What happened: Delaware’s Chancery Court denied PPG Industries’ bid to force Westlake Corporation to pay or secure a $704M Brazilian judgment from a 1998 cargo ship fire.
Who’s involved: PPG Industries (plaintiff), Westlake Corporation, Axiall Corporation, and related spinoff entities (defendants).
What’s at stake: A Brazilian damages award of $90.4 million plus $93.3 million in corrections and interest, with Westlake estimating total exposure at $703.85 million - and just under $300 million in untouched insurance.
Why it matters: The ruling tests what happens when a corporate spinoff splits the liability from the insurance and neither side will act first - a problem coverage and claims professionals see routinely.
Where it stands: Decided after a two-day trial. Both sides ordered to submit a joint implementing order.
In November 1998, the cargo ship DG Harmony exploded off the coast of Brazil, destroying the vessel and its cargo.
Among the wreckage: calcium hypochlorite manufactured by PPG Industries. PPG settled the resulting lawsuits for $81.5 million. Its insurers paid $56.5 million after PPG absorbed a $25 million deductible.
One claimant never went away.
Di Gregorio, a Brazilian company that had sub-chartered the vessel, sued PPG in Brazil in 2006. A New York federal court entered a default judgment in 2009 ordering Di Gregorio not to pursue PPG. The Brazilian court ignored the order and found PPG liable anyway.
PPG spun off its commodity chemicals business in 2013. The Di Gregorio liability went to the spun-off group, later acquired by Westlake Corporation. The insurance policies stayed with PPG.
For over a decade, Westlake defended the Brazilian case on PPG’s behalf and sent invoices to PPG’s insurers. The insurers refused to pay without a formal transfer of PPG’s policy rights. PPG offered only a conditional, narrowly tailored transfer - and only if Westlake kicked back 30 percent of any insurance recoveries. Westlake wanted a clean transfer before paying anything.
Nobody blinked.
Then the Brazilian court issued its damages decision: $90.4 million in damages, $93.3 million in monetary corrections and interest, plus legal fees and fines. Westlake estimated total exposure at $703.85 million.
PPG filed suit in Delaware in June 2024, asking the court to force Westlake to step into the Brazilian case or post a bond. Westlake counterclaimed, demanding PPG hand over the insurance.
The Delaware Court of Chancery, in a post-trial opinion issued November 18, 2026, denied every one of PPG’s requests. PPG had waited 11 years after the spinoff to demand Westlake take its place. And forcing a party into litigation that a New York federal court had specifically ordered to stop would put Delaware at odds with that ruling.
Both sides’ Brazilian law experts agreed that posting a bond would not pause enforcement under Brazilian rules - and could actually hand Di Gregorio access to funds it otherwise could not reach.
Westlake did not walk away empty-handed. The court ordered PPG to hand over insurance proceeds for defense costs Westlake had already paid - more than $2 million in legal fees since the spinoff. But the court denied a full transfer, finding the spinoff agreements required payment of the underlying liability before the broader insurance rights kicked in.
Just under $300 million in insurance remains available under PPG’s policy. Westlake committed under oath to hold PPG harmless against any enforcement of the Brazilian judgment.
The case boils down to a standoff claim and coverage professionals will recognize: who moves first when a corporate spinoff separates the liability from the insurance, and each side refuses to act until the other does.
This decision addresses the facts as they stand. No payment order has been issued in Brazil, and neither party has indicated whether an appeal is planned.