Pothole damage claims at Tesco Insurance have already passed last year’s full-year total, and each claim is now costing more.
New data from the insurer shows claims between January and September were 50% higher than in the same period of 2025. The total value of payouts rose 77% year-on-year.
The average payout climbed 18%, from £3,299 to £3,904. That suggests potholes are causing more serious, costly damage to vehicles.
Plymouth recorded more pothole damage claims than any other UK town or city so far this year. Peterborough and Tonbridge complete the top three, followed by Leicester, Northampton, Guildford, Colchester, Derby, Nottingham and Belfast.
Kirkwall, Lancaster and Bolton logged the fewest claims.
The ranking marks a change. Peterborough had recorded the most claims every year since 2020, Which? reported, and it also led the January-to-May figures.
“Potholes have become an all too familiar hazard on Britain’s roads, and our latest figures show the problem is showing no signs of easing,” Alex Cross, chief customer officer at Tesco Insurance, said.
“We’ve already settled more pothole damage claims this year than we did in the whole of 2025, highlighting the scale of the problem facing drivers.
“The cost of repairs is climbing too, with the average claim now costing almost £4,000, a significant bill for any driver to face out of their own pocket.
“With darker evenings and winter weather setting in, potholes are likely to become both more common and harder to spot, so we’d urge drivers to take extra care on the roads over the coming months and remain alert to changing road conditions.”
The figures build on earlier warnings. Tesco Insurance settled 12% more pothole claims in January alone than in the whole of the second half of 2025, Insurance Business reported.
Aviva separately found the average pothole claim costs £3,863, and one in four ends in a write-off. That average is 54 times the £72 cost of fixing a pothole, according to the 2025 ALARM survey. Its analysis covered January 2023 to January 2026.
Road conditions are unlikely to improve quickly. The latest ALARM survey put the repair backlog in England and Wales at £18.62 billion, a job that would take 12 years at current funding. Government funding for local roads in England reached nearly £1.6 billion in 2025/26, a £500 million uplift.
Councils reject most claims. BBC figures reported by Auto Express show they turn down about three in four pothole claims.
For brokers, that may steer more clients towards their own insurers when damage occurs. The data could also inform conversations about excess levels, no-claims bonus protection and how to document damage with photos and repair quotes.
Winter may add pressure. The insurer noted that heavy rain, frost and freezing temperatures can speed up road deterioration, while darker mornings and evenings make potholes harder to spot.
Tesco Insurance has shared five tips for drivers. They include slowing down on poorly maintained roads, keeping a safe distance and checking tyre pressure regularly. The insurer also urges care after heavy rain or flooding, and avoiding sudden braking or swerving.