The Association of British Insurers (ABI) has published new guidance on cash settlements for home insurance claims, arriving at a moment of intensifying parliamentary and regulatory pressure on an industry that critics say has been too slow to improve how it handles major property claims.
The package includes updated voluntary best practice guidance for insurers and a new consumer guide explaining the options available after significant property damage - both developed with ABI members in direct response to instructions from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
The timing is significant. In October 2026, a House of Lords cross-party committee published a report concluding that the FCA must move faster to improve consumer understanding of home and travel insurance and tackle poor claims handling. The Financial Services Regulation Committee found that the FCA’s Consumer Duty had not yet led to better outcomes for consumers, and cited FCA data showing that home insurance claims acceptance rates in 2025 ranged from just 62% to 71% - compared with 99% for motor insurance. The committee said the FCA should set out clearly how it intends to address poor claims handling practices, including cash settlements and outsourced claims management.
That backdrop gives this guidance considerably more weight than its voluntary status might suggest.
Read more: Lords tell FCA to move faster on home and travel insurance
The guidance is described as voluntary, but that framing requires some qualification. It was developed in direct response to the FCA’s General Insurance Retail Roadmap, published in July 2025, which found poor oversight and monitoring of cash settlements at some firms, a failure to consider customer vulnerability, and evidence that some insurers had promoted cash settlements without ensuring good customer outcomes. Which? followed that in September 2025 with a super-complaint warning that some firms appeared to be offering cash settlements primarily to contain their own costs rather than act in customers’ best interests - and that settlement figures sometimes reflected discounted rates from insurers’ own supplier networks unavailable to customers in the open market.
The FCA’s December 2025 response to that super-complaint explicitly named cash settlements as a supervisory priority for 2026 and confirmed its support for the ABI’s work in this area. Firms that deviate from guidance developed under those circumstances face meaningful scrutiny under Consumer Duty outcome requirements - the regulator has already invited one firm to sign a voluntary requirement restricting its business following the home and travel claims review.
In that context, “voluntary” may be better understood as “not yet mandatory.”
The ABI’s best practice guidance sets out seven core principles for insurers determining whether a cash settlement is appropriate. Insurers are asked to consider customer vulnerability, the complexity of the damage and the availability of suitable repair providers before offering a cash settlement.
They must ensure the settlement figure fairly reflects the full cost of reinstating the property, based on an agreed scope of works, and must clearly explain what accepting a cash settlement means in practice.
The guidance also requires insurers to understand and follow customers’ communication preferences, take reasonable steps to support customers who undertake their own repairs, and maintain clear oversight and governance arrangements to support good outcomes.
Alongside the insurer guidance, the ABI has published a consumer-facing guide that has received the Plain English Campaign’s Crystal Mark accreditation for clarity. The guide explains when an insurer might recommend a cash settlement, the role of loss adjusters, loss assessors and surveyors, and what questions customers should ask before accepting a settlement offer - including whether the figure aligns with quotes from other qualified tradespeople.
Chris Bose, director of general insurance policy at the ABI, said the guidance was designed to improve communication at a critical point in the claims journey.
“Good customer outcomes start with clear communication to help people understand the choices available to them. That is particularly important during what can be a stressful time, when someone is dealing with significant damage to their home and considering how best to carry out repairs.
“The claims process can involve a range of specialists and decisions, so it’s important that customers have clear information and understand the options available to them. Together, they represent another step in our work with members to increase customer understanding throughout the home insurance claims process.”
Read more: UK property insurance claims hit record £10,000 average as subsidence surges
For brokers, the most immediate question is practical: what does this guidance mean when a client is offered a cash settlement? The consumer guide published alongside the insurer principles is directly useful here. It sets out the questions a policyholder should ask their insurer - including how the settlement figure was calculated, whether it reflects a full scope of works and whether it aligns with independent contractor quotes. Brokers handling claims on behalf of clients are well placed to walk through these questions and to push back where a settlement figure appears to reflect the insurer’s preferred supplier rates rather than open market costs.
The Consumer Duty is the enforcement mechanism underpinning all of this. Firms - including intermediaries - must be able to demonstrate they are delivering good outcomes for customers. Where a broker helps a client navigate a cash settlement offer, their own Consumer Duty obligations are engaged.
The claims environment makes this more pressing, not less. UK insurers paid out £6.1 billion in property insurance claims during 2025, the highest annual total on record, according to the ABI. The average home and business insurance claim reached a record £10,000 in the third quarter of 2026, driven by rising repair costs and an unprecedented volume of subsidence claims linked to the hottest UK summer on record. At that level of claims spend, the pressure on insurers to settle in cash rather than manage repairs directly is likely to grow.
The ABI also confirmed that it and Grant Thornton will shortly publish additional good practice guidance for outsourced and delegated claims handling - a separate FCA supervisory priority. More than 90% of managing general agent (MGA) members of the ABI outsource their claims management to third parties, making the forthcoming guidance directly relevant to a substantial portion of the market. The FCA has said it intends to expand its review of firms’ oversight of outsourced claims processes to ensure consistent service standards across the market.