Holiday preparations should include a cyber coverage check

Year-end staffing gaps and Black Friday sales pressure give agents reason to revisit clients’ cyber controls and coverage, says AmTrust's Courtney Hans
Holiday preparations should include a cyber coverage check
CYBER
By Gia Snape
Nov 19, 2026

Small businesses heading into Black Friday could lose access to critical technology during their busiest trading period and discover their cyber insurance does not cover the disruption.

However, businesses do not need a Black Friday sales surge to face greater cyber exposure during the holidays. Employees rushing to clear year-end work or covering for absent colleagues can let routine checks slip, giving attackers an opening even at companies whose trading patterns barely change.

Courtney Hans (pictured), vice president of cyber services at AmTrust Financial Services, said agents should widen their holiday risk conversations beyond seasonal retailers.

“Even a business that is not seasonal, that isn’t seeing any particular increase in business or activity around this period, is still staffed by humans. Humans are feeling busier during these times,” Hans told Insurance Business.

Read more: H&M says it's investigating hacking claims as retail cyber risks spread

Holiday shortcuts create openings for fraud

Vacations leave businesses with fewer staff, while employees covering colleagues’ responsibilities may be distracted or tempted to bypass checks to meet year-end deadlines. Travel can also bring unfamiliar remote access arrangements.

Meanwhile, AI makes fraudulent requests harder to distinguish from legitimate correspondence, including messages that imitate a vendor’s writing style. “It used to be very easy to spot a phishing email. The grammar was bad, the branding looked really off. It would kind of scream fake in your face,” Hans said. “Now, with AI, tone can be mimicked, branding can be copied.”

Businesses should verify unusual requests through a separate communication channel. A change in payment instructions should prompt a phone call rather than a reply to the suspicious email. Deepfakes warrant awareness, she added, although ordinary phishing is more likely to confront the average business.

“The nature of the game for threat actors hasn’t necessarily changed, but the speed and scale have,” Hans said. “People used to think, ‘I’m a small business. I’m not really a target.’

“But small businesses tend to have fewer resources to dedicate to cybersecurity. With AI, it’s no more work to generate 2,000 phishing emails than one, so threat actors can take a shotgun approach and spread their efforts across thousands of targets.”

Supplier dependencies in the spotlight

At the same time, cyber events without any malicious attack behind them also present a significant exposure. The November 12-14 Microsoft outage, which disrupted workplaces in the US and worldwide, highlighted businesses’ dependencies on third-party systems and vendors.

In the wake of that outage, Hans encouraged businesses to ask their agents what business interruption coverage looks like under their particular policy, including what constitutes a covered event and whether they must provide proof of loss.

“The Microsoft outage wasn’t necessarily a cyber issue, but it shows how critical suppliers that many of us use can become unavailable, whether through a cyberattack or an operational hiccup,” she said.

Read more: Microsoft 365 outage loss estimates range from minimal to $700 million

Hans recommended keeping an inventory of critical suppliers, their contacts and the company data they access. Businesses should understand suppliers’ contractual breach-notification obligations and plan how to operate when those providers are unavailable.

Before the holiday rush, agents can ask clients which provider’s failure would stop trading, how staff would communicate without their usual email platform and whether an alternative process has been agreed with the people covering absences.

Preventative actions key before a breach or outage

Finally, agents can direct clients to preventive services available through their insurers. Hans said AmTrust offers policyholders an email security review and advisory support. Her priorities include multifactor authentication and removing unused accounts, alongside testing backups and reviewing remote access.

Businesses with limited budgets may already have protections available within software they use. Checking email access settings and establishing clear rules for working remotely can help address vulnerabilities introduced when employees travel or use personal devices to access company resources.

A short incident response plan should identify who to call and provide contact details. Hans urged employees to report suspected mistakes promptly, without fear of being shamed. Suspected payment fraud requires immediate action.

“If you feel that you have sent a fraudulent payment, you’ve got to act quickly,” Hans said. “Contact the bank, contact your insurance provider. The sooner you move, the more likely it may be that you could claw some of those funds back.”

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.