5 states where you don't want to file an auto claim

Your clients could experience an auto premium jump of more than 40% after making a claim if they live here.

5 states where you don't want to file an auto claim

Insurance News


A producer’s role could include advising consumers on whether or not to make an auto insurance claim in certain states, where filing just one claim worth more than $2,000 could cause rates to jump by more than 40%.

According to a December 2013 Quadrant study, data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners suggest that rate increases vary widely state by state, though some face jumps of nearly 70%.

Massachusetts led the nation in rate increases, where drivers experience an average 67% increase in premiums after filing a claim of more than $2,000. The state was followed closely by California, with a 62% increase, New Jersey (59%), North Carolina (47%) and Minnesota (45%).

The rate increases varied slightly for bodily injury claims related to auto accidents, though the same states led the pack with jumps ranging from 49% in Minnesota to 73% in Massachusetts.

Insurance Information Institute President Robert Hartwig said that while the increases made sense in theory, he was “very surprised by the magnitude of these numbers.”

Hartwig added that producers can help avoid such high premium increases to an extent by shopping around for more moderate rates.

“The market is competitive,” he said.

Laura Adams, a senior insurance analyst with InsuranceQuotes.com—the site that commissioned the study—told the Boston Globe careful analysis when making claims is also recommended.

“If there’s a claim under $1,000, you really want to scrutinize it,” Adams said.

The Quadrant report found that while post-claim auto premiums increased significantly for drivers in all states, the penalties weren’t quite as great elsewhere.

Maryland drivers are the luckiest, according to the NAIC data, experiencing just a 20% increase after filing a claim. Alabama followed with a 22% increase, and Michigan (23%), Wyoming (23%) and Oklahoma (25%) rounded out the bottom five.

You may also enjoy: "The 7 most expensive moving violations in auto insurance"
"The top carrier websites in auto insurance"
"Consumer loyalty 2014: Big jumps for health, auto"

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!