UK regulators consult on cyber resilience guidance as FCA incidents hit second-highest level

Claim costs have tripled in five years, and clients without documented controls face weaker terms at renewal
UK regulators consult on cyber resilience guidance as FCA incidents hit second-highest level
CYBER
By Rod Bolivar
19 Nov 2026

The Bank of England, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) published a joint consultation on cyber risk and resilience management on November 19, 2026, giving financial services firms until February 26, 2027 to respond.

The consultation follows October 2026 recording the second-highest monthly number of cyber incidents reported to the FCA in five years, 52% above the previous 18-month peak in May 2025. The Bank’s latest Systemic Risk Survey also ranks cyber among the risks with the greatest impact on the UK financial system.

The proposed guidance brings together existing requirements and lessons from supervisory experience rather than adding new rules. It covers governance, identification, protection, detection, response and recovery, and aligns with the National Cyber Security Centre’s (NCSC) Cyber Assessment Framework. Firms that fall within scope of existing operational resilience requirements are the primary audience.

FCA chief executive Nikhil Rathi said the financial sector has “a crucial role in tackling those threats, including through products like cyber insurance,” but added that the response “shouldn’t always be more rules.” PRA chief executive Katharine Braddick, also deputy governor at the Bank, said regulators need confidence “both that firms have strong cyber controls and that they can detect, contain and recover quickly from incidents.” NCSC chief executive Dr Richard Horne welcomed the proposals as helping firms better understand, assess and strengthen cyber resilience.

Separately, the regulators published additional effective practices on AI and quantum computing risks. A Bank of England and FCA survey found 88% of respondents expect frontier AI cyber capabilities to have a moderate or high impact on their risk profile over the next two years. The effective practices material is not formally open for consultation but the regulators are seeking industry feedback on whether the format is useful.

Read more: Cyber market approaching critical turning point in 2026, DUAL warns

What it means for the insurance market

Kathryn Moore, head of non-life at Broadstone, said the sharp rise in reported incidents underlined the critical importance of robust cyber resilience and appropriate insurance protection.

“The evolving threat landscape, particularly the growing use of AI by cyber criminals, presents new challenges for insurers in assessing, pricing and underwriting cyber risk,” she said. “As attacks become more sophisticated and their potential financial consequences increase, insurers will need to continually reassess their exposure and ensure that their products remain fit for purpose.”

Moore added that “the strength of businesses’ cyber security and resilience measures will also be increasingly important in determining the availability, scope and cost of insurance cover.” Underwriters at the stricter end of the market already request dated records - patch compliance rates, MFA deployment logs and backup restore-test results - rather than self-certified proposal answers. Clients without documented remediation since their last renewal are in a weaker position at renewal.

Read more: NCSC warns of ‘unprecedented’ rise in cyber incidents, even as serious breaches fall

The gap between rates and claims

International cyber insurance rates have dropped 43% since the fourth quarter of 2023, according to DUAL, which describes the UK as in late-stage softening. Claims costs have moved the other way. Chubb’s 2026 Cyber Claims Report found the average claim cost for mid-sized UK and European businesses rose 210% over five years to US$318,820 in 2025, while ABI data shows UK cyber payouts grew 234% from £59 million in 2023 to £197 million in 2024.

That divergence between falling rates and rising claim severity is precisely the environment in which the regulator’s guidance lands. For brokers, the consultation confirms that cyber resilience documentation is becoming part of the placement conversation rather than an optional extra.

The government’s Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025 found 45% of UK businesses hold some form of cyber insurance, while only 7% have a standalone policy. The consultation closes February 26, 2027. Separately, rules confirmed in April shorten incident-reporting timescales and require firms to keep a register of third-party providers, taking effect March 18, 2027. The Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, at Report Stage in the House of Lords by September, proposes 24-hour initial notification and 72-hour full reporting, with penalties of up to £17 million or 4% of global turnover.

The Financial Ombudsman Service’s latest report on insurance complaints urges insurers to improve claims handling, oversight of third-party handlers and treatment of vulnerable customers. Which? has called for firm FCA action following its September 2025 super-complaint on home and travel insurance, which the regulator rejected on enforcement grounds but addressed with a commitment to a public update by the end of 2026.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB UK.