In the latest edition of Insurance Business TV, we delve into the E&S space with our leaders network. Experts from Amwins, AJ Wayne & Associaties, and E-Risk, a Nationwide company, delve into how much new capacity is differentiated underwriting appetite versus capital chasing growth. They also look at how wholesale broker consolidation is changing service levels and if litigation and social inflation have changed how carriers underwrite casualty risk.
[00:00] Andrew Kelly: Well, I'm seeing a lot of reverse engineering of the underwriting appetite.
[00:04] James Walsh: We have to ensure that yes, we grow, but we grow correctly, we grow profitably going forward.
[00:10] Liz Goldie: The reason that the wholesale market exists in my mind is to bring specialization and expertise.
[00:18] Paul Lucas: Hello everyone, welcome to Insurance Business TV and welcome to our second ENS Leaders Network roundtable. Our first session available on IBTV established the structural pressures, talent, delegated authority, surplus lines, and complaints shaping who actually runs ENS businesses today. This edition turns to the capital and capacity side, what's actually driving new entrants into the space and whether that competition is sustainable.
[00:46] To talk us through it, we welcome back Andrew Kelly, Executive Vice President at AJ Wayne and Associates, and making their debut James Walsh, President at Erisk, a nationwide company, Liz Goldie, Senior Vice President, Casualty Broker at Amwins. So welcome everyone. Of course, new capacity keeps entering the ENS market. I'd love to know how much of that is genuinely differentiated underwriting appetite versus capital simply chasing growth wherever admitted markets have perhaps pulled back. Andrew, what's your opinion?
[01:18] Andrew Kelly: Well, I'm seeing a lot of reverse engineering of the underwriting appetite. What I mean when I say that is when you had underwriting appetites that were fundamentally correct, you decided what you were going to underwrite, you ran it through actuarial, and then you formed the budget around what was fiscally responsible to take in.
[01:42] Now I'm seeing it the other way around. You decide with your investors what the number has to be, and then you form the underwriting appetite around what's coming in the door. That's kind of what's going on in the marketplace right now. I'm seeing a lot of overstretching these days that is creating unnecessary competition in the marketplace and driving down rates. Whether or not that has real-world implications about claims that come in and alter a lot of carriers' balance sheets is something we're going to see in the next two to three years.
[02:21] Paul Lucas: That's a great way to kick us off. Liz, to build on that, what's your opinion here? Is this differentiated underwriting appetite, or capital simply chasing growth, or perhaps a mix of the two?
[02:33] Liz Goldie: That's exactly right. I think it's a mix of the two, and our job as wholesalers is to differentiate between the two. Both things are happening in the market right now, and when you work alongside a wholesaler, their job is to place the business with those carriers that are differentiating their appetite, have real expertise, and will be around for the long term.
[03:01] Paul Lucas: Okay, so a combination of the two. James, are you in agreement with that?
[03:06] James Walsh: Yeah, I am. I think Liz and Drew both make very good points. From 2020 through 2024, there were really good opportunities from a rate, capacity, and coverage standpoint to grow quite aggressively and successfully in E&S. There has definitely been a boom in that market.
[03:33] I think trying to now go completely in the other direction to keep holding that type of growth pattern is not the right underwriting approach. We have to ensure that yes, we can grow, but we grow correctly and profitably going forward. There will be less opportunity to meet profit goals unless you grow at a more modest rate and choose the right risks. New entrants have to demonstrate their willingness to sacrifice growth in order to ensure profitability.
[04:22] Paul Lucas: Let's pick up on market growth. Program business and MGA-fronted E&S paper have both grown substantially. Liz, what due diligence should retail brokers be doing before placing meaningful volume with one of these newer programs?
[04:42] Liz Goldie: It's a great question and one we ask ourselves often. That long-term carrier partner is paramount, so doing due diligence on the MGA is very important. I would look at four areas: the paper, the people, the claims handling, and the reinsurance backing.
[05:00] Look at the fronting carrier rating and how much risk is being retained versus ceded. Look at the reinsurers and how long they're committed. Track the people and underwriters involved and understand their experience and stability. Then focus on claims handling. Carriers are there to pay claims, so understand who handles losses and what that process looks like. Asking those questions helps ensure business is placed with good MGA partners.
[05:54] Paul Lucas: That's from the broker perspective. James, what should carriers be looking for?
[06:00] James Walsh: If you're an MGA going to market and you want capacity from a carrier, there are three pillars you have to demonstrate. First, underwriting talent and capability. Second, a legitimate distribution model that brings business in a new or alternative way. Third, technology or operational efficiency that improves how business is run.
[06:42] A really good MGA can do all three. You should also understand how the business is financed, who is backing it, and what the long-term goals are. If you're a broker or insured, you don't want to find that within two years the program has a different owner or a completely different underwriting philosophy. You have to trust that the business is being built financially in a strategic and intelligent way.
[07:30] Paul Lucas: Great perspectives. Andrew, I guess it really depends on how the market is positioned.
[07:37] Andrew Kelly: From a street-level perspective, with our MGA partners we like to make sure we're marketing submissions, not routing them. If we have a newer MGA partner, we're approaching a broad sector of the market, comparing forms, rates, exclusions, and endorsements.
[08:02] We're making an analysis of what's in the application and how different policy forms respond. That way, if you're looking at carrier A versus carrier B versus carrier C versus a new entrant, you have a real-time comparison you can hand to the insured. If you're doing that properly and making markets compete honestly, everything else tends to sort itself out.
[08:43] Paul Lucas: Another hot topic is broker consolidation and wholesale broker consolidation. How is that changing service levels and market access for retail brokers who depend on those relationships? James?
[09:05] James Walsh: We haven't seen as much consolidation among independent wholesalers recently, but we are seeing large retail firms build internal wholesale networks. One major question is how that's affecting existing wholesale relationships and their books of business.
[09:32] Another concern is ensuring the broker we're working with understands the risks being submitted and can help manage claims and underwriting issues effectively. There's significant pressure because margins are lower today, and everyone is trying to find ways to retain profit and growth. We're seeing increasing consolidation of wholesale business into internally owned firms.
[10:54] Paul Lucas: Andrew, this activity is taking choices away, isn't it?
[11:10] Andrew Kelly: Most insureds don't even know the wholesaler exists. Historically, a retail agent had access to multiple wholesalers. If they weren't getting the right outcome, they could approach another wholesaler to make sure the account was properly marketed.
[11:37] Now you have owned wholesalers that don't have to compete with anybody else. If a risk isn't getting the proper result, sometimes the answer is simply nothing. Insureds often don't understand why outcomes change after a retailer is acquired and starts using an owned wholesaler. It absolutely changes service levels and outcomes. The best thing insureds can do is market their business themselves and not assume all the best choices are automatically being made at renewal.
[12:48] Paul Lucas: Liz, this is something we can't ignore, is it?
[12:54] Liz Goldie: Absolutely. I agree with both James and Andrew. The purpose of the wholesale market is to bring specialization and expertise. Our job is to be deeply rooted in the marketplace and those relationships.
[13:20] For those of us who have remained independent and specialized, our goal is always to make sure the insured is placed with the best market and the retailer gets the best service. There's a natural competitive nature to most wholesalers, and I'm not sure how that exists in owned wholesalers.
[13:51] Paul Lucas: In our previous session, litigation funding and social inflation featured heavily as claims concerns. Has that translated into any real change in how E&S carriers are underwriting casualty risk?
[14:11] Andrew Kelly: I think it has. Because of the competitiveness around trimming rates, many carriers are trying to figure out how to meet budget while staying competitive. One result is the growing use of exclusions.
[14:34] It's common now for new exclusions to appear on renewals or for endorsement wording to be subtly modified. Ten or fifteen years ago there was much more stability in policy forms. Even small changes to definitions, conditions, or endorsements can fundamentally alter how coverage works. Brokers and agents have to be extremely careful and not assume forms mean the same thing they did last year.
[15:35] Liz Goldie: I'll speak for the casualty marketplace. We're seeing it less in forms and more in underwriting discipline. We're seeing shifts in limit deployment, attachment points, and greater scrutiny around venue and classes.
[15:58] It's real, not speculative anymore, especially in excess liability. Retailers are seeing more questions around loss control, particularly auto liability, safety practices, fleets, and exposure details. Underwriters want to stay disciplined and make sound choices for insureds that may be susceptible to social inflation losses.
[16:36] Paul Lucas: Let's wrap up by looking at the broader cycle. James, what would be the clearest early warning sign that E&S pricing is softening too far relative to the risk being taken?
[16:54] James Walsh: In management liability, professional liability, and cyber, I think we're already past the warning-sign stage. Competition over the last few years has driven pricing down too far and broadened coverage too much.
[17:28] We're seeing increased frequency and severity of claims, especially in employment practices liability and cyber. Claims costs today are up dramatically compared with 2015 or 2016. Yet we still have a very competitive market because these are specialized lines that attract premium.
[18:04] To keep the market healthy, participants have to make difficult choices about rate, coverage, and limits. Growth for growth's sake doesn't work. Profitability and underwriting discipline have to remain paramount.
[18:57] Paul Lucas: Andrew, it looks like you're smiling along. You're in agreement with James?
[19:01] Andrew Kelly: Being at the wholesale level, I get to see a lot of this firsthand. Every time we price a renewal or new business account, we're analyzing the base rate. Historical base rates on many professional liability accounts should be around $1.15. Today, it's not uncommon to see 15 cents or 25 cents on the dollar.
[19:27] I recently had a cyber renewal priced at 8 cents on the dollar. That means one of two things: either the market is phenomenally gifted at underwriting, or those rates are simply unsustainable. I believe this underwriting environment is not going to work long term.
[20:01] In the past 12 months, I can count on one hand the number of double-digit rate increases that actually stuck. Usually competition drives rates right back down. I want to see carriers thrive, not take on unsustainable losses. At some point the bill comes due, and I'd like to see a return to a little underwriting sanity.
[20:44] Paul Lucas: Strong statements there from Andrew. Liz, can you top that? What are you seeing in the casualty marketplace?
[20:51] Liz Goldie: I feel for my financial lines friends. It's been a challenging marketplace. Excess liability auto continues to be a line that isn't being written profitably across the board.
[21:13] Warning signs of excessive softening are rate decreases in classes with unresolved loss-trend issues. If the loss trend keeps showing up but rates keep dropping, there's a disconnect. Another warning sign is broader terms and conditions combined with increased limit deployment.
[21:47] Rate tells you where the market is today, but terms and conditions tell you where it's headed. Understanding both together provides a clear indication of where the casualty market is going.
[22:20] Paul Lucas: Great thoughts and a super interesting discussion. Fantastic to have you all with us. There's obviously so much happening in the ENS space right now and no doubt lots more to talk about in a month's time. We'll see you then, right here on Insurance Business TV.