Insurance fraud in the United States is becoming faster, cheaper, and harder to detect. Mentions of AI in questionable claims increased by more than 1,400% from 2025 to mid-2026, according to National Insurance Crime Bureau’s (NICB) member-exclusive 2026 threat assessment – a figure that shows where pressure is concentrating across auto, liability, cargo, and workers’ compensation lines.
New intelligence released by NICB, a nonprofit headquartered in Oak Brook, Illinois, identifies three converging threats reshaping the US fraud landscape: AI-enabled identity schemes, organized crime networks combining digital and physical tactics, and professional networks of attorneys, medical providers, and auto repair firms operating together to inflate claims. The report was published on November 16, 2026.
Fraudsters are using accessible tools to generate fabricated medical records, synthetic identities, and doctored accident photographs – producing fraudulent evidence at a volume that existing claims workflows were not designed to absorb.
Separate research from Verisk, published in March 2026, confirms what claims professionals are already encountering. The Verisk State of Insurance Fraud study – based on surveys of 1,000 US consumers and 300 claims professionals – found that 36% of consumers would consider digitally altering a claim image or document, even if doing so broke insurer rules. Among Generation Z, that figure rises to 55%.
On the insurer side, 76% of claims professionals reported that manipulated media submissions have grown more sophisticated over the past year. Only 32% said they were confident their organization could identify a deepfake.
That detection gap has a direct pricing consequence. Fraud losses inflate loss ratios, and loss ratios drive premiums. The FBI estimates non-health insurance fraud costs the US at least $40 billion annually, a figure that underpins why premium exposure from fraud is a commercial reality for every broker advising clients on property-casualty lines. Brokers advising commercial clients across those lines will find context in Insurance Business America’s coverage of how the AI-fueled fraud surge is forcing insurers into an arms race.
Read more: AI-fueled fraud surge forcing insurers into ‘arms race,’ warns Verisk executive
Physical fraud networks continue to run parallel to digital schemes. NICB identified more than 1,600 transnational, interstate, and state-level organized crime rings operating in 2025, running schemes spanning staged accidents, vehicle theft, and complex multi-party fraud.
Predatory legal and medical networks present a separate but related problem. The NICB report describes these groups as systematically exploiting the litigation system – turning low-severity incidents into mass litigation and driving settlement values well beyond the underlying loss. NICB has focused legislative efforts on fraud in litigation funding, an area generating growing concern for commercial lines underwriters and the brokers placing those risks.
At the carrier level, Travelers Investigative Services – one of the largest specialized investigative units in the property-casualty industry – sees the same dynamics playing out. In a statement issued alongside the NICB report, Pranay Mittal, vice president of Travelers Investigative Services, said: “Shared insight is our strongest defense as an industry, because every insurer holds a piece of the picture. Working with NICB and the broader coalition of fraud-fighting partners helps our investigators spot patterns sooner and focus investigations with greater precision as new threats emerge.”
The commercial cargo line is where broker exposure is sharpest and most measurable. Total supply chain crime incidents across the US and Canada held roughly steady in 2025 – 3,594 events against 3,607 in 2024 – but estimated losses reached nearly $725 million, a 60% year-on-year increase, according to Verisk CargoNet’s January 2026 annual analysis. The average value per theft rose 36% to $273,990.
Confirmed cargo theft cases rose 18% year-over-year. California, Texas, and Illinois accounted for just over half of all incidents, but New Jersey, Indiana, and Pennsylvania each recorded significant increases – a geographic spread showing the risk has moved beyond traditional hotspots.
For brokers placing cargo or logistics cover, policies underwritten against 2023 or 2024 loss assumptions may no longer reflect current exposure. As strategic cargo theft drives underwriting pressure in logistics insurance, carriers are tightening terms, adding exclusions, and demanding stronger chain-of-custody controls from clients – conversations that now fall to brokers to initiate.
Read more: Strategic cargo theft drives underwriting pressure in logistics insurance
NICB is integrating business intelligence across its member companies, authenticating digital evidence, and building infrastructure to flag emerging fraud patterns earlier. Field agents work alongside law enforcement to disrupt cargo theft operations directly.
Aimee Stidham, president of the International Association of Special Investigation Units (IASIU) – a global nonprofit anti-fraud body headquartered in Albany, New York – and claims SIU manager at Hiscox USA, said in a statement issued alongside the NICB report: “The fight against insurance fraud is no longer an effort undertaken by any single organization. Today’s most effective anti-fraud initiatives are driven by collaboration, intelligence sharing, and a shared commitment to protecting policyholders.”
Policyholders and industry professionals can report suspected fraud to NICB reportinsurancefraud.org.