What happened: Thirty South African call centre workers are suing a UK vehicle insurance broker in England, alleging it controlled their employer, cut their pay, then wound up the company after they filed grievances.
Who's involved: Business Insurance Solutions Limited, a UK motor insurance broker, and its founding director.
What's at stake: Damages for lost remuneration and alleged conspiracy - quantum not yet determined.
Why it matters: The ruling tests how far a UK broker's control over an offshore appointed representative can expose it to liability for that entity's workforce.
Where it stands: Jurisdiction confirmed in England; the merits have not been tried.
Told the legal papers were on their way, the founding director of a UK vehicle insurance broker replied by email that he "hadn't been reading enough fiction lately" and was "looking forward to it."
The High Court in London was less entertained. In a ruling handed down on November 19, 2026, the court dismissed jurisdiction challenges brought by Business Insurance Solutions Limited (BISL) and the company’s founding director, keeping in England a damages claim brought by 30 former call centre workers from South Africa.
The case turns on who really controlled a South African company called ConnectAQuote (CAQ) and what happened to its workers when things went wrong.
BISL is a Guildford-headquartered broker serving the UK motor insurance market. In August 2022 it signed a contract – a Terms of Business Agreement, or TOBA - appointing CAQ to handle certain regulated insurance distribution services from a call centre in Cape Town. The deal worked on what the defendants called a “cost-plus funding arrangement”: if CAQ’s outgoings rose, BISL’s payments rose to match. The TOBA stated that no employment relationship existed between BISL and CAQ’s staff.
The workers say the reality was different. They allege CAQ was set up specifically to give BISL a call centre in South Africa “where labour costs would be more affordable and the regulatory regime more lenient,” according to the judgment, and that BISL effectively took over responsibility for CAQ’s payroll.
The company’s founding director is described in the judgment as an entrepreneur who has founded, invested in, and operated several specialist insurance brokers. He is the beneficial owner of BISL through a Jersey trust structure and was also a founding director of CAQ. He was not a director of either company at the time of the events that followed.
From early 2023, according to the judgment, BISL raised concerns about CAQ’s performance and asked the company to cut costs. CAQ responded by changing its employees’ bonus structures.
On May 20, 2023, 36 CAQ employees filed a grievance with South Africa’s conciliation and arbitration commission over changes to their commission payments. Two days later, a BISL director put CAQ on notice that BISL was considering ending the TOBA. By May 26, BISL gave 30 days’ notice to terminate.
The workers allege that timing was no coincidence. One of the claims brought in the High Court is for conspiracy, alleging the TOBA was terminated “with the predominant intention to retaliate” against the workers for their grievance proceedings.
Between June 19 and 23, 2023, claims on behalf of 32 CAQ employees were issued in the Cape Town Labour Court. The Labour Court ordered that funds could not be removed and that bonuses must be paid. That order was complied with.
Six days later, CAQ’s managing director told staff the TOBA had been terminated, that CAQ had no other business, and that the company would stop trading at midnight on June 29, 2023. CAQ entered voluntary liquidation on July 1, 2023.
Here is the detail the workers say reveals the pattern. After CAQ was wound up, the claimants allege that BISL “re-engaged all of the CAQ staff who had not pursued labour court claims through another London based company within the BISL group.” The workers who had filed grievances were left behind.
The 30 claimants issued proceedings in London against BISL and its founding director. Their claims include causing loss by unlawful means, conspiracy to injure, and negligence in handling the payroll function that BISL had taken on under the TOBA.
None of these allegations have been tested in court. The defendants have not conceded any of the claims, and no court has ruled on the merits.
The jurisdiction fight that followed was itself a saga. BISL is registered in England, but the founding director lives abroad. A BISL director told the workers’ solicitors that the founding director “has homes in several countries, many of which are off grid with limited postal services” and “rarely spends much time in any single one.” The judgment records that he was described as leading “a semi-nomadic lifestyle.”
The workers’ solicitors eventually obtained permission to serve him by email at his family office address - the same address from which he had sent the “fiction” quip.
Both defendants argued the case should be heard in South Africa. They offered to submit to the Western Cape High Court and said the dispute was really a South African employment matter. The workers said the case was about control exercised from England by an English company and its beneficial owner.
The court accepted expert evidence from a former judge of South Africa’s Constitutional Court that the Western Cape High Court could not simply take the case just because the dispute had a connection to South Africa. Under South African law as it currently stands, the court would need either submission by the defendants, service while they were physically in the country, or attachable assets there. None of those conditions existed when the founding director was served.
Even treating South Africa as available for both defendants, the court found England was “clearly and distinctly the appropriate forum.” The key documents and decision-making sat with BISL in England. The workers’ own legal team had identified 11 likely defence witnesses, 10 of whom live in England. The allegations centred on control exercised from England, not on the South African employment contracts themselves.
As a fallback, the court also found a real risk that the workers would not get a fair hearing in South Africa. An experienced South African lawyer – who had acted for many of the workers in the earlier Labour Court proceedings – gave evidence that no firm would take the case on a no-win-no-fee basis because, even if the workers won, enforcing a judgment against defendants with no South African assets or presence would be “practically futile.”
The founding director separately argued that the workers’ lawyers had failed to properly inform the court when applying to serve him abroad. That challenge also failed.
The claims will now proceed in England.
For brokers running operations through offshore partners or appointed representatives, the ruling is a reminder that a contract clause disclaiming any employment relationship may not be the last word especially if the broker effectively controls the payroll.