Pedestrians make up 17% of vulnerable road user claims but 45% of serious injuries

Hastings Direct data exposes a severity gap with direct implications for motor claims costs
Pedestrians make up 17% of vulnerable road user claims but 45% of serious injuries
MOTOR & FLEET
By Mark Rosanes
16 Nov 2026

Pedestrians account for less than a fifth of motor claims involving vulnerable road users but nearly half of those where someone dies or suffers a life-threatening injury. That severity concentration, drawn from analysis of almost 4,500 Hastings Direct motor claims, points to a claims cost pattern that extends well beyond one insurer’s book.

The data, released by Hastings Direct during Brake’s Road Safety Week 2026 and based on claims filed between November 2025 and October 2026, shows pedestrians making up just 17% of vulnerable road user claims while representing 45% of those involving a fatal, life-threatening or serious injury requiring hospitalisation. Vulnerable road users, including pedestrians, cyclists and motorcyclists, accounted for 56% of UK road deaths and serious injuries in 2025, according to Brake, which cites government casualty data.

The severity gap reflects a structural feature of how injury claims are priced and settled. Unlike the whiplash tariff, which covers most low-severity vehicle occupant claims with fixed compensation bands, vulnerable road user injuries typically involve fractures, orthopaedic damage and, in serious cases, catastrophic trauma. Those claims sit outside the tariff framework and tend to be more complex, more expensive and longer to resolve.

Junctions and rush hour

The Hastings data also identifies where and when collisions cluster. Around half (43%) of all claims involving pedestrians, cyclists and motorcyclists happen when a vehicle is turning or pulling out at a junction. The 4pm to 7pm window accounts for 29% of vulnerable road user claims, roughly twice the rate seen during the same hours at weekends, as the school run and evening commute converge. Cyclist risk extends into the morning. Around one in six cyclist claims in the data occurs on weekday mornings.

Pedestrian exposure increases sharply in winter. Claims involving pedestrians run around 50% higher between November and February than in the rest of the year, with November consistently among the peak months in Hastings Direct’s data.

Rising severity, rising costs

The pattern sits against a deteriorating cost environment across the motor market. UK motor insurers paid out £3.2 billion in claims in Q3 2026, 8% higher than the same period a year earlier, according to the Association of British Insurers (ABI). The average claim was £4,900, up 1% year on year.

Modelling published in August 2026 by insurance analytics consultancy Angelica Solutions, using police STATS19 collision data, meanwhile, found that vulnerable road users already account for 57% of all people killed or seriously injured on England’s roads. The consultancy projected that a rise in walking and cycling activity could push third-party injury costs up by roughly 18% and overall motor claims costs by around 6%.

The Department for Transport’s final 2025 road casualty statistics, published in July 2026, confirmed serious injuries rose 4% year on year even as fatalities declined. That pattern is at odds with the government’s Road Safety Strategy target of a 65% reduction in killed or seriously injured (KSI) casualties by 2035.

Toby van der Meer, chief executive of Hastings Direct, said the company’s claims data showed junctions as a particular danger point. Small changes in driver behaviour, such as taking an extra moment before turning, reducing speed and minimising distractions, could reduce the risk, he said. Hastings Direct sponsors Road Safety Week, which is organised by Brake.

The Hastings Direct analysis examined claim descriptions and injury severity records across the 12-month period. The company noted that circumstances were identified through claim descriptions and do not represent a determination of fault.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB UK.