The 10 states where insurance costs the most: Study

A new analysis from NerdWallet reveals the 10 most expensive personal lines insurance markets in the United States.

Insurance News

By

The average American spends about 12% of their yearly income – or $5,261 – on personal lines insurance, according to a new study from NerdWallet. That includes $1,100 for auto insurance; $2,823 for health insurance; $1,034 for home insurance and $304 for life insurance.

Those amounts can fluctuate greatly depending on location, however – something independent insurance agents may wish to point out in explaining costs.

The 10 states where residents pay the most to carry auto, home, health and life insurance policies include:
  1. Louisiana – 18.1% of earnings, $7,300 annually
Auto: $2,264
Homeowners: $1,742
Health: $2,990
Life: $304
  1. New York – 17.4% of earnings, $8,495 annually
Auto: $1,906
Homeowners: $1,158
Health: $5,142
Life: $289
  1. Florida – 17.1% of earnings, $6,602 annually
Auto: $1,417
Homeowners: $2,084
Health: $2,797
Life: $304
  1. Rhode Island – 16.7% of earnings, $7,987 annually
Auto: $2,513
Homeowners: $1,233
Health: $3,937
Life: $304
  1. New Jersey – 15.8% of earnings, $8,705 annually
Auto: $1,742
Homeowners: $981
Health: $5,678
Life: $304
  1. Vermont – 15.7% of earnings, $6,713 annually
Auto: $818
Homeowners: $782
Health: $4,809
Life: $304
  1. Oklahoma – 15.4% of earnings, $5,778 annually
Auto: $1,465
Homeowners: $1,501
Health: $2,508
Life: $304
  1. Massachusetts – 15.0% of earnings, $8,168 annually
Auto: $1,237
Homeowners: $1,150
Health: $5,477
Life: $304
  1. Michigan – 14.9% of earnings, $6,648 annually
Auto: $3,096
Homeowners: $802
Health: $2,445
Life: $304
  1. Mississippi – 14.8% of earnings, $5,222 annually
Auto: $1,043
Homeowners: $802
Health: $2,561
Life: $304
 
The study also found that the cost of insurance can fluctuate greatly by state – up to $4,763. For example, New Jersey residents top the list at $8,705 in annual premiums while Utah policyholders pay just $3,942 a year.

Similarly, the cost of insurance as a percentage of income differs. Louisiana policyholders give up the greatest portion of income – 18.1% - and Maryland consumers pay 7.7%.

NerdWallet suggests that shopping smart, perhaps through an independent agent, is one way consumers can exert some degree of control over geographical differences in pricing.
 

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!