Why cyber insurers can no longer afford to wait for a claim

‘Insurers will increasingly compete on their ability to help policyholders reduce exposure throughout the policy term’
Why cyber insurers can no longer afford to wait for a claim
CYBER
By Emily Douglas
Nov 16, 2026

As cyber threats evolve, the role of insurers is changing. Beyond providing financial protection, insurers have an opportunity to help businesses proactively identify, understand, and reduce their cyber risks.

But what does this mean for the future of cyber insurance in the years to come and, more importantly, how will it impact the relationship between insurers, brokers, and policyholders?

At Cowbell, the team recently introduced Risk Advisor, an AI-powered tool designed to make personalized cybersecurity guidance accessible to its policyholders. Built on Cowbell's OMNI decision intelligence system, Risk Advisor translates complex security data into actionable recommendations, helping businesses strengthen their resilience throughout the policy term.

And, speaking to Rajeev Gupta, Co-founder and Chief Product Officer at Cowbell, he told IB that Risk Advisor’s implications for claims and underwriting can’t be understated here.

“The inspiration came from our policyholders. Our Cybersecurity Advisory team speaks with thousands of policyholders every month, answering questions about security findings, emerging vulnerabilities, and changes in their Cowbell Factors. These conversations create tremendous value, but each requires specialist expertise. With OMNI, we can make that expertise accessible whenever a policyholder needs it.”

Addressing the coverage gap

As Gupta explained, much of the cyber insurance market still treats the policy as the product. Businesses purchase coverage, receive a security report, and may not hear from their insurer again until renewal or a claim. Larger organizations have security teams to act on those findings, but smaller businesses often don't.

“Risk Advisor addresses this gap by analyzing each policyholder's Cowbell Factors, security findings, and real-time threat intelligence,” added Gupta. “It explains what matters, prioritizes actions based on potential risk reduction, and provides evidence behind its recommendations.”

Risk Advisor's development reflects the market's shift toward continuous risk management and away from more reactive approaches.

“Traditional underwriting assumes the risk assessed when a policy is bound remains relatively stable throughout the term,” added Gupta. “In cyber, that assumption quickly becomes outdated. New vulnerabilities emerge daily, attackers change tactics, and businesses continually introduce new technologies and vendors.”

‘This changes where value is created’

At Cowbell, Gupta told IB that the company already assesses risk continuously, updating Cowbell Factors throughout the policy term. However, this continuous assessment only reduces losses if businesses act on the findings - and it’s Risk Advisor that bridges the gap by translating changes in risk into practical, prioritized actions.

“For the industry, this changes where value is created,” Gupta continued. “The period between binding and renewal becomes an opportunity to prevent losses rather than simply wait for the next transaction. Insurers will increasingly compete on their ability to help policyholders reduce exposure throughout the policy term, alongside pricing and claims handling. Ultimately, prevention at scale can help keep cyber insurance affordable and accessible.”

But in a market that’s somewhat overrun with new AI tools and innovative platforms, all of which promise to soothe the sector’s pain points, Risk Advisor’s real power lies in its unique ability to cut through the jargon and make sense of the data.

“Traditional assessment tools are effective at identifying vulnerabilities, but they often produce lengthy reports ranked by technical severity,” added Gupta. “For SMEs without dedicated security teams, interpreting those findings can be challenging. A critical-rated vulnerability that's difficult to exploit might rank above a moderate issue actively being exploited by attackers. Risk Advisor goes beyond technical severity, evaluating findings against each business's specific circumstances and current threat activity.”

It prioritizes remediation based on potential risk reduction, provides supporting evidence, distinguishes confirmed issues from advisory signals, and guides policyholders through corrective actions, as Gupta told IB. And the technology behind this is equally important.

“Risk Advisor operates on OMNI, Cowbell's decision intelligence system, which maintains a continuously updated model of each insured business, enriched with live data and threat intelligence. Unlike general-purpose AI assistants, Risk Advisor delivers recommendations grounded in each policyholder's actual risk profile, with supporting evidence and transparency when information is missing.”

‘AI-powered advisory creates opportunities for meaningful engagement’

Looking to the future of the sector, it’s clear that AI-powered advisory tools have the propensity to reshape relationships between insurers, brokers and policyholders, with proactive guidance eventually becoming the industry gold standard.

“Today, interactions between insurers, brokers, and policyholders largely revolve around transactions: quoting, binding, renewal, and claims. AI-powered advisory creates opportunities for meaningful engagement between those moments,” added Gupta.

Policyholders gain greater transparency into how their insurer assesses their risk and what they can do to improve it. Understanding the reasoning behind their Cowbell Factors makes them more likely to take action.

“Brokers also stand to benefit significantly,” Gupta told IB. “Risk Advisor deliberately leaves coverage advice to the broker, instead addressing cybersecurity questions that might otherwise require specialist assistance. This allows brokers to focus on coverage, limits, and decisions requiring their professional judgment. Clients who better understand their exposures are also better equipped for those conversations.

“I believe proactive risk guidance will become a standard expectation, and sooner than many anticipate. Not long ago, quoting small cyber risks in minutes was a competitive differentiator. Today, brokers expect it. Risk guidance is likely to follow a similar trajectory.”

As cyber insurance evolves, the ability to translate risk intelligence into meaningful action could become as important as the coverage itself. For insurers and brokers, technologies like Risk Advisor represent an opportunity to strengthen client relationships, support better risk management, and move toward a more proactive model of protection.

And at Cowbell, the goal is to make that guidance available when it matters most, helping businesses build resilience before an incident occurs.

This article was created in partnership with Cowbell

Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.