What happened: West Virginia’s top court ruled that a driver’s parked, uninvolved vehicle qualifies as “underinsured” under state law, voiding a Milbank Insurance Company policy clause
Who’s involved: Milbank Insurance Company, Erie Insurance Property and Casualty Company, the estate of a deceased passenger
What’s at stake: UIM benefits under a Milbank policy with stated limits of $25,000/$50,000, with a counterclaim seeking liability-level limits
Why it matters: Insurers cannot condition UIM coverage on the underinsured vehicle’s involvement in the accident
Where it stands: Decided by the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals on November 13, 2026, with remand for remaining claims
Five people died in a wrong-way highway crash, but the car that triggered a West Virginia coverage fight was never there.
Caleb Ratcliffe drove Sierra Mattson’s Hyundai Accent the wrong way on Ohio State Route 7 on November 23, 2019, slamming head-on into an oncoming vehicle. Five people died, including Ratcliffe and Mattson, who was riding as a passenger in her own car.
Mattson’s vehicle was insured by Milbank Insurance Company. Ratcliffe separately owned a car insured by Erie Insurance Property and Casualty Company. That car was parked at his home and had nothing to do with the accident.
The estate collected $120,000 from pooled liability proceeds - both policies carried limits of $100,000 per person and $300,000 per accident - and said it was not enough.
So the estate claimed underinsured motorist (UIM) benefits under the Milbank policy, treating Ratcliffe’s parked, uninvolved Erie-insured vehicle as the “underinsured motor vehicle.” The logic: Ratcliffe owned a vehicle with liability coverage, that coverage fell short, and the statute does not require the vehicle to be in the crash.
Milbank disagreed and asked the Circuit Court of Ohio County to confirm it did not have to pay.
The case turned on one difference. West Virginia’s UIM statute defines an “underinsured motor vehicle” as one “with respect to the ownership, operation or use of which there is liability insurance applicable at the time of the accident.” No requirement that the vehicle be involved. But Milbank’s policy endorsement added one - requiring the owner’s “liability” to “arise out of the ownership, maintenance or use” of the underinsured vehicle. That language ties coverage to the vehicle’s involvement.
The circuit court sided with the estate. The Intermediate Court of Appeals reversed, calling the policy language the “starting and ending point.”
The West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals, in a decision filed November 13, 2026, reversed the intermediate court and reinstated the original ruling. The court held that Milbank’s endorsement is more restrictive than the statute and unenforceable. Ratcliffe owned a vehicle with applicable coverage that proved insufficient. That was enough.
The majority cited decades of precedent that UIM coverage must be “construed liberally” to fulfill the state’s policy of full compensation for injured parties. Chief Justice Bunn and Justice Trump dissented.
The estate also alleges Milbank’s UIM selection forms were defective, which could mean coverage at the liability limits rather than the stated UIM limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. That issue and other outstanding claims - including bad faith and unfair settlement practices - go back to the lower court.
For claims teams reviewing UIM endorsements, the ruling is direct: West Virginia will not let insurers tie UIM coverage to whether the underinsured vehicle was in the accident.
The UIM coverage question has been decided. The remaining claims have not been resolved, and no court has ruled on their merits.