In our latest Leaders Network Transformation Roundtable, four insurance leaders speak out on invisible efficiency, in-house talent and how the regulatory pace is impacting the sector. Experts from Blagrove Underwriting Agency, CFC, Hotspot Cover and Pacific Life Re examine whether digital transformation reaches policyholders and brokers, in-house talent versus consultants, board funding and prioritisation, and how AI and data regulation slow delivery.
00:00 - Dan Keeler: we don't want to be reliant on that outside help. We want to make sure that we've got it in house and we keep it in house.
00:06 - George Dagnall: Any unproven tech cannot be deployed.
00:09 - Leigh Moore: The age of multi-year monolith programs for transformation is probably ebbing away.
00:13 - Paul Waring: The biggest challenge is that technology is changing very fast and regulation is not changing as fast.
00:20 - Paul Lucas: Hello everyone and welcome to our second Leaders Network round table on digital transformation. Now in our last session available now at Insurance Business TV we looked at where transformation is real versus PowerPoint and which function is moving fastest. Well this edition presses a little further toward budget reality, talent and whether any of it is reaching the end customer. And to take us on a walk down that digital highway we welcome back Paul Waring, Director Information Technology and Chief Security Officer at Blagrove Underwriting Agency, George Dagnall, Non-Executive Director at Hotspot Cover and Director of Insurance and Partnerships at Concentrix. And for the first time we welcome Leigh Moore, Transformation Delivery Lead Back Office at Pacific Life Re and Dan Keeler, Head of Digital Underwriting at CFC. Let's welcome everyone and of course now that the initial transformation pushes have time to bed in across most companies I'd love to know is it visibly improving outcomes for policy holders and brokers or is the benefit still mostly internal efficiency? George I know you're perhaps your company works in a slightly different way but tell us what you're seeing.
01:30 - George Dagnall: Sure thanks Paul. Yes I guess from our perspective we're definitely seeing transformation on the front end so anything where clients and shorts are taking up placements online that's becoming more efficient but from our world within assistance response of kidnap and ransom or accident and health technology for us cannot substitute at all. You know it has to be the human intervention so even if we have automated platforms today um if have friction, if they have stress, then, you know, trying to fill out a sheet on when you're having a security instant is just not going to be um, the one that's going to help them at the end of the day. So, I guess from our perspective transformation is going to be invisible to the insured. It's something that we do in the back end, you know, like live threat tracking, geo like geo tracking and anything where duty of care might be might be important. So, um, I guess ultimately brokers, um, insurers are going to see slicker digital portals, um, but policy holders still experience the delays the same way they would do normally. So, for us, um, it's an it's an invisible uh, efficiency um, from an assistance perspective, but yeah, we are seeing some form of transformation on the front end.
02:48 - Paul Lucas: Yeah, and Paul, I imagine for you it's kind of a similar situation because you're not dealing directly with the policy holders.
02:54 - Paul Waring: Yeah, that's right. So, we only deal with brokers really apart from on the claims side. Um, so most of our efficiency changes are seen internally uh, rather than externally. So, any benefit to policy holders and brokers would be predominantly indirect. If we're getting better at or faster at handling claims, that's good for them, but they wouldn't necessarily notice that um, in the same way that our internal team were. So, most of our work is around claims, um, getting better data analysis, getting more granular data, um, and basically being able to handle claims a bit more efficiently and um, in a bit more depth as our as our business continues to grow. But yeah, so brokers and policy holders don't tend to log into our system very much, um, even though they can do. Um, it's predominantly internal. So, they wouldn't notice most of the changes we make. Most claims related communication is still done over the phone or via email rather than on a platform.
03:54 - Paul Lucas: A little bit of a different situation for you though, I imagine, Dan. I imagine it's much more front facing for you.
04:00 - Dan Keeler: Here it is with a predominantly SME book that we that we manage here at CFC. A lot of our uh a lot of our transformation is split between a benefit of internal efficiency and then really broker because we mainly do B2B. Um a lot of broker uh benefit as well. So we try and split our that's where we try and split our ROI. Um whether it's digital trading, whether it's agentic underwriting, um anything that we do is relatively front uh sort of front office transformation that we're really trying to push for at the moment. So we've seen that sort of split benefit and we're trying to sort of amass the benefit and put it all together as one. What we're seeing is that we're seeing that internal efficiency is important and it continues to be really important for us, especially as an underwriter heavy business, MGA. Um but then also we are super focused on whether that benefit flows down into the broker channel as well. And then hopefully we were talking about policy holders, hopefully then that benefit does filter down to our policy holders as well in speed of service and the accuracy of the uh sort of terms that we're putting out straight away first time every time. Um that 's where we've been targeting our benefit mainly.
05:10 - Paul Lucas: And same question for you as well, Leigh, but also want to pick up on Dan's point a little bit. Do you think that efficiency is the end game here?
05:17 - Leigh Moore: No, I think it's obviously an important enabler. Um we're constantly try striving to improve those internal processes to uh to add more value internally, but ultimately that that that extends to that external value, whether it's B2B or B2C. Um the that better decisions, faster decisions, um a better customer experience, whether that's again as I say a business customer or a direct customer in in say general insurance.
05:45 - Paul Lucas: Okay. Well, let's talk a little bit about how you're resourcing all of this transformation as well internally. Is that hiring specialist talent? Is it retraining existing underwriters and claims staff? Is it just leaning on external consultants and and vendors? Uh Paul, what's your approach?
05:59 - Paul Waring: So everything we do pretty much is internal um because we have our own core platform which does our claims, our underwriting, accounts, everything. Um and all of that is developed by internal people who work for us directly. Um we've actually hired um extra people for that team fairly recently because of that. Um and as a result it's all internal resource. There's no like external consultants really. Very occasionally we might ask for some uh specific expertise, but nearly everything is done in house internally. Um so we can drive the pace of that um and whatever suits us and we can change direction if we need to um rather than being reliant on third party vendors or consultants or whoever who might not have the same time frames as we do.
06:51 - Paul Lucas: Okay. And then with Dan at CFC obviously a bit of a giant on a global scale. Does that Does that mean that you kind of have to look elsewhere or is it all in-house hiring for you as well?
07:02 - Dan Keeler: I think we're in a very lucky position similar to Paul that a lot of our technology is proprietary and in-house IP. Um and that's been the same way for many years since CFC was founded and very relevant for me in digital underwriting as well that our digital platforms are all in-house. Um we've continued on that track and that one of our key sort of drivers behind our technology and our transformation is our in-house teams, our in-house engineering teams, our in-house transformation team. And just recently one of the biggest things that we've had to sort of change tack on and bring in um when we say like hiring specialist talent is actually people to help us execute. Because as a growing business like you say Paul we're growing we're like globally growing as well and we still want it to be that core central IP and that core central technology that we want to use at CFC um and we want to develop that and we're going through an evolution of that now. The main people that we've had to bring in are people that help us execute. So that's the change and the transformation people that can really help us help us deliver on what we want to do. And then time to time we have dipped in and had consultants come in um for a very brief moment, but just to Paul's point there, we don't want reliant on that outside help. We want to make sure that we've got it in house and we keep it in house.
08:22 - Paul Lucas: Yeah, and Leigh just again to pick up on that point. I imagine when you do have to con turn to consultants, there's got to be a sort of a real blend with the internal team as well, has there?
08:32 - Leigh Moore: Absolutely. We don't want to be baking independency to our transformations. We want to be uh bringing in the people with the knowledge and the expertise when necessary, but making sure that when they roll off that the uh the skills and the necessary expertise to run the thing or to maintain the thing exists within the organization. So uh that that's a really important balance for us to keep.
08:58 - Paul Lucas: Okay. So picking up on that blend idea, George, I mean, how do you make sure that everything is understood across the board?
09:05 - George Dagnall: Yes, I guess to us given the fact that we work across quite a few different areas and support many markets to do so um uh what we like to call a cross-functional bridge from India to internal understanding, which is obviously always important in any business um knowing what one team does and another team does is super critical to the wider organization. But I mean from uh a Hotspot cover perspective or um it reminds me that they had internal um development. So individuals who came from a historic insurance background ended up becoming uh fully AI now um uh not themselves, but across the business building AI platforms to uh enhance and make things more efficient. So I completely agree with the internal sort of resource resourcing if possible. But as um somebody mentioned just then on uh looking wider afield to third-party providers sometimes having external consultants in just to kind of give you a view on things is always important as well.
10:01 - Paul Lucas: Yeah. Okay. Well, that's that the sort of the hiring approach and um yeah, this this sort of the general overview, but budgets of course have to have play a big role in this as well and they're under continued pressure, I think, across the board. So I'd love to know how much genuine appetite is there from board or leadership at all of your companies to keep funding transformation at the pace that I guess the market is expecting. Um Dan is it top of mind for you?
10:26 - Dan Keeler: Certainly top of mind at the moment in budget season. Um but for us um I think one thing we want to do is focus our investment in what we're in our transformation portfolio. Um just recently we've looked at our entire change stack um which was quite disparate across CFC. Um and you can see how the appetite could be constrained there because it was a huge pile of 250 270 different initiatives that we were up to I believe. And what we've done very recently um that has gained a lot of appetite for investment is focus that focus that attention on what the sort of key priorities are for the business and having them tied a lot more closely to the board strategy and the exco strategy. Since then we've just seen ever growing appetite for investment in our transformation. So we're in a very lucky situation as we are coming into our budget season where we feel confident that we can put pretty hefty numbers behind the sort of advancements whether they're technological, whether they're operational, whether they're risk and compliance. Um we can be pretty punchy with those numbers because we know we've got the board's appetite there. So pretty good from where we are.
11:31 - Paul Lucas: Okay. Yeah that prioritization element that's vital isn't it Leigh?
11:36 - Leigh Moore: Absolutely. You've got to make sure that you're delivering value for the for the investment um and that that value is measurable uh rather than just uh tasks ticked off on a list that you are actually demonstrating the value that that we're delivering and to do that I think the time and the age of multi-year monolith programs for transformation is probably ebbing away and what we've got now is more of an iterative approach where we can demonstrate that value a lot sooner to the stakeholders, to the business, to the customers uh then gain that confidence that further investment is warranted.
12:20 - Paul Lucas: Yeah. And Josh, just talk us talk us a little bit more about prioritization if you don't mind. How do you go about prioritizing?
12:28 - George Dagnall: I guess um I guess there's a there's a there's a continual cycle of reassessment um as particularly in the assistance world of the dial on what's most important or what's um presenting as the highest threat or risk changes every day. So we always have to look at our um spectrum of clients um and ensure where the world is moving to work out what is a priority. So exactly um that was just said about the multi-year transformation um those are completely dead in the water. It's always for us more of a six month transformation piece and constantly reassessing to make sure that ROI the ROI for us being you know the human element, the safety element is in place. Um so I guess from a prioritization speculative features kind of go out the window for us. Um there's a lot of build sometimes to help things but sometimes there's a lot of shall I say the fluff on things that aren't really needed. So we try and cut things down to what isn't what we need um and we really interrogate that need at all times. So what might go into us is threat intelligence feeds, cross border regulation, data handling, anything that's really going to drive um uh support and value um uh from a from a rigid perspective as opposed to speculation. So yeah um we've got the budget there, we've got the appetite but it's about maintaining the pace in line with the world uh the way in which the world is holding the pace at the moment.
13:56 - Paul Lucas: And just to loop back on that sort of budgeting appetite question if I can Paul. I mean you're on the board of your firm so you must be driving that appetite.
14:04 - Paul Waring: Yeah, I think the whole board understands that this kind of investment is necessary um both for benefit to the business and so we don't fall too far and we don't fall behind. Um things like the claims this claim side in particular for us um getting extra data, getting more granular data. Um, we've promoted some people, we've hired extra people. We've got training budgets and everything. So the money is there and it's very much there's a very strong appetite to keep working on this um, for, you know, 12 months and beyond.
14:35 - Paul Lucas: Just like at a concert they always save the biggest songs till last. Well, I thought we'd finish on a high and let's talk about that most interesting of issues, regulation. Uh, whisper it quietly, but there are of course regulatory expectations around data, AI, governance, operational resilience. They do keep evolving as well. Leigh, from your perspective, is that accelerating transformation or is it slowing it down as firms start to prioritize compliance first?
15:02 - Leigh Moore: I think it's a case of both, Paul. It's where the regulation and maybe the technology's established and more mature, then it's well understood um, and it's not hindering delivery too badly. Uh, but when you when you look at new technologies and new concepts such as AI where the regulation's really struggling to keep up with the pace of development and innovation, um, that does become a barrier, a blocker to a degree whilst you work out the potential impacts and risks associated with that. But all in all, you know, it's governance by design rather than retrofitting it is sort of the byword. But um, you know, there's only so much you can do in such a fast-moving market.
15:54 - Paul Lucas: Yeah, it is fast-moving market of course, George, and that makes it vital to pay attention to regulation, doesn't it?
16:01 - George Dagnall: Yes, yeah, definitely. I mean, exactly as the way in which the world is moving, regulation is constantly changing. Um, different regimes, different countries are always changing what they want even from a medical standpoint, from a visa standpoint. So for us we always have to keep up to date and we are always have to make sure that we got the latest amount of information, but equally there's a lot of technology out these days from third-party providers. So, um for us, it's about making sure that if you're having a risk-tracking tool um and it and it cannot prove 99.9% then it you can't really deploy it, right? Because it is that point of a percent that that cannot be um given to an insurer or a broker at all. Um so it's kind of up to us to stay ahead of regulation at the forefront, I think as I mentioned earlier. So, any unproven tech cannot be deployed. Um anything from tracking medical to data security threats or um GDPR, um it always needs to be reassessed. So, I think it slows us down definitely, but it's only as uh I think we're going as fast as we can as much as everyone else uh probably in the market, but it's naturally going to make us slow. Yeah. And I think that it's important not to take shortcuts.
17:11 - Paul Lucas: Well, let's just expand on those complications if we can, Paul, because, you know, to the point that both of the gents have made so far, some of these governance rules, they're not fully bedded in yet, are they? So, what impact does that have?
17:24 - Paul Waring: Yeah, I mean, we kind of almost don't know what's going to happen. We kind of have some guidelines, if you like, from people like the FCA and the ICO. Um so you've got to always keep quite an open mind when you're doing transformation and think about do we have the flexibility to change course if a regulation suddenly becomes actual law as opposed to a proposal? So, you 've got to keep your eye on all those things that are changing and being consulted on, knowing that some of them may or may not come into force. They may come in in a different way to what you expected. So, you always got to have the flexibility ready so you can change course. And that does constrain the pace. And I think the biggest challenge is that technology is changing very fast and regulation is not changing as fast. And you're in the middle and you're trying to sort of balance both of those. You want to keep up to date, but you can't always go as fast as you want because of you know, you've got to wait for the regulation to catch up. So, keeping that balance is the real the real big challenge, I think, for a lot of people.
18:25 - Paul Lucas: Yeah, that's one of the challenges, perhaps down another, is perhaps building a team that can handle those compliance regulations.
18:32 - Dan Keeler: Yeah, for sure. And especially we're going through a big global transformation as well and a global expansion. I'm going to stay with the with the theme as well. I'm not going to lie and say that it isn't slowing us down. Um it for sure is slowing us down. The um the sheer amount of regulation, the speed and pace of it. And the reality for CFC as well is we're part of our sort of organizational evolution where we are building this muscle for the first time. It's part of our it's part of our growth um let's call them growing pains for CFC and that's just what we've what we've got to face. The really the really good thing about it and the way that we're viewing it now, if I think about even our change stack and our transformation stack, is that risk and compliance is part of that. So, it doesn't it isn't seen as a dual track. Here's your transformation or your business outcomes that we're going to be measuring and getting ROI and then risk and compliance separate. It's all seen as one. And I think now we've done that and we've doubled down with our new risk team um and embedded our compliance team fully into that transformation. That helps us out massively because as somebody who runs a trading team, we want to be fully aware of what that means, like what that what the outcomes are going to be for us because eventually it's all going to protect us, right? The stuff that we're doing in this sort of risk and compliance and uh regulatory governance transformation that we're going through, it is protecting us as a business. And for us, I think now we've embedded it like I say within our transformation portfolio, that helps us no end.
20:04 - Paul Lucas: Sure everybody listening feels better protected now they've heard all of your thoughts as well. It's been fantastic to have you all with us. Uh remember this group will be back again and will indeed continue to grow just like that regulation. Uh they'll be back in a month's time, so keep it right here on Insurance Business TV.