Home insurance confidence masks gaps as 75% unsure what underinsurance means

Paymentshield research finds most homeowners feel confident but few understand underinsurance
Home insurance confidence masks gaps as 75% unsure what underinsurance means
PROPERTY
By Jonalyn Cueto
20 Nov 2026

Most UK homeowners say they have no worries about their home insurance. New research suggests that confidence may not match their understanding of what the cover includes.

Paymentshield found 54% of UK adults with home insurance initially said they had “no particular concerns” about their policy. Opinium surveyed 2,000 UK adults for the insurer in September 2026. Paymentshield said the findings show where advisers can add value by helping clients understand their cover and identify potential gaps.

Gaps in understanding

Only 25% of policyholders are confident they understand “underinsurance”. That means cover that falls short of the full cost of rebuilding a property or replacing possessions. Three quarters are not sure.

The problem is widespread. RebuildCostASSESSMENT estimates 70% of UK properties are underinsured. On average, they are insured for 66% of the cover needed for a full rebuild, Insurance Business reported.

For those owners, a claim may not cover the full rebuild cost, leaving them to fund the shortfall. The same report said 71% of brokers saw more claims reduced because of underinsurance in 2025.

Among those surveyed, 21% know their circumstances have changed significantly since their last policy review, 25% of those who remortgaged said nobody checked whether their home insurance was still suitable, 20% are not confident they understand what their policy covers, and 57% wrongly expect accidental damage to be covered as standard when it usually requires additional cover.

Even high-profile risks have prompted little action. After wildfire coverage this year, 50% of policyholders have not checked whether their buildings or contents cover would be adequate if they lost their home.

Wildfire activity has also grown. The Environment Agency has recorded 110 wildfires on protected sites in 2026, and 2025 was the UK’s worst wildfire year on record, with more than 47,879 hectares burned. Insurers also paid a record £6.1 billion in property claims in 2025, according to the Association of British Insurers.

Younger owners want advice

Confidence varies sharply by age. While 72% of boomers report no concerns, that falls to 39% of millennials and 30% of Gen Z.

Younger customers are also more open to guidance. In total, 68% of Gen Z respondents want advice to ensure their home is properly protected, against 54% of millennials and 32% of Gen X.

Willingness to pay also differs. Some 59% of Gen Z would pay more for peace of mind that they have the right cover, compared with 55% of millennials and 39% of Gen X.

“The biggest risk for many homeowners isn’t necessarily having no insurance at all. It’s believing they have the right cover in place for their needs,” Nasar Hussain, associate director of intermediated household at Paymentshield, said.

“Underinsurance is a good example. It can have devastating financial consequences, yet three quarters of homeowners aren’t confident they understand what it means.”

For brokers and advisers, the findings suggest an opening for routine conversations. “Younger homeowners in particular appear to be more open to receiving professional guidance, but conversations around home insurance shouldn’t be limited to any specific age group,” Hussain said.

“A simple question about underinsurance, changing circumstances or whether someone has reviewed their cover recently can open up a valuable conversation and help ensure clients have the protection they need.”

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB UK.