools across the customer journey, from quote to claim. These include voice-based risk assessment, document validation, predictive fraud models and real-time fraud database checks. It also uses predictive AI to detect quote manipulation.
The industry is detecting more costly fraud. Insurers detected 93,900 fraudulent claims worth £1.34 billion in 2025, according to the Association of British Insurers. While case numbers fell 2.7%, total value rose 14%, and motor fraud accounted for 55% of detected cases. Zurich said this month it had detected a record £109.3 million of fraud in the past year, with ghost broking among the growing threats.
For brokers, ghost broking is a direct reputational threat. Fraudsters who pose as intermediaries undermine trust in legitimate brokers, and customers who buy fake policies may be left driving uninsured without knowing it.
Brokers can help by making their FCA authorisation easy to verify, and by reminding customers, particularly younger drivers looking for cheaper motor cover, how to spot fake providers. With 57% saying awareness of consequences would deter them from fraud, clear communication about disclosure and honest claims also has a role in reducing fraud at source.