Which?, the organisation millions of people rely on to tell them what is worth buying, has stepped a little further into the business of selling. The consumer group has extended its partnership with protection broker LifeSearch, launching a co-branded online journey that lets members get a quote, apply and buy life cover without speaking to an adviser.
The two organisations pitch it as a matter of choice for around half a million Which? members: do it yourself online, or call a LifeSearch adviser. But the launch also sharpens an awkward question for a body whose brand rests on independence. Can a consumer champion that is paid when its members buy a policy also be a neutral guide to the market it is selling into?
The financial link isn't secret. LifeSearch's Which? member pages state that if a customer goes ahead with the broker, Which? receives a commission to help fund its not-for-profit mission and campaigning. Which? is also an introducer appointed representative of LifeSearch Partners – in plain terms, a regulated referral channel.
That commercial role sits close to the editorial one. Which?'s guide to the best life insurance in the UK carries "get a quote" buttons for the LifeSearch service. Last year the group used part of its commission to fund half of a John Lewis gift card for members who bought cover through LifeSearch during a promotion that ran from May to June 2025. According to the two organisations, enquiries across life insurance and private medical insurance rose 17% over the past year, and the number of people taking out cover through the arrangement climbed 20%.
The launch announcement did little to put clear water between reviewer and partner. Phil Amy, commercial director at Which?, said LifeSearch "continues to be the best in the market, with our results further demonstrating that this partnership works for consumers". It is an unusually firm endorsement from an organisation that normally lets its testing do the talking, and it comes from the commercial side of the business rather than its researchers.
Which? would argue that none of this compromises its judgement. Its statement of editorial independence says affiliate revenue comes at the final stage and has no bearing on which products it covers. The group also has a clear financial reason to build these revenue streams. It is owned by a charity, the Consumers' Association, and its paying membership fell from 543,865 in 2022/23 to 521,343 in 2023/24, according to its annual report. Its latest accounts credit growth in non-subscription income with offsetting the decline.
Read next: Aviva adds life cover to ChatGPT app
The launch comes less than two months after the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published the final report of its pure protection market study. The regulator found that competition generally works well for people who already hold cover and chose not to bring in new market-wide rules. It did, however, put remuneration under the spotlight, reminding firms that distribution arrangements must be consistent with delivering fair value. Nothing in the report singles out Which? or LifeSearch, but commission-funded referral chains are exactly the kind of set-up that guidance is aimed at.
Read next: FCA: Protection market works, but awareness gap remains
The self-serve journey raises a second issue. Responses to the FCA's interim findings pointed to a "beneficiary gap", particularly in non-advised channels, where policies are bought without being placed in trust or set up with named beneficiaries. LifeSearch has built a digital trust step into its own online journeys, but the announcement does not say whether Which? members buying online will be offered it.
The bigger prize is the 58% of people who, according to the FCA, hold no protection at all. A trusted consumer brand is a powerful way to reach them, which is precisely why the line between recommending and selling matters.
Read next: FCA urges insurers to close UK protection gap as majority of adults lack cover
Tom Dobbe, director at JK Insurance Brokers in [location], welcomes trusted brands entering protection, since anything that encourages more people to think about protecting their families is a good thing. But he does not see them as direct competition for advisers. Buying life insurance is relatively straightforward, he said, while working out how much cover is needed, which type of policy fits and how it should be structured is often considerably more complicated.
"Consumers may be confident they've purchased the right protection simply because they've bought it through a brand they trust," he said. "But a trusted brand doesn't automatically guarantee that the cover they've selected is suitable for their circumstances."
JK does not charge clients a fee for protection advice. It is paid through commission from the insurer and is open about that, Dobbe said, and the Which? partnership shows commission is not exclusive to traditional brokers. "The important distinction is whether consumers understand how the business they're dealing with is remunerated and, crucially, what level of advice or service they're receiving," he said.
His biggest concern is what gets missed when cover is bought without advice. Consumers understandably focus on the monthly premium, but the cheapest policy is not necessarily the most appropriate. "Someone might purchase £200,000 of life insurance believing that's sufficient, without properly considering their outstanding mortgage, future household expenditure, childcare costs or the income their family would lose if they died," he said.
Writing cover into trust is another frequently overlooked area. Where appropriate, a trust can help proceeds reach the intended beneficiaries without forming part of the deceased's estate, avoiding unnecessary delays and potential inheritance tax implications. Consumers may also not fully appreciate the differences between level and decreasing term assurance, critical illness cover and income protection. For business owners weighing relevant life, key person or shareholder protection, the picture is more complicated still.
"Ultimately, the most expensive life insurance policy isn't necessarily the one with the highest premium. It's the one that fails to provide the protection a family thought it had," he said.
As trusted brands push further into protection and the FCA keeps watching how distribution is paid, that is the test every channel, co-branded or advised, is likely to face.