A loose board on a pontoon takes five minutes to fix and seconds to log. The ones that go unrecorded are the ones that end up in court. For boatyards, marinas and boatbuilders, the difference between a claim an insurer can fight and one it has to settle increasingly comes down to what the business can show a court.
Stephen Loader (pictured), managing director at Trafalgar Marine Trades, part of Pen Underwriting's marine practice, has spent 39 years in marine insurance, the first decade in claims. Across every exposure he described, his advice came back to the same point. "You have to put yourself in the best position for insurers to defend you," he said.
The economics make that more pressing. Claims costs, court awards and legal fees are rising faster than premiums, and the gap is widening as the market softens. Claimant lawyers, particularly no-win, no-fee firms, tend to fire claims at every party they can find. Insurers are often accused of either refusing to pay or rolling over too easily, but sometimes they settle simply because there is no defence available.
"You could easily end up defending a claim, paying £100,000 to defend the claim, and the premium rising as a direct result," Loader said.
The lesson that stayed with Loader came from a client rather than a single claim. He inherited a marina risk that lost money at every renewal, even in a soft hard market, on the back of repeated slips and trips claims involving boat owners and staff. Walking the site with the berthing masters, he found hazards were being noticed but never written down and forgotten about.
"I said, you've basically written nothing down. They said, well, there's not really much to write down. I see this every day. I said, that's part of the problem."
A simple regime followed - a clipboard walk around each area of the marina, defects logged, repairs diarised and their completion recorded, with signage and photographs where a fix had to wait for parts. The next three years produced a clean claims record.
UK courts generally accept that not everything can be fixed instantly, Loader said, provided a business can show a reasonable repair regime. A successfully defended claim also discourages others from following, which matters when the same slip can cost several hundred pounds more each year than it did the last.
The same logic applies to the people a yard brings in. The liability marine trades businesses most often overlook, is the exposure they may carry for their subcontractors' work. Quality and reputation should come first, and subcontractors should hold their own liability cover.
"They will often pick subcontractors on the basis of who's going to provide the lowest quote, and I would say that's probably not the way of doing it," Loader said.
For brokers, the checks needn't be onerous. Five minutes on a contractor's website and social media, confirming that they have terms and conditions and that the client knows what those say, and making sure there are no waivers of subrogation. Such waivers are rare in the UK but less so overseas, which matters for yards importing products to sell on to UK customers.
Signed customer terms carry similar weight. In the UK that generally means British Marine Federation terms, which have been tested in court, and Loader warned against arriving without them as the courts move ever further in favour of consumers. "Somebody who's owning a million-pound boat isn't really the man in the street, but they will be treated as [such] under consumer legislation by the courts."
Paperwork cannot rescue everything. A yard whose forklift puts "two nice little prong holes" in a stored boat is, in Loader's words, all but undefendable. But it shapes the rest, including exports, where he advised contracting ex-works under English or UK law, keeping delivery abroad as a separate contract, and never agreeing to US or other jurisdiction without insurers knowing. Repairs and products carry liability long after a boat leaves the marina, and ultimately, he said, it comes down to what a court decides.
The same logic applies to storm risk. Marinas should warn berth holders when bad weather and high tides coincide. Claims already arise from owners who tied their own boats up badly and then pursued the marina, and Loader said he was watching action groups beginning to form internationally against boatyards and marinas after major storm damage. Many countries already issue written storm procedures to clients as standard, and he believes the UK industry should do the same.
The urgency is seasonal. "We traditionally used to get the 1-in-25-year storm every 25 years. Now we're probably getting three or four of those a winter, pretty much everywhere in the UK," Loader said, urging businesses to review their flood precautions before this winter and to issue those warnings in writing.
His broader advice is to treat insurers like any other valued supplier, the timber merchant or the engine supplier, because "insurers aren't the enemy". With defence costs climbing and consumer protection tightening, the marine trades businesses that stay insurable on good terms are likely to be those that can prove what they did, not just do it well.