When renewals get easier, captive conversations between brokers and their clients can lose their urgency. With more capacity and better pricing on offer in traditional markets, some of the pressure that pushed buyers towards alternative structures during the hard market has eased.
Mike Matthews, commercial director, EMEA at Artex Risk Solutions, said that takes away some of the immediate pressure but doesn't remove the strategic case. A soft market, he said, may be the best time to do the work.
"If a captive was only ever meant to solve one difficult renewal, interest may fade when the market softens. If it's about taking more control of risk over the longer term, it remains very relevant through any hard and soft market cycle."
With less pressure around the next renewal, the business has more options, and because reinsurance is soft as well as the primary market, fronting and reinsurance may be available on better terms. That gives buyers time to design a structure properly. If the evidence says not to proceed and everything stays in the conventional market, Matthews said, that is a valid outcome too.
Some captives formed in the hard market have since closed, particularly where the rationale was short-term or the captive wrote a single line and lost scale. Matthews said that is why feasibility work needs to test the strategy under different market conditions and loss scenarios before anything is formed.
The strongest programmes use the captive and the commercial market together, with the captive taking the more predictable working layers while insurers and reinsurers protect against the bigger shocks, and the balance shifting as conditions change.
Nor is there a premium figure at which a captive suddenly makes sense. Premium spend matters because the structure needs enough scale to justify the capital, governance and running costs, but Matthews starts with the risk: how predictable it is, whether there is good data behind it, how much the business already retains through deductibles and uninsured losses, and whether it can absorb more volatility.
A smaller programme with stable, well-understood losses can make a stronger case than a much larger one with poor data and volatile claims, and a short feasibility study will tell a client far more than a headline premium number.
That puts the broker at the start of the process. Matthews, whose firm is owned by Gallagher, said brokers were once wary of involving captives because they feared losing control and revenue, but a captive changes the broker's role rather than removing it.
The client still needs access to insurers and reinsurers, fronting capacity, programme design, claims support and analytics, and the broker helps decide what sits on the client's own balance sheet, what goes into the captive and what stays in the commercial market. A first conversation should be exploratory rather than a sales pitch, starting with what the client is trying to achieve, its loss experience and how much risk the business can genuinely take. Transparency matters throughout, he said, with the client clear on who does what in the chain and how each party is paid.
"The reason to recommend a captive is that it improves the client's risk financing strategy, not because it protects a particular revenue stream."
The quieter market also leaves time to bring the UK into the domicile conversation. The PRA and FCA consultation on a bespoke captive regime closed on 14 October, with launch due in summer 2027, and Matthews expects the first users to be UK-headquartered businesses that already understand captives and see a practical benefit in having one close to the parent. Proximity rarely decides it on its own, though. A captive may be in place for decades, and the best domicile is the one that fits the parent and the risks it wants to write.
Much will depend on how the regime works in practice rather than on paper. Beyond clarity on authorisation, capital, governance and tax reporting, owners will need the experienced directors, managers and actuaries that established offshore centres already provide.
"Creating the rules of engagement around the domicile are one thing, but they're not enough. You need to have all of the support services to make it a success."
Building that bench will take time. In the meantime, the quieter part of the cycle gives brokers and their clients the chance to test the case properly, rather than waiting for the next hard renewal to force the conversation.