Texas among least affordable P&C markets as costs compound

Severe weather, population growth, and nuclear verdicts combine to squeeze Texas coverage
Texas among least affordable P&C markets as costs compound
PROPERTY
By Mark Rosanes
Nov 18, 2026

Texans now spend about 4.1% of median household income on homeowners insurance premiums and roughly 1.9% on personal auto, placing the state among the 10 least affordable in both categories, according to a new issues brief from the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I). The homeowners ratio has risen from 2.86% in 2020, a deterioration that reflects how quickly the market’s cost base has moved.

The brief, titled State of the State: Texas, draws on the Triple-I’s Insurance Affordability Index and identifies three overlapping drivers: the frequency and severity of severe weather, rapid population growth into high-risk areas, and a litigation environment that adds measurably to loss costs across both personal and commercial lines.

“Texas families and business owners are feeling the strain, but the price of insurance is a symptom, not the cause,” said Sean Kevelighan, chief executive officer of Triple-I, in a statement accompanying the brief. “Lasting relief depends on addressing the underlying cost drivers, from severe weather losses to litigation costs through the likes of community resilience building and legal reform.”

Weather and growth as structural cost drivers

Texas ranked first for both tornadoes and hailstorms in 2025, with lightning losses averaging $60,382 per claim against a national average of $26,616, according to the brief. The state also has the second-highest population growth rate in the country, with average home values in the top five nationally. More people are moving into the path of storms that are already driving some of the highest claim costs in the country.

Those dynamics compress the options available to brokers placing residential and commercial risks in the state. When claim frequency is high and replacement costs are rising, carriers adjust appetite and price accordingly, and clients push back on renewals they cannot explain with a single cause.

The commercial lines picture is more concentrated. Texas commercial auto posted a direct incurred loss and defense and cost containment (DCC) ratio of 86.6% in 2025, the third-highest in the country and 13 points above the national average of 73.6%. General liability came in at 86.3%, ranking sixth nationally. Loss ratios at that level reflect a market where underwriting margins are thin and carriers have limited room to compete on price.

The litigation cost the brief puts a number on

Texas ranked third in the country for nuclear verdicts, defined as jury awards of $10 million or more, with $3.4 billion recorded in 2025. The brief cites a Perryman Group study finding that nuclear verdicts raise Texas P&C insurance costs by at least 15.25%. That figure comes from a commissioned economic analysis, rather than independent regulatory data, and should be read accordingly. The directional claim, that large jury awards feed directly into loss costs and premiums, is consistent with what the broader industry literature and casualty experts have documented nationally.

Texas Senate Bill 30, a measure aimed at capping nuclear verdicts, failed to pass during the 2025 legislative session. Governor Greg Abbott directed the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) in August 2026 to identify administrative measures to address affordability. TDI responded on September 16, committing to enforce bulletins requiring insurers to account for FORTIFIED roof status in rate-setting, propose a rule clarifying prohibitions on using roof age as grounds to deny coverage, and produce a claims-cost study for the homeowners, personal auto, and commercial auto markets by the end of 2026. Abbott has said he will carry additional statutory measures to the 2027 legislature.

Florida as the stated reference point

Triple-I points to Florida’s post-2022 legislative reforms as a model. Following reforms targeting litigation costs and assignment-of-benefits abuse, Florida recorded the only statewide average property rate decrease in the country in 2025, while around 20 carriers entered the residential market. As documented in the American Property Casualty Insurance Association's (APCIA) analysis of how Florida’s property placement market shifted after those reforms, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation’s market share fell from 15% in 2023 to 3% in 2025, and homeowners direct written premiums dropped 7% last year, the first decrease since 2009.

Texas and Florida share some structural similarities. Both are large, fast-growing states with significant catastrophe exposure and elevated litigation costs. The difference, Triple-I argues, is the reform trajectory. Florida acted and market conditions shifted. Florida remains the most expensive state for homeowners insurance, and its litigation costs have fallen in volume but not been eliminated. Texas has not yet passed equivalent legislation, and the brief frames that gap as the central policy question heading into the 2027 session.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.