In our latest Leaders Network Transformation Roundtable, four insurance leaders speak out on adoption gaps, responsible AI and vendor dependency. Experts from Heffernan Insurance Brokers, Crawford & Company, Jimcor Agencies and WTW cover whether insurance transformation improves the policyholder experience, adoption of customer-facing tools, responsible AI and security, vendor consolidation risk and what separates a transformed insurer.
00:00 - Daryl Beaton: The gap is not just deployment. Um, it's the success that depends on where the people are using or trusting the tool.
00:06 - Kate Grasman: The one capability that separates us is our people.
00:10 - Kristen Skender: We've sacrificed speed for security and accuracy in our deployments.
00:15 - Rob Evans: don't think the leaders three to five years from now will be companies that have automated the most decisions. They'll be uh the ones that have gotten the best at continuously improving decisions.
00:26 - Paul Lucas: Hello everyone and welcome to our latest Leaders Network Digital Transformation Roundtable. Of course, this group consisting of some of the biggest names across the insurance transformation space meets monthly and the last session looked at the human and governance cost of transformation, drobs, ROI measurement, shadow AI. This edition moves to the customer facing side where the all that internal investment is actually changing what policy holders and clients experience. And for our discussion today, we welcome Daryl Beaton, Director of Underwriting at WTW, Kristen Skender, Chief Growth Officer and Senior Vice President Brokerage at Jimcor Agencies, Rob Evans, Director Claim Process Technology at Crawford and Company, and Kate Grasman, CIO at Heffernan Insurance Brokers. Uh so welcome everyone and to get us started, I would love to know is the transformation happening inside underwriting and claims actually translating into a better experience for the end policy holder or is most of the benefit still internal? Um, what's your view? Kate, I'll start with you.
01:36 - Kate Grasman: You know, I'd actually say it's both because, you know, ultimately at Heffernan, we care most about our customer and the transformation is helping us because we've been able to improve some of our internal processes, our internal workflows, and what that's done, it's actually enabled us to as we've optimized those internal processes, now we can actually take more time to support our customers. And so I think it's a benefit uh both sides.
02:02 - Paul Lucas: Okay. So, a win-win. Kirsty, are you in agreement? I mean, the speed that has to have benefited the policy holder, doesn't it?
02:10 - Kristen Skender: Absolutely. Our speed and how quickly we can turn things around has improved significantly with regard to clearance, triage, reviewing, and releasing quotes. We're utilizing drag and drop technology as well as email intake inbox as where possible as well to improve that for the end user. So, all that said, I still think that most of the benefit is happening internally for our team on speed and efficiency and where they can use their time other places.
02:38 - Paul Lucas: It seems like everybody's on that sort of win-win trajectory, Daryl, but I'd love to know from your perspective, is it even possible to track these things?
02:47 - Daryl Beaton: It is easier and in my opinion, easier internally um because those cost savings are easily to quantify um in that initial risk can be managed. Now, when we get to the external part of it, it probably is a little bit more difficult to make that connection point to those savings and to that efficiency that you bring to the customer.
03:10 - Paul Lucas: Okay. And what is the reason for that?
03:13 - Daryl Beaton: Um I think because again it again it internally it's a whole lot easier. I mean, we can talk about submission flow and where that leads into a quote, to a bind um and then to the process after that. But it's that's easy to track internally, but what did cause that quote to come in? Was it because of my efficiency or was it because of the need? And I think that's where the disconnect is coming in to where we're not necessarily seeing what that benefit of my internal investment is doing and really translating that to the externals.
03:45 - Paul Lucas: Overall, Rob, I would guess this has to be helping reduce admin work, doesn't it?
03:51 - Rob Evans: Yeah. Uh we're seeing a nice blend of internal and external benefits. Internally being AI taking some of the heavy uh data load um document summarization, routine workflows, um, so that the adjusters in particular can provide that empathetic support. And that really matters because our surveys consistently show that um, the things that really matter are very human things, relationships, courtesy, responsiveness as drivers of satisfaction. So uh, the technology and the AI is allowing the adjusters to focus on those human elements which benefits the claim process, the insured and the claimant.
04:38 - Paul Lucas: Okay. Well, it seems as though that these investments are perhaps paying off, but I'd love to know exactly where those investments are being made. Where are carriers and brokers making those investments in in customer-facing digital tools? Is it self-service? Is it instant quoting? Is it claims tracking? And indeed is adoption actually meeting expectations for these things? Uh, so Kristen, what are you seeing?
04:58 - Kristen Skender: We're absolutely interested in all of the areas that you mentioned, but we've focused first on expanded product and market access and secondly on reducing friction for our clients' experience with a wrap around of a human element. With all of that said, adoption rates have not been what we expected on some of this. So clients are not utilizing as frequently the tools that we had expected. And so that requires us to take a closer look at whether it be marketing, training, internal buy-in and adoption rates. How do we really convert the investments that we're making into an ROI?
05:38 - Paul Lucas: Okay. Well, let me pick up on that point around adoption rates with you, Daryl, as well. The uptake, I'm assuming it must differ depending on the customer, mustn't it?
05:48 - Daryl Beaton: I think that's the differentiator right there to be able to understand the tool and how effective that tool is because it is going to differ by transaction, by customer need. The gap is not just deployment, um, it's the success that depends on where the people are using or trusting the tool, I think, ultimately at the end of the day, and whether they choose to use it or incorporate it into every day, their success life. That's the difficult part to see, I think, to even what Kristen's saying right there. What is in that customer's mind? What does that customer need? Our customers are different. Our customer needs are different. So how do you translate that effective tool that you know can be effective into success ultimately to the customer?
06:34 - Paul Lucas: All right. And is it that, you know, the implementation of these tools, Rob, from your perspective, is that reducing some of the friction?
06:41 - Rob Evans: Yeah, one of the ways uh that we're seeing it is uh just even with things like texting, uh sometimes with the initial submission of the claim, there's some information that may be missing or maybe there's a development that um because we're using uh just another medium to communicate that uh we're getting information sooner that gets us then to the appropriate resource sooner. Um and so, you know, I think the thing is with all of this is not uh so much uh making digital adoption the objective, but rather a better customer experience. So we really feel like the winners will be those to know when technology should handle the interaction versus when the human should.
07:32 - Paul Lucas: I suppose the one question that I haven't asked, Kate, and I'll point this at you if you don't mind, is are these tools actually good enough?
07:42 - Kate Grasman: At this point, I don't think all of them are good enough. I mean, if we think about the role of a broker and the role of an underwriter, you know, insurance is complex, right? And when customers call us, they're looking for information. They're looking to make sure that all of their needs are covered and then they're not surprised when a claim comes in. So I would say yes, I am with Kristen. We are trying to reduce the friction, you know, for our customers, but I haven't seen a number of tools that have been able to do that completely. Um, but we have been able to reduce some of the work internally. So for instance, now we have endorsements. We can get those easily. We can do policy checks easily. Um, getting certificates of insurance. But you know, again, that just gives us more time to actually work with our customers in order to provide the right level of, you know, advice on what insurance they should have.
08:40 - Paul Lucas: And another factor, I suppose, that I haven't really touched on when it comes to adopting more of these third party and indeed AI driven tools is that cyber security risk within the technology stack because that that's grown as well, hasn't it? Um, [sighs and gasps] Daryl, how seriously is that risk being weighed against the potential speed of adoption?
08:57 - Daryl Beaton: I think very seriously today in regards to the concerns that we hear publicly in the news, wherever the case may be, the rules and regs that define us and how we might be able to use AI, the hallucinations we hear about and everything to that point. I do believe it has slowed it down. I do believe our talk, our initiatives and our goals are very lofty, very aggressive in in implementing AI today, but it is still at a slower pace because of that.
09:25 - Paul Lucas: Okay. Would you agree with that overall, Rob? Do you think that responsibility is being taken into account properly?
09:33 - Rob Evans: Yeah. Uh, we're seeing the conversation mature from can we deploy AI to can we prove we deployed it responsibly? Um, people are taking a lot deeper look into the whole technology ecosystem as a whole. Where does the data go? Who has access? Uh, things like fourth party dependencies. Um, seen some research of some, uh, 60% of large companies, uh, from 1,600 senior executives that had been surveyed are slowing, pausing or pulling back on AI deployment this year. Um, and you know, I think, uh, it's not so much about whether AI is creating value, it's whether you can defend how you used it uh to your customer, regulator, board, or potentially even a court.
10:25 - Paul Lucas: Guessing Kate, for you, you're a CIO, this must have made your job a little bit difficult, hasn't it?
10:32 - Kate Grasman: You know, honestly, AI has made the job of a CIO and CISO incredibly different difficult, you know, not to mention, you know, what's coming with quantum computing and tensors, right? So um when I look at AI, I'm with Rob here. I agree that at Heffernan, you know, we are really implementing AI in a way that's helping our employees and helping our customers, but we're also doing it responsibly, right? So I feel like, you know, we've really moved the needle. We're not saying should we be using AI, where we're using it is what's important. And so, you know, what we're really working on is we have our resources really wanting all this technology. And so what we've put in place is all I'm asking our users to do is, hey, could you just fill out the form? Can I do a security assessment? If I say no, you can't use it, right? And we're watching, you know, what's happening there again. I believe in harnessing the creativity of all of our employees, so I don't want to say no. I just want to make sure it's responsible.
11:36 - Paul Lucas: Sense, but I guess, Kristen, at some point, perhaps some sacrifices have to be made along the way. You can't always have both, maybe?
11:47 - Kristen Skender: Absolutely. We've sacrificed speed for security and accuracy in our deployments. We're hoping that the long-term pays off, that the adoption internally and externally will be a more trusted solution, but as we go forward, we're going to have to kind of weigh having both, as you mentioned, speed and security.
12:08 - Paul Lucas: Okay. Well, let me uh I guess change gears a little bit and let's talk a little bit about the sort of the vendor and partner technology consolidation that has sort of continued throughout the space. I'd love to know what are the risks right now of becoming overly dependent on a perhaps a small number of external providers for your core functions. I mean there's got to be some huge risks involved, Rob.
12:30 - Rob Evans: You know, there is tremendous value in consolidating around strategic technology partners, but there's a point at which efficiency can become a concentration risk. So I think about risk in three areas. You've got operational, financial, and strategic. So with operational, you know, everybody can be maybe using the same cloud providers and that can have a cascading effect if something goes wrong there. From a financial perspective, you know, as your dependency increases, you can lose negotiating leverage. And from a strategic standpoint, the more deeply embedded that one major provider becomes in your core operations, your road map can become dependent on theirs. So I think the vendor strategy has evolved from a procurement discussion to one of a resilience discussion to where we're not asking who's the best partner. It's also how dependent are we prepared to become on that partner.
13:40 - Paul Lucas: Makes a lot of sense and I guess another thing to kind of take into account, Kate, would be whether or not the this consolidation is finished.
13:47 - Kate Grasman: Yeah, I mean I don't think the consolidation is near being finished. I'm beginning to see a number of vendors. They all look the same to me. So, you know, our strategy at has really been about, you know, picking a technology and then implementing it and my goal is to hold on to it for about three years, right? So if I can hold on to it for three years, that reduces the amount of change in our organization. Change is the hardest thing to get. And so if I can have a couple of tools that are working really well, I just need to be ready to pivot, you know, if something markedly changes in the industry or with that particular vendor. I also, you know, manage my contracts, right? So there are ways to build your contracts so that if a company does go out of business or gets sold, you have some protections in place. And so that's what we're doing. But you know, we're placing bets. We're consolidating with a couple of vendors and we just have to be ready to pivot when it's necessary.
14:44 - Paul Lucas: Insightful strategy. And Kristen, I guess, you know, a take like that, it does lead to savings, doesn't it?
14:51 - Kristen Skender: Absolutely. I think that there could be further consolidation with regard to the third party vendors that would bring out some of the best solutions and eliminate some redundancies. And I also agree with what Rob had shared that a deeper dialogue has to take place before we take on a third party contract regarding our alignment, future values, how are we going to collaborate and the vision on what we want to co-create. So it's a deeper, more meaningful conversation than we've had in the past when we consider a software partner.
15:24 - Paul Lucas: I Daryl, I'll turn to you if I can just to get some insight on how deeply you're thinking. What are the key questions that you're thinking about when choosing vendors?
15:34 - Daryl Beaton: I love what Kate said and that that ability to pivot and yet have her time frame to be able to pivot is key for any of us. I do think in this consolidation, merger and acquisition stages, do the customers actually truly receive the promised functionality in their operating context or do they become dependent on a vendor that is slow to integrate and enhance? So that to me is the worry I have when I see the consolidation is how is that the systems integrated to benefit all the customers with the most effective model?
16:08 - Paul Lucas: Well, I always like to finish with a little bit of a forward looking question. So I'd love to get the views from all of you. Let's look forward if we can three to five years out, shall we say? What's the one capability that you would say separates a genuinely transformed insurance business from one that's simply automated its existing processes. Kate, what do you think?
16:28 - Kate Grasman: You know, honestly, the one capability that separates us is our people, right? Our own human potential of our ability to change and transform the industry. You know, for me, it's really not about the tool. It's how we our people can leverage the tools, bring their own creativity, and then basically service our customers. So for me, it's people.
16:50 - Paul Lucas: The people and Kristen, from your view, what does the wholesaler of the future look like?
16:56 - Kristen Skender: The wave of AI and technology enhancement is here. So it comes down to who's best positioned to not be just treading water or trying to keep your head above water, but who's actually swimming forward and riding that wave. So for us, I don't know all of the attributes or maybe to narrow it to one other than that we're the one surfing the wave at the end.
17:18 - Paul Lucas: Uh makes a lot of sense. And Daryl, I mean, how do we make better decisions across the business going forward?
17:27 - Daryl Beaton: Um that that's the challenge really for any of us that we sit there right now. It the challenge is the legacy systems, interfaces, proprietary dependencies, data, I mean, functioning as we see it today, but it is adopting to the change that helps us be able to take those tasks to where we can make better decisions at the end of the day. AI is going to help us get to that point to where I can make better decisions as an underwriter. I can make better decisions at the end of the day, and we're headed down that path um today with where we're headed. So I see great progress, great effort, and great success with adopting um the innovation that that sits in front of us today, even with the challenges that we have.
18:16 - Paul Lucas: Right. So we've seen a vote for people. We've had one for AI as well. Rob, in your view, what's the what's the differentiator here?
18:24 - Rob Evans: So uh going on some of the themes that have already been mentioned, uh I think the decision intelligence or the proactiveness of that uh is going to be a differentiator. Um finding transformation that helps make better decisions and the continuous learning from the outcomes will be important. I don't think the leaders three to five years from now will be companies that have automated the most decisions. They'll be uh the ones that have gotten the best at continuously improving decisions.
18:52 - Paul Lucas: I love it. A great way to wrap things up. Another brilliant group discussion. Remember, many of these faces and others will be joining us again in a month's time, so don't miss out. Stay tuned right here on Insurance Business TV.