What happened: A Scottish insurer argues a credit hire agreement is unenforceable because the hire company may lack FCA authorisation - and wins the first round.
Who's involved: Advantage Insurance Company Limited (insurer), Call Robert Hire Drive Ltd (credit hire company)
What's at stake: £6,264 in credit hire charges at £180 per day plus VAT for 29 days
Why it matters: Insurers defending credit hire claims may have a new line of attack - checking whether the hire company holds the right FCA permissions
Where it stands: Trial assigned for February 18, 2027; the FCA authorisation question remains undecided
You cannot claim you lost the use of your car while you were driving a different one. That, stripped to its core, is what a Glasgow sheriff has just told a motorist pursuing a £6,264 credit hire claim against Advantage Insurance Company Limited.
The ruling, handed down on November 10, is a procedural win for the insurer. But it is the court's preliminary remarks on FCA authorisation that could have the wider industry impact.
The facts are straightforward. In October 2023, a vehicle insured by Advantage collided with a stationary car. The insurer admitted liability for the accident. The motorist hired a replacement vehicle on credit from Call Robert Hire Drive Ltd at £180 per day plus VAT, running up a 29-day bill of £6,264. That figure is the entire claim.
The insurer's defence went beyond the usual arguments about hire rates and mitigation. Advantage argued that Call Robert was not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority to enter into regulated consumer hire agreements - a type of hire contract that, by law, can only be offered by firms with the right FCA permissions. Without that authorisation, the insurer said, the agreement could not be enforced against the motorist. No enforceable agreement, no liability incurred, no loss.
The motorist's fallback was blunt: even if the agreement is unenforceable, he still lost the use of his vehicle for 29 days and should be compensated anyway.
The court was not persuaded. On the motorist's own account, he had use of a replacement car for the entire 29-day period. There was nothing to suggest the replacement fell short of his own vehicle in any material way.
"The pursuer cannot have his cake and eat it," the court stated. "He cannot have the use of a replacement vehicle and also seek damages for loss of use of a vehicle for the same period."
The fallback claim was struck out.
The larger prize for Advantage - a ruling that the credit hire agreement itself is unenforceable - remains undecided. That question turns on whether Call Robert held FCA authorisation to enter into regulated consumer hire agreements when the contract was signed. The motorist disputes that it lacked authorisation. The court could not resolve that factual dispute at a preliminary hearing and sent it to trial, now set for February 18, 2027.
The court did, however, offer detailed preliminary views on the contract. The credit hire agreement contains a condition stating the hire period "will not exceed 270 days." That makes it capable of running for more than three months - which is the threshold for a regulated consumer hire agreement under the Consumer Credit Act 1974. If Call Robert was not FCA-authorised to enter such agreements, the legal consequences follow directly: the agreement breaches what the statute calls the "general prohibition" on unauthorised regulated activity, rendering it unenforceable and the hire charges irrecoverable.
The court drew on the House of Lords' reasoning in Dimond v Lovell, where a credit hire agreement that turned out to be unenforceable left the claimant with no recoverable loss. The cost fell on the non-compliant credit hire company - the law's way of penalising the firm and protecting the consumer, not a route for the firm to recover indirectly from the negligent party.
The motorist's side argued that any unenforceability could be cured - the FCA has a power to validate agreements by written notice, and that possibility meant the agreement was not permanently unenforceable. The court dismissed this. No such validation had been sought or obtained. Until it is, the agreement is either enforceable or it is not.
A trial is scheduled for February 18, 2027. The outstanding issues are described in the ruling as "relatively crisp and focussed" - chiefly whether Call Robert held FCA authorisation and whether the motorist was genuinely unable to afford conventional hire costs when he signed the credit hire agreement. A one-day hearing is expected to be sufficient.
If the insurer proves Call Robert lacked FCA authorisation, the entire £6,264 claim collapses under the court's preliminary analysis. For claims teams handling credit hire, the signal from Glasgow is worth noting: checking a hire company's FCA register entry may be as important as challenging the daily rate.