Soft market will punish carriers whose AI strategy stopped at cost-cutting

West Monroe and SAS both warn carriers that cost-cutting AI strategies will fail the 2027 margin test
Soft market will punish carriers whose AI strategy stopped at cost-cutting
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION
By Camille Joyce Lisay
Nov 20, 2026

Insurers heading into 2027 will be judged on whether their AI spending produces results, according to outlooks released this week by consulting firm West Monroe and analytics company SAS. 

West Monroe’s 2027 Outlooks, published November 18, cover eight industries and business disciplines, with insurance framed as “the year discipline becomes the advantage.” Across the series, the firm identifies an “AI value gap”: investment is accelerating, but evidence of business value is not keeping pace as leaders try to tie adoption and productivity gains to revenue, margins and customer outcomes. 

“The pressure to deliver is consistent, but what it takes to deliver is specific to each industry,” said Harin Shetty, president of West Monroe. 

The firm also points to AI’s electricity demands drawing capital toward data centers and energy infrastructure, and to shared systems, data, capital and supply chains that allow disruptions to spread beyond individual organizations. 

SAS, in a separate release on November 19, said the soft market will expose which AI strategies were built for growth and which were built only to cut costs. It noted that property and specialty rates are falling and rating agencies expect margins to tighten through 2027. Insurers that have used AI mainly to reduce headcount may exhaust those savings before they find the next efficiency lever, while those using it to price risk more precisely and launch new products are better placed to grow through the softening cycle. 

“The soft market will expose cost-cutting AI strategies as short-sighted,” said Oana Avramescu, global director and head of insurance solutions for risk, fraud and compliance at SAS. 

SAS also expects AI-generated documents and images to outpace rule-based fraud detection in 2027. “Insurers are going to need equally advanced AI-driven verification systems,” said Jonathan Moran, senior manager, horizontal solutions marketing. The company added that climate exposure could make some areas unaffordable or uninsurable, with some insurers exiting lines of business entirely. 

The outlooks follow a KPMG survey in which insurers rated themselves AI leaders but none had rebuilt distribution around the technology, and today’s separate KPMG Global Insurance CEO Outlook finding that only 1% of insurance CEOs have achieved a measurable return on AI investment despite two-thirds planning to direct 11-20% of total budget to it over the next 12 months. On pricing, WTW has said property rates are still falling while excess casualty increases may be peaking. 

For brokers, a softer market gives clients room at renewal - but carriers under pressure to show returns on AI are likely to lean harder on automated underwriting and claims processing. Brokers may want to ask carriers how AI is being used in pricing decisions and fraud checks, and monitor for capacity pulling back from climate-exposed lines or geographies as the margin squeeze tightens. 

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.