The government is set to introduce legislation before Christmas that would ban most new leasehold flats in England and Wales and replace them with commonhold, where residents collectively own and manage their buildings, the BBC reported. Housing minister Matthew Pennycook described the current leasehold system as “blighting lives” and called it “an anachronism in the twenty-first century,” according to the report.
The proposed Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill would also cap ground rent at £250 a year for existing leaseholders, later reducing it to a nominal rate. The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) confirmed that the Prime Minister has pledged to introduce the Bill before the Christmas recess, though key questions around converting existing leasehold buildings and compensating freeholders remain unresolved, according to the BBC.
The scale of what the legislation would eventually reshape is significant. There were an estimated 4.9 million leasehold dwellings in England in 2024-25, accounting for 20% of the English housing stock, according to official MHCLG statistics.
Under the current leasehold model, freeholders and professional managing agents typically place block buildings policies and recover the cost through service charges. Under commonhold, that responsibility moves to resident-owned Commonhold Associations (CAs).
The draft Bill, published in January 2026, goes beyond existing law by establishing a framework under which the Commonhold Community Statement can require public liability insurance and signalling an intention to ensure CAs have access to adequate cover, according to law firm Keoghs, which has convened a parliamentary roundtable on the insurance implications of the reforms.
That shift fragments a relatively concentrated market. Under the current leasehold model, professional managing agents frequently place insurance across portfolios, allowing risks to be pooled and weaker risks to be absorbed. A shift to building-by-building procurement under commonhold risks higher premiums for poorly maintained or higher-risk buildings and reduced availability of cover for marginal or complex risks.
Brokers placing block policies have already faced scrutiny over how that commission flows. Those longstanding commission concerns are now meeting a legislative deadline. Secondary legislation passed on October 25 will implement restrictions on commission-sharing under the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 from November 1, 2027. From that date, landlords will be prohibited from recovering insurance commissions through the service charge, with only a defined “permitted insurance payment” allowed.
The longer-term challenge goes beyond commission. CAs under commonhold will typically be run by volunteer resident directors with no professional background in property insurance. Keoghs has flagged the risk of mis-disclosure, underinsurance, and claims handling delays when decision-making passes from professional managing agents to residents with no equivalent expertise.
The Spectrum building case in Dagenham showed what happens under the current model when that decision-making chain breaks down entirely: freeholder insolvency froze the insurance proceeds, leaving leaseholders paying mortgages on a demolished building while the courts worked through the administration.
Resident directors of CAs would take on legal responsibilities for the building’s insurance arrangements, creating a potential need for management liability and directors’ and officers’ cover in a segment where that demand does not currently exist.
The transition adds complexity. The BBC reported that converting existing leasehold buildings to commonhold is far more complicated than applying the rules to new developments, raising concerns about a two-tier system in which buyers of new properties move to commonhold while millions of existing leaseholders remain on the old tenure.
The near-term answer is that the market will not change overnight. Insurance effects will arrive gradually, beginning with new-build flats. Commission reform lands first, in November 2027. The structural shift in who buys buildings cover will follow the pace of new development and, eventually, any framework for converting existing buildings.