The crime data insurers use to price London high street risk may be responding to changes in how police record offences rather than changes in actual risk on the street. That is one of the central findings of a new study by Seenity, which sells risk intelligence software to insurers, covering 488 of the capital’s high streets across two three-year windows: 2016 to 2019 and 2023 to 2026.
Data shows that 29% of ranked high streets moved into a different risk band between the two periods. When Seenity weighted crimes by severity rather than counting them by volume, shoplifting and burglary pulled in opposite directions. Shoplifting rose 74% across London high streets and theft from the person rose 53%. Burglary, the heaviest-weighted high-volume crime in Seenity’s index, fell 24%. Non-residential fires fell 17%, injury road collisions fell 16%, and nitrogen dioxide fell approximately 34%. Overall crime harm rose 7%.
The gap between those two readings is the one commercial property and retail underwriters should pay attention to. A pricing model that counts crime incidents will produce a different risk assessment than one that weights them by seriousness, and Seenity’s argument is that most location scores still use the former.
Three separate changes to source data affected London crime records during the period Seenity analysed. According to the analysis, police.uk replaced every anonymised crime location in the capital in July 2022. In February 2024, the Metropolitan Police’s move to the CONNECT records management system shifted an estimated 1,500 offences a month between theft categories, according to Seenity’s analysis.
Seenity also pointed to changes in how shop theft involving threats is recorded, noting that incidents where violence or threats occur during a theft or escape are now captured as robbery rather than theft under clarified police recording guidance, which the company said affected its trend data.
Each of those changes could produce a statistical trend in a pricing model that never occurred on an actual street. Seenity tested its most-improved high streets against three catchment definitions, 5,000 random weightings of the five hazard categories, a median-year test and a displacement check on the surrounding 300 metres specifically to filter out data artefacts. Streets that did not hold up under those tests were removed from the final list.
“A new police records system, a reclassified offence or a refreshed map of anonymised crime locations can manufacture a trend that never happened on the street,” said Oren Atia, chief executive of Seenity. “For an insurer or a lender, the right question is never only ‘how risky is this place?’ but ‘which way is it moving, and how confident are we?’”
Of the streets Seenity identified as most improved, all 22 recorded a fall in burglary, ranging from 38% to 77% across the top ten. New King’s Road in Fulham was used as an illustrative example, with overall crime harm down 40%, burglary down 51% and vehicle crime down 66% compared with the pre-pandemic baseline.
The findings have a direct bearing on commercial property risks placed on London high streets, where location-based crime scores feed into both pricing and coverage decisions. A portfolio priced on pre-pandemic location data carries assumptions that may now be wrong in both directions. It may overstate risk on streets where burglary has fallen sharply, while understating it on streets where personal theft has surged.
Seenity drew on 13 million police.uk street-level crime records, 287,000 Department of Transportation road collision records, London Fire Brigade incident data and the Greater London Authority’s atmospheric emissions inventory. All underlying data sources are published under the Open Government Licence. The full methodology and a ranking of all 616 high streets initially assessed are available on request from Seenity. Of those, 488 met the threshold for inclusion in the final ranked study.