At small businesses, the confidence gap during open enrollment runs deeper than most benefit summaries show. New Justworks survey data finds 18% of employees at businesses with fewer than 100 people say their current health insurance does not meet their needs well. That compares with 10% at larger companies. Fifteen percent are not confident they understand their available plans well enough to choose one, versus 8% at larger firms. Just 27% feel very confident navigating that choice, against 41% at larger employers.
The survey was conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Justworks in November 2026, polling 2,014 US adults. The small-business comparison figures come from the press release accompanying the report. The full report covers general population findings only. Justworks is a payroll and benefits platform that sells directly to small businesses.
The gap sits against a cost environment that has been grinding against small-business clients for years. Gusto data from earlier in 2026 puts the median health insurance premium at small businesses at $8,743 per employee, up 31% since 2022. Employees paying more for coverage they do not fully understand are more likely to default to last year’s plan without comparing options.
The survey also captures where employees go when they cannot get answers. Fifty-two percent of Americans who chose or plan to choose health insurance through open enrollment have used AI at some point in that process. The most common uses were comparing plan differences (23%), understanding potential costs (21%), explaining insurance terms (21%), and identifying questions to ask (19%).
Comfort with AI assistance is high: 65% of respondents overall said they would be comfortable using it as a resource when choosing health insurance. Among employees at businesses with fewer than 100 people, that figure rises to 74%. Among employees under 30, it reaches 77%. But the data shows clear limits on how far employees want that involvement to go. Only 24% would be comfortable having AI recommend a plan, and just 12% would let it make the final decision.
That picture is consistent with what The Hartford found in its 2026 Future of Benefits Study. Fifty-eight percent of small employers said they look to brokers for open enrollment guidance, compared with 42% of larger employers. AI and human guidance are not substitutes in this environment. Employees are reaching for AI because structured support is scarce, not because they prefer a less-guided process.
Justworks’ 2025 Benefit Blindspots Report found 62% of Zillennials had used AI tools for medical or insurance information. Zillennials span Gen Z adults and younger millennials. That compared with 29% of Gen X and Boomers. The 2026 data builds on that trend, extending it across a broader age range and anchoring it to open enrollment behavior specifically.
Businesses with fewer than 100 employees typically lack the internal HR bandwidth larger companies deploy during open enrollment. That includes dedicated benefits teams, enrollment platforms with built-in decision tools, and structured guidance sessions. The result is employees navigating consequential decisions with less support, at a moment when plan complexity and premium costs are both rising.
Advisors helping small-business clients navigate the annual benefits decision are working in the environment the data describes. Two out of three small business owners wished they had outside help navigating benefits, according to a separate October 2026 Justworks survey. The new enrollment confidence data puts employee-side numbers alongside that employer-side finding.
The question the Justworks findings push on is what that outside help looks like in practice. Employees are open to AI as a starting point for understanding their options. The same survey shows they want to retain control of the final decision. Structured guidance makes the process more trustworthy. The limits of AI-only benefits guidance are sharpest in the small-business market, where the gap between what employees need and what their employer can provide is widest.