SMEs want more cyber insurance, but 55% still buy on price

A quarter believe they are already covered elsewhere, even with cyber rates falling
SMEs want more cyber insurance, but 55% still buy on price
CYBER
By Rod Bolivar
19 Nov 2026

Most insured UK SMEs say they are likely to increase their cyber insurance, yet 55% still choose a provider mainly on price and 26% believe cyber may already be covered elsewhere, according to Brit Insurance.

Brit’s A Turning Tide report, for which 500 UK SME decision-makers were surveyed between August 19 and 27, 2026, also discloses a £350,000 reserve on a 2026 cyber claim under a policy with an annual premium below £3,500.

Appetite for cover climbing

Some 82% of insured SMEs are likely to increase their cover over the next year, 37% of uninsured firms are very likely to buy, and 68% say AI has made them more likely to purchase cyber insurance. Some 55% also say larger clients now expect them to meet their cyber standards - a supply chain pressure that is turning buyer intent into a commercial requirement.

UK cyber rates have fallen about 7% on average through 2026, yet GlobalData puts SME take-up near 40%, against roughly 70% for FTSE 100 companies. Some 79% of SMEs think AI makes attacks more sophisticated and harder to prevent. Cyber security is a top or high priority for 64%, and 43% of firms that plan to spend more cite growth as the main reason.

Price still decides

Brit says a breach will almost always cost more than a cyber insurance policy, yet over a third of SMEs have no dedicated cyber budget or team. Government research it cites puts a small firm’s average recovery cost after a serious breach at close to £8,000, which can exceed £50,000 once downtime, reputational damage and lost income are counted.

Coalition’s November 2025 survey of 600 mid-market firms found they expected an incident to cost about £200,000, yet 35% said the risk did not justify the price of cover and 35% of former standalone buyers had dropped it.

Cover that may not exist

Larger SMEs with turnover above £50 million tend to worry that claims will not be paid or assume they are already protected elsewhere. Some 26% say they hold too little sensitive data to need cover, rising to 36% among smaller firms.

Brit says many traditional small business policies do not cover breaches or attacks, and unclear wording can leave silent cyber gaps. Outsourcing IT does not transfer responsibility for customer data, contracts or daily operations. The Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, still before Parliament in early November, would bring managed service providers into regulation.

Markel’s October research found 44% of 1,500 UK small businesses had no cyber cover and 39% of the uninsured rated their risk as low. All 16 brokers in the study reported confusion over comparing cover across insurers.

Supply chain exposure and regional spread

Some 61% of SMEs fear being held responsible if an attack on them disrupted a customer, 52% accept they could be a route into larger clients and 44% fear a supplier attack could stop them trading. Half say recent high-profile attacks changed their view of cyber risk, and 42% think their exposure has risen over the past year. A third fear their business would not survive an attack. The ABI said its members paid £197 million in cyber claims in 2024, up 230% on 2023.

Spending intent rises sharply with turnover: 25% of firms under £500,000 plan to raise cyber spending, against 52% at £500,000 to £10 million, 75% at £10 million to £50 million and 73% above that. Nearly two-fifths say their defences cannot keep pace with growth, rising to 58% among the smallest firms. A third give staff no cyber training, despite 30% ranking human error among their top three risks.

Read next: Lords call for Flood Re-style safety net for cyber as they warn UK is unready for cascading crises

A sale built on advice

Adelle Gruber, class underwriter, cyber and technology at Brit Insurance, said SMEs increasingly see how an attack could interrupt trading, damage their bottom line and constrain growth.

“The encouraging finding is that many businesses now intend to act, with 74% of SMEs planning to respond in some form over the next year,” she said. “Cyber insurance should not simply be viewed as a payout after an attack, but as a resource that helps businesses manage cyber risk at every stage.”

Brit’s report advises brokers to raise cyber in every client growth conversation and identify each client’s main barrier - whether price, a perceived lack of exposure, confidence in an IT provider or uncertainty about what cover actually provides. For SME brokers, the report’s most commercially useful finding is that the barrier is rarely cost alone. The 26% who believe they are already covered elsewhere represent a conversation that can be settled with a policy review in minutes. The 55% buying on price represent an advice gap that standalone cyber cover cannot close on its own - what closes it is a broker who can explain what a £350,000 claim reserve looks like against an annual premium below £3,500.

Read more: Cyber’s next divide will be over who reaches small businesses

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB UK.