AI will reshape insurance roles, not replace people, HR leaders say

Oxbow and LMG research finds human judgement and relationships will matter more as routine work is automated
AI will reshape insurance roles, not replace people, HR leaders say
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION
By Josh Recamara
16 Nov 2026

AI is likely to change how insurance organisations structure teams and develop expertise as much as it changes underwriting and claims, according to research from Oxbow Partners and the London Market Group.

The consultancy and the LMG interviewed senior HR executives across the industry about how AI will affect talent. They found the future workforce is unlikely to be defined by either people or AI, but by how well organisations combine the two.

Human skills rise in value

The report found AI can boost productivity, speed up learning, widen access to expertise and improve decision-making. As routine tasks are automated, uniquely human capabilities, including judgement, creativity, relationship-building and leadership, will become more important.

“The organisations that pull ahead will be those that treat AI as a catalyst to rethink roles, accelerate how people learn and give their teams more time for the judgement and relationships that clients value most,” said Miqdaad Versi, partner at Oxbow Partners and co-author of the report.

Versi said this was a leadership question as much as a technology one.

Redesigning work, not just adopting tools

The report argues that insurers should look beyond efficiency and consider how AI can augment employees, unlock new capabilities and make organisations more adaptable. LMG chief executive Caroline Wagstaff said the challenge for insurers was not simply adopting new technology, but redesigning how work gets done.

That means rethinking how people learn. In a traditional apprenticeship model, junior staff build expertise through routine tasks. If AI absorbs those tasks, firms will need new ways to develop the judgement senior roles require.

A shrinking pipeline

The findings land as the London market faces a demographic squeeze. The LMG has projected the market will need around 82,200 full-time employees by 2034, up from about 61,000 today. Over the same period, it expects the share of the workforce aged under 30 to fall from 24% to 7%.

Other research this week points the same way. Burns & Wilcox found 92% of London brokers are concerned about replacing retiring colleagues, and 65% said their teams now recruit more for data skills than for traditional insurance expertise. The Lloyd’s Market Association found a third of respondents believe some groups may have less access to the experience needed to succeed in an AI-enabled market.

For insurers, brokers and MGAs, the research suggests AI could ease the London market’s talent shortage by making smaller teams more productive. But it may also deepen another problem: if routine work disappears, the traditional routes by which juniors learn the trade disappear with it.

Firms that redesign roles deliberately, using AI to speed up learning rather than simply cut tasks, are likely to be better placed. Those that treat AI purely as a cost-saving tool risk weakening the pipeline of experienced people the market needs.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB UK.