Richard Wood (pictured), now EVP Head of property at Westfield Specialty, walked into Lloyd's 40 years ago and felt as though he had stepped into a spaceship. He remembers a strange, inside-out Richard Rogers building that everybody was talking about, and a room so loud that conversations about the football, the rugby and the risks being placed carried on right behind him.
Wood was in his early twenties and worked on the box, which doubled as his office. On his first or second day he asked a colleague where the bin was and was told he was sitting in it, while the colleague screwed up paper and chucked it over his shoulder.
With no other office to go to, underwriters went to and from Lloyd's every day and got to know everyone on their half of the floor. "That gives you an incredible sense of collectivity about the marketplace," Wood said. "Probably we've lost some of that today." Technology and digitalisation have changed how people work, and Wood said the rapport that came from living on the box does not develop in the same way.
Business was done face to face, and the market would only trade with people it knew. A stranger walking in would be asked who they were, and being a Lloyd's broker carried real kudos. Barriers to entry look lower now, and he suspects there are far more Lloyd's brokers than in 1986, many of whom can reach the market without ever walking round the Room. He is clear that is not a criticism, and thinks plenty of the relationships formed in those years still exist today. Selling a Lloyd’s policy was harder then, with question marks over the market’s capital and longevity, and Wood remembers strong, respected leaders among underwriters and brokers alike.
Underwriters have perhaps become a bit less collective as businesses have grown bigger, with the collective instinct under pressure as a result. Wood still gets a buzz walking in, and even a quiet market is worth the trip for the people you bump into. He said the refurbished underwriting room looks impressive and has a bit more of a club feel, but he questions how much underwriting still happens there compared with business being taken away.
Exposures were once calculated in ledgers on the box, and underwriters often did not know what they held. "40 years ago, nobody knew or considered risk-adjusted pricing. Nobody considered adequacy of pricing." Decisions sat with the underwriter and were, he said, largely unregulated, and Lloyd's could not be run that way at its current size.
Wood said the way the market is run and regulated is completely different now, and it had to be. He recalls people getting annoyed about Lloyd's asking too many questions, but asks whose business Lloyd's is. It is the capital providers' business, clearly, but "it's the Lloyd's franchise. It's the Lloyd's licensing. It's the Lloyd's infrastructure that allows everybody to trade", and he argues that protecting that, including the central fund, is for the greater good.
Technology has also made it easier for brokers to send submissions out widely, and Wood said the connection between client, broker and underwriter is less personal as a result. "It's turned more into a transaction, and transactions come and transactions go."
He liked some of the old intensity, with brokers queuing at the box for hours and underwriters making on-the-spot decisions they had to stand by. A broker could prepare for a day or three and knew how to steer the conversation. The underwriter did not. "It's still a great marketplace," Wood said. "It's just very different."
The fundamentals of underwriting have not moved, with the need to make a profit through the cycle, soft or hard, as constant as ever. His concern for anyone starting out today is AI, which he said he does not understand well enough. He worries about underwriters putting a 300-page survey report through it and getting an appraisal in minutes.
"It took me two days to read that 20 years ago, and I don't need to read it every year, but I read it," he said. "So how are you going to learn?" Whilst he does not know the answer, he believes people are bright and will work it out as time and technology goes on.
Wood is not sure the building that struck him as a spaceship will still be standing in 40 years, though he expects the regulatory framework to remain. He also expects ups and downs, and believes the market will be in good shape for another 40 years if tradition and the entrepreneurial infrastructure stay together with whatever the future looks like.