Hot 100

Top trailblazers

The eighth annual class of the IBA Hot 100 represents the top insurance leaders in the US in 2023, featuring the best in the industry across all specialties and markets. These are the people who have influenced, driven initiatives, and plotted the course of the sector over the past 12 months. 

So, what distinguishes these leaders from the rest? 

For the first six years of his career, James McNitt assumed a variety of roles. Upon finishing his MBA, he set out to find a new challenge and was offered a job at Risk Placement Services (RPS) in the wholesale space. Back then, he had no knowledge of the industry, no prospective clients, and no relationships with underwriters. 

“To quote a great business book title and common adage, ‘The harder you work, the luckier you get’ ”
 James McNitt, Risk Placement Services 

 

 

McNitt told his mentor about the opportunity, who dismissively retorted, “You’ll never make it.” 

“That was the only motivation I needed,” says McNitt. He embraced the challenge and developed the relationships and placements necessary to succeed. 

 

Rising to the top

McNitt, a healthcare practice leader, was one of the top five new business brokers at RPS in 2017 and 2019. He pulled in $4 million in revenue and made it to the IBA Hot 100 in 2022. 

Testimonies from his colleagues illustrate just how highly he is regarded. One says, “He gives us every resource we need to be successful. He must have 48 hours in his day, because he is always available to me and our team. I attribute a lot of my own success to his leadership and rebranding of the practice in the market.” Another team member adds, “It’s so hard to put into words how much work he does, and he does it flawlessly. Working for him is a big treat.” 

Sharing his approach, McNitt explains, “In our industry, every leader needs to think of themselves as a role model. We have a very talented next generation of underwriters and brokers entering the industry, and current industry leaders will have a large impact on the culture that is created by this next cohort. With the increasing complexity of placements, it’s more important than ever that we lead ethically, authentically, and with integrity.” 

And what does he recommend for others interested in making the Hot 100 in future years? “Every single successful person in our industry has one thing in common: they work very hard,” he says. “This has remained true even during the pandemic shutdowns. The hardest-working insurance brokers found ways to create their own success during unpredictable marketplace conditions. 

“To quote a great business book title and common adage, ‘The harder you work, the luckier you get.’” 

Karen Frany, also part of this year’s Hot 100, got her break in the industry via a diversity internship program whilst attending Providence College. 

She explains, “As a first generation Asian-American woman, I initially questioned my ability to rise in corporate America, but I’ve always been taught that hard work leads to success. Being recognized as part of this year’s Hot 100 due to my hard work has certainly surpassed my career expectations.” 

The skillset that Frany, managing director of executive liability at Brown & Brown, feels has enabled her to prosper is her comprehensive knowledge base – as she’s been both an underwriter and broker over the past 15 years. 

“My experience as an underwriter has truly guided my approach as a broker and has served me well over the years”, she says. “By thoroughly understanding my clients’ needs, I can best develop and customize an insurance program best suited for each of their unique risks.” 

Someone who also took an unorthodox route is Andreas Kleiner. The president and CEO of American Modern Insurance Group was educated as an engineer and applied for a job at Munich Re, not knowing what reinsurance was. 

“I never regretted joining the insurance industry. My career has not only greatly shaped who I have become, it has led my family and me to so many exciting places, “explains Kleiner. “So far, we have been able to work and live on four continents. The experiences from living in different cultural environments are simply priceless, and we are very grateful for that.” 

Kleiner’s unconventional path to a career in insurance hasn’t stopped him flourishing and he is part of the Hot 100. And he credits one strategy that’s allowed him to stand out. “We have been able to leave all of our IT and product legacy issues behind through our business transformation project. There are very few larger insurance companies who have achieved that and this is difficult to replicate.” 

“When one person gets success, we have success. There are other wholesalers out there who are cutthroat and compete with one another. For us, if somebody gets a good deal or a win, the whole group gets the win”
 George Sella, Brown & Riding

 

“Your ego is not your amigo” 

Another member of this year’s Hot 100 is Curtis Barton, who joined his father in the industry back in 1997. 

He pursued a wide range of avenues, such as immersing himself in the middle-market commercial sector, doing a lot of alternative risk programs, and establishing himself as a leading salesman. 

And he has maintained that attitude. “Your ego is not your amigo,” explains Barton. “I love that line. I think that means a lot. When they get some success, people tend to get overly proud of themselves, and it clouds their judgment. So, just don’t let your ego get involved. Do what’s right. If you do what’s right consistently, good things will happen.” 

Barton has proactively carved out a career. He placed up to 150 cold calls a day to create a book of business that was sustainable. He dealt with the collapse of the construction market in 2008. And he orchestrated the merger of seven friends’ businesses to ultimately create ALKEME Insurance. 

Now, as CEO of ALKEME Insurance, he oversees a run-rate revenue of close to $100 million, maintains a 94% employee retention rate, and enjoys 13.3% organic growth. “The KPIs [key performance indicators] are there,” he says. “We’re doing a good job of growing 70% of our business in middle-market commercial.” 

One of his colleagues says, “As CEO, he has guided the organization through 15 acquisitions while maintaining double-digit growth. He expanded operations to five additional states. He developed and launched two significant tech plays in a digital MGA with five programs called Brokkrr Insurance Services.” 

Barton pinpoints two factors that have enabled him to make his mark. 

“First, let your people know you’re in the boat with them rowing – you’re willing to do whatever you’re asking them to do. Second, have vision. It’s being able to see beyond the next movie and really look downstream and say, ‘What issues are going to face me in the next 10 years or the next five years?’” 

What would he say to others eager to build a reputation in the industry? “Go around and talk to people in your office – other producers – shadow them, learn from them, and take what you want and leave behind what you don't want and start to form your own path forward,” says Barton. “And we’ve always been niche-focused – that’s the winner. If you’re going to be in this business, you have to be proficient and efficient at what you do. As a salesperson, you need something to differentiate yourself right from the get-go. 

“Ultimately, get good at what you do. Start with education first. Put out a lot of content, content, content. And once people start to see you’re a leader and have a sphere of influence within that space, they’ll start coming to you, and the job gets a lot easier.” 

“Do what’s right. If you do what’s right consistently, good things will happen”
 Curtis Barton, ALKEME Insurance

 

 

Do what you love

After studying insurance at the University of Mississippi, George Sella moved to Los Angeles. He partnered with Chris Brown of Brown & Riding, focusing on the construction sector. 

“I started building a book,” says Sella. “When you’re young, it’s hard to get a good stronghold with some strategic big clients, so Chris Brown, our chairman, mentored me through that process, and he really took me under his wing.” 

Sella’s work life became increasingly challenging. He has overseen growth of up to 60% each year over the past 12 years, and despite being relatively young, he has managed people across a wide variety of age groups and demographics. 

Now, he’s been a shareholder for nine years, and six years ago, he moved to Atlanta to build up his team there, which has grown to 13 people. The company has expanded from three offices to 20, with more than 350 employees. 

Recognized in the 2022 Hot 100, Sella is consistenntly one of the top performers in the firm. 

“[Sella] has contributed greatly to Brown & Riding’s growth and continues to play a leading role in the CPG [construction practice group] and in the firm overall,” says Brown. 

Sella is open about what has allowed him to build such a stellar list of achievements. “It's more about helping other people become successful and seeing other people thrive,” he says. “When one person gets success, we all have success. There are other wholesalers out there who are cutthroat and compete with one another. For us, if somebody gets a good deal or a win, the whole group gets the win.” 

His advice to those embarking on a career in insurance or those who are still relatively early in their journey is to craft a niche. “I always tell people to try to specialize, because our industry is going towards specialization, and to try to specialize in what you’re passionate about and what you enjoy,” he says. 

“You have to wake up every morning and do this as a young person for 40 years, so you want to do what you enjoy and do what gets you excited. I found that everyone who is passionate about what they do, they're wildly more successful than people who just do it for a job.” 

This is also something that resonates with Frany. She’s eager to instill standards and expertise in the younger colleagues who she oversees. “Being entrusted by the Brown & Brown executive team to guide the company's next generation of brokers is what I feel to be a testament to my ongoing diligence and professional growth,” she adds. “I view my professional reputation as inherently linked to my personal reputation. As such, I strive to be a good person, exercise good judgment, work diligently and genuinely care about others.” 

“By thoroughly understanding my clients’ needs, I can best develop and customize an insurance program best suited for each of their unique risks”
Karen Frany, Brown & Brown Karen Frany, Brown & Brown

 

Hot 100

  • Adam Jakubowitz
    Assistant Vice President
    HUB International
  • Akhil Chopra
    Managing Director and Cyber Growth Leader
    Lockton Financial Services
  • Alex Furlong
    National Wholesale Brokerage Practice Leader
    One80 Intermediaries
  • Alka Manaktala
    Managing Partner
    Insurance Office of America
  • Amy O'Brien
    Vice President – Carrier Practice Sales
    Gallagher Bassett
  • Amy Shore
    Chief Customer Officer and Executive Vice President
    Nationwide
  • Andrew Silva
    Senior Financial Lines Manager
    Woodruff Sawyer
  • Anna Tan
    Head, Excess Casualty Wholesale
    Navigators, a brand of The Hartford
  • Anne Anastasi
    First Vice President
    Old Republic Title
  • Anton Rosandic
    Co-Founder and Chief Operating Officer
    ALKEME Insurance
  • Ashley Engl, ACSR, GBDS, VBS
    Employee Benefits Client Success Account Executive
    Lawley
  • Bill Creedon
    Global Head, Construction
    Willis Towers Watson
  • Bill Gatewood
    Corporate Senior Vice President and National Personal Insurance Practice Leader
    Burns & Wilcox
  • Bridget Gainer
    Global Head, Public Affairs and Policy
    Aon
  • Bruce Peddle
    President
    Jencap Insurance Services
  • Bryan Clark
    President
    Gorst & Compass Insurance
  • Christiana Flaherty
    Senior Marine Underwriter
    The Hartford
  • Christopher Alviggi
    Managing Director and Environmental Practice Group Leader
    NFP
  • Clinton Anderson
    President, National Specialty Practice
    HUB International
  • Cory Schilling
    Executive Managing Director and MGA and Program Solutions Leader
    Aon
  • Coryn Thalmann, CIC, CIW
    Chief Executive Officer and Chief Operating Officer
    Jimcor Agencies
  • Daniel Ginden
    Chief Everything Officer
    Scottish American
  • Danielle Larsen
    Head, Underwriting Services
    Everest Insurance
  • Dave Obenauer
    Chief Executive Officer
    CRC Group
  • David M. Barnes
    Senior Vice President and Transactional Liability Practice Lead
    CAC Specialty
  • Davis Moore
    Vice Chairman, Brokerage of Amwins
    Amwins
  • Deborah Fox
    Vice President
    NFP
  • Denise Campbell, CPM
    Senior Vice President, Client Executive
    Marsh
  • Emily Golecki
    Surety Specialist
    Florida Surety Bonds
  • Emma Ye, ASA, MAAA
    Vice President, Risk
    At-Bay
  • Eric Goldberg
    Vice President, Texas Market Leader
    IMA Select
  • Errica Rivera
    Culture and Inclusion Lead
    State Auto Insurance
  • Garrett Droege
    Director, Innovation + Strategy
    IMA Financial Group
  • Gary Leonard
    Executive Vice President and National Director, Account Management
    Gallagher Bassett
  • George Woods
    Head, US P&C Broker Sales Management
    Swiss Re
  • Greg Barats
    Chief Executive Officer and President; Global Head of IoT – Munich Re
    HSB
  • Greg Gunn, CIC
    Chief Executive Officer and President
    Gunn-Mowery
  • Gregory Chaples
    Vice President, Property and Casualty
    Capstone Group
  • Jacob Ingerslev
    Head, Cyber and Tech Underwriting
    Tokio Marine HCC
  • Janet Jordan-Foster
    Executive Vice President and Head, Primary Casualty
    AXIS
  • Jason Rodriguez
    Chief Executive Officer
    Prominent Insurance Services
  • Jeff Cunningham
    Vice President and Senior Broker
    UCPM
  • Jeffrey Duncan
    Executive Vice President, Commercial Lines
    AmTrust
  • Jeffrey T. Benson Jr.
    Managing Partner
    Prominent Insurance Services
  • Jenni Lee Crocker
    Senior Vice President Agency, Operations and Growth
    PCF Insurance Services
  • Jessica Scelzi
    Chief Commercial Officer
    The Zebra
  • Jill M. Kizyma
    Area Vice President and Senior Director – Public Sector Practice
    Gallagher
  • Jim Untiedt, CPCU, ARM, CRIS
    Construction Practice Leader
    PentaRisk
  • Jody Yee
    Global Industry Solutions Director – Technology, Media and Telecommunications
    Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty
  • Jordan Tamchin
    Senior Vice President and Tax Insurance Practice Leader
    CAC Specialty
  • Jude DiBattista
    Head, Casualty
    GuideOne Insurance
  • Karen S. Williams
    Senior Managing Director
    Risk Strategies Company
  • Karin Venegas
    Managing Director – Business Insurance
    Higginbotham
  • Karl Henley
    Executive Vice President and Partner
    SeibertKeck Insurance Partners
  • Kyle Burnett
    Senior Vice President, E&S Property
    Swiss Re
  • Lael Chappell
    Chief Market and Business Development Officer
    Desq
  • Larry Fine
    Management Liability Coverage Leader
    Willis Towers Watson
  • Lisa Gentile
    Vice President
    Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • Mark Engel
    Managing Director and Corporate Vice President
    RB Jones
  • Matthew McLellan
    Managing Director
    Marsh
  • Michael Gordon
    Vice President
    Marsh Mclennan Agency
  • Michael Gruetzmacher
    Head, Alternative Risk Transfer and Innovation
    Aon
  • Michael J. Sicard
    Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
    USI Insurance Services
  • Michael Palotay
    President
    Tokio Marine HCC
  • Morgan Cook
    Vice President
    Brown & Brown
  • Nancy Bewlay
    Chief Executive Officer, Reinsurance
    AXA XL
  • Ngozi Nnaji
    Founder and Managing Partner
    Ako
  • Norman Ives
    Cannabis Practice Leader
    Amwins
  • Pam Humphrey
    Global Client Executive
    Chubb
  • Paul Roberts
    Senior Director, Education and Market Development
    Word & Brown General Agency
  • Peter R. Taffae, MLIS, CFE
    Managing Director
    ExecutivePerils
  • Phillip Lane
    Vice President and Partner
    Insurance Office of America
  • Ray Deaton
    Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer
    Commercial Insurance Solutions
  • Ricky Bryan
    Executive Vice President and Director, Houston Energy
    IMA Financial Group
  • Rob Carney
    Chief Executive Officer, Retirement and Benefits Solutions
    CRC Group
  • Scott Konrad
    North American Nonprofit Practice Leader
    HUB International
  • Shawn Woedl
    Chief Executive Officer and President
    REInsurePro
  • Sonji K. Grandy
    National Personal Lines Co-Manager, DE&I
    The Liberty Company Insurance Brokers
  • Steve Brown
    Chief Executive Officer
    Hoffman Brown Company
  • Susan Johnson
    Chief Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Officer
    The Hartford
  • Teresa Milano
    Vice President, Management Liability
    Woodruff Sawyer
  • Thomas Reagan
    Managing Director and US Cyber Practice Leader
    Marsh
  • Tony McIntosh
    President; Executive Vice President and Partner
    Aura Risk Management & Insurance Services; The Liberty Company Insurance Brokers
  • Tyler Asher
    President, Independent Agent Distribution
    Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • Wes Becknell
    Vice President, Business Development
    Rocklake Insurance Group
  • Yiana Stavrakis
    President
    Monarch E & S Insurance Services

Methodology

Starting in August 2022, Insurance Business America invited insurance professionals from across the country to nominate their most exceptional leaders for the eighth annual Hot 100 list. After receiving hundreds of nominations, IBA narrowed the list down to 100 movers and shakers whose contributions have helped shape the insurance industry over the past 12 months. 

From innovators at the forefront of change to leaders who are transforming the way the industry does business, this year’s Hot 100 list represents the best the industry has to offer.  

The IBA Hot 100 report is proudly supported by the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (the Big “I”). 

 

About the supporting association

Founded in 1896, the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (the Big “I”) is the nation’s oldest and largest national association of independent insurance agents and brokers, representing more than 25,000 agency locations united under the Trusted Choice brand. Trusted Choice independent agents offer consumers all types of insurance – property, casualty, life, health, employee benefit plans, and retirement products – from a variety of insurance companies. The Big “I” strives to provide independent insurance agents and brokers with a sustainable competitive advantage in the insurance marketplace by equipping members with tools and resources and providing advocacy and support to maintain excellence in business and customer service.