The individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement (ICHRA) market is growing, although broker sales remain below 50%, while the technology platforms enabling it are maturing fast.
But for the US benefits broker community, a growing market for a product that hands power to end users raises an uncomfortable question: as ICHRA administrators build direct relationships with employers and their employees, are some brokers inadvertently signing away the very client relationships they spent years building?
Brandy Thompson, co-founder and CEO of BenefitBay, says the risk is real and that many brokers are not reading the fine print carefully enough to know it is happening to them.
"Sometimes the brokers aren't reading those agreements in fine-tooth detail, but they're losing their clients after a couple of years," Thompson told Insurance Business Benefits US. "It's just a referral bonus or a referral agreement for a couple of years."
Thompson made clear that BenefitBay's model works differently - its broker agreements are ongoing service relationships rather than time-limited referral arrangements. But her candor about how many platforms operate in the ICHRA space points to a structural tension that benefits brokers and advisors need to understand before they commit to an administrator.
Under a referral-only agreement, a broker introduces an employer client to an ICHRA platform and receives compensation, typically for two years. After that window closes, the agreement expires and the administrator effectively owns the client relationship.
For brokers who have spent years building trust with an employer, it is a significant concession to make, often buried in contract language that does not get the scrutiny it deserves during a sales cycle.
The issue is particularly acute in the ICHRA space because the product's complexity creates natural dependence on the platform. Once an employer is integrated - HRIS connections built, payroll rails established, ACA 1095 filing workflows embedded - switching administrators is disruptive. A broker whose agreement expires at the two-year mark may find that their client has effectively become the platform's client, with the broker's leverage sharply reduced.
"I do know across the administrator landscape, some agreements are referral agreements for that broker, and so that broker does lose their value after two years," Thompson said. BenefitBay, she added, has employers who have been on its platform since 2021 with the same producer renewing every year - evidence, she argued, that the broker relationship retains ongoing value when the agreement is structured to support it.
The referral agreement risk does not fall evenly across the broker population. Thompson segmented today's benefits broker community into three distinct tiers, and the picture she painted of the bottom tier is a pointed warning.
At the top are what she called superusers - brokers who have leaned into ICHRA, invested in education, and are now delivering high-level consultative value to employer clients on plan benchmarking, carrier monitoring, and contribution strategy.
In the middle sits the majority: brokers at average education levels who understand the product but have not yet differentiated on it. At the bottom is a cohort that engages with ICHRA only when an employer demands it, and even then reluctantly.
"They're not going to talk about a carrier unless their employer absolutely wants it, and they're going to come along begrudgingly, and their employer's not going to have the best outcome," Thompson said. "Often they may not stay seated at the table year two."
That bottom tier, she implied, is precisely the group most at risk from unfavorable platform agreements, because a broker who is not actively adding value in year one has little leverage to assert when year two arrives and the referral window closes.
The SMB end of the market presents a more fundamental challenge. Thompson acknowledged directly that for small employers - particularly those for whom ICHRA is simply a vehicle for providing a first-time health benefit rather than a complex defined-contribution strategy - the case for a broker in the middle is genuinely weakening. "It's just really not fruitful for either the broker or the employer to be using a broker in the middle if technology is able to solve their ancillary products and some of their other solutions," she said.
State-level tax credits targeted at small businesses are accelerating ICHRA adoption in that segment, which may draw smaller employers into the market through direct or near-direct channels, further reducing the broker's natural foothold at the lower end.
Read next: ICHRA risk shift: why brokers must prepare clients for the stakes
Thompson was careful not to overstate the disintermediation threat at the larger-employer end of the market, and her argument deserves equal weight. For mid-to-large employers - those with geographic complexity, multi-legal entities, HR turnover, Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) 5500 filing obligations, and payroll integrations to manage - the broker's consultative role remains difficult to replicate through a platform alone.
"We very much still believe the broker has a seat at the table," she said, pointing to the ongoing work of benchmarking new plans, navigating carrier movements, and managing contribution structures across multiple rating areas as the durable core of broker value in an ICHRA renewal cycle.
She said that when a carrier like Cigna exits certain markets, it is the broker - armed with real-time platform intelligence from BenefitBay - who gets ahead of the conversation with the employer before open enrollment rather than reacting to it. "How do we calm the population? The noise in the ACA tends to be political," she said. "In the levers that there are to pull in ICHRA, they can have a multi-rating area contribution for that high rating area - and in a different rating area where it didn't go up, they can maintain cost structure."
That kind of multi-variable contribution modeling - isolating a 13 percent rate increase to the geography where it actually occurred rather than absorbing it across the whole employer population - is not something a platform does automatically. It requires a consultant who understands the tool and has the relationship to have the conversation. That is where the broker's position is defensible. That is also, she implied, where the gap between superusers and the defensive cohort becomes commercially decisive.
The deeper structural argument Thompson made is about data and loyalty. Under traditional group insurance, an employer's claims experience underwrites their future renewal - creating a feedback loop that benefits the carrier and the administrator, not the individual employee or their broker. ICHRA severs that link.
"The only way we drive improvement in healthcare is we get the person who actually utilizes the healthcare to be empowered to make the decision of which carrier they're going to choose," she said.
Whether that empowerment ultimately strengthens or weakens the broker's position depends entirely on whether the broker is in the room when those decisions get made and whether the agreement they signed two years earlier still gives them the right to be there.