The US excess and surplus lines property market now represents roughly $100 billion in premium and competes directly with admitted carriers across a growing range of accounts. In a recent roundtable hosted by Insurance Business, three senior leaders examined catastrophe risk, property valuation, artificial intelligence, and the sector's long-term outlook. A central theme runs through the discussion: the industry is rethinking what qualifies as a catastrophe peril, and what that means for underwriting discipline and long-term portfolio management. With global reinsurer capital at a record $785 billion and data center exposure set to generate $134 billion in cumulative premiums by 2030, the stakes for getting these decisions right have never been higher.
The E&S market is highly competitive. Wes Robinson, national property president at Risk Placement Services, told Insurance Business that the current market reflects rate increases over the past three years. "The E&S sector can very actively compete with the admitted markets, single-carrier deals, and win those deals. [Maybe] not all of them, but more than I can remember. That's how competitive the E&S market has become, and it's become that way for a [couple] of different reasons, flexibility and creativity." Tom Krause, SVP and head of middle market property at Westfield Specialty, added that carriers are actively evaluating whether to enter new lines, new sectors, or different layers of the risk tower to sustain growth.
Krause told Insurance Business that many organizations, including Westfield, no longer view them that way. "From a secondary peril perspective, there are many organizations, including Westfield, not looking at flood, convective storm, or wildfire as secondary perils. We view them as critical catastrophe perils. We've always been cognizant of those exposures, and we're seeing where organizations are being more cognizant of those exposures due to their risk analyses." Jake Rothfuss, CEO of Velocity Risk Underwriters and WKFC Underwriting Managers, agreed, telling Insurance Business it is "really a question of which perils have been well modeled versus those that are truly harder to understand, such as wildfire or severe convective storm." Krause noted that Tornado Alley has now expanded into Dixie Alley, and a catastrophe can occur in any zone.
The numbers are substantial. Verisk projects global insured catastrophe losses will average $171 billion annually on a modeled, long-term basis, with the US accounting for $117 billion of that total, or 68 percent, its highest annual estimate on record. Reinsurance Market Dynamics, Aon's 2026 report, put global reinsurer capital at $785 billion at the end of 2025, a record high and almost 10 percent higher year over year. Krause told Insurance Business that the E&S marketplace has, in his almost 40 years, "always been a consistent provider of capital for those exposures," and that carriers and brokers can feel confident that solutions exist no matter what loss events occur.
Valuation accuracy has real consequences. Rothfuss told Insurance Business that valuation is one of the most critical elements for his company as an underwriting organization: "[It's about] understanding the risks that we're taking on. The last few years of the hardened market really helped us get valuations to a place where they felt correct, they were at the right technical levels." He added that disciplined organizations consult econometric data, claims data, internal data, and third-party industry data. Robinson warned of what happens when valuations fall short: "There was a reckoning during the hard market a couple of years ago because it was such a systemic problem, and there are legitimate claim examples." He told Insurance Business the industry is now in a much better spot.
The tools matter. So does how they are used. Robinson told Insurance Business that underwriting companies need to evaluate the cost-benefit analysis of any new tool they introduce, but that tools have to be used in conjunction with the human element. Krause went further, saying no tool can replace a human underwriter's creativity and expertise: "At the end of the day, there are a lot of very talented E&S underwriters at their desks who are making very critical decisions for their firms." He added: "The tool is only going to spit out a result. And what if the data is bad? Bad data input into AI tools leads to bad results." Krause told Insurance Business that developing and implementing effective AI tools will be important for the industry over the next several years.
Data centers present concentrated, complex property risks. Robinson told Insurance Business: "Data centers are so unique from a property risk perspective, each one of them is measured in the hundreds of millions to multiple billions of dollars at a single location." Aon's 2026 Reinsurance Market Dynamics report estimates that data centers will generate approximately $134 billion in cumulative global insurance premiums between 2026 and 2030, with 2,108 data centers under construction or planned by that year. Large, multi-building data center campuses can require insurance limits exceeding $10 billion. Robinson noted, ironically, that these data centers are not using AI to place their own insurance, "further showcasing the need for the human element to actually do the job."
The consensus is cautious optimism. Absent a major capital event or loss of reinsurance capacity, Krause told Insurance Business he expects "our marketplaces for the next two years are going to be consistent." Goldman Sachs Asset Management's 2026 Global Insurance Survey found that 62 percent of insurance companies are currently using AI; among those using or considering it, 83 percent cite reducing operational costs and 38 percent cite insurance risk underwriting. Rothfuss offered the boldest view: "This is the start of a golden age for the E&S sector in terms of utilizing AI in a way that adds value for clients, carriers, capital providers, and brokers." Brokers and underwriters tracking E&S market developments can explore Insurance Business America's premium reports for further expert analysis. If this roundtable is useful to your team, share it on Facebook, Twitter, or LinkedIn.