Auto theft falls 10.1% again, but Canadian premiums aren't following

A second straight year of declining theft numbers hasn't eased the cost pressures still keeping auto insurance rates elevated

Auto theft falls 10.1% again, but Canadian premiums aren't following

Motor & Fleet

By Josh Recamara

Canadian auto theft continued its decline in the first half of 2026, with 20,759 vehicles reported stolen nationally between January and June, down 10.1% from the 23,093 thefts recorded in the same period last year.

The drop follows an even steeper decline of roughly 18% to 19% for full-year 2025, meaning theft levels have now fallen for two consecutive years and are approaching what Équité Association called pre-2021 levels, before a pandemic-driven surge pushed the country into what the industry repeatedly labelled a national crisis.

Alberta had the steepest regional decline at 15.1%. Western Canada overall was down 14.3%. Ontario fell 8.4%, Quebec dropped 6.4%, and Atlantic Canada saw the smallest decline at 4.1%, easing from 910 thefts to 873.

"The decrease in auto theft showcases the successful collaboration of the insurance industry with law enforcement and all levels of government," said Bryan Gast, national vice president, intelligence and investigations at Équité Association. He said sustaining the trend now depends on Transport Canada modernizing its Motor Vehicle Safety Regulations, so manufacturers build stronger anti-theft technology into new vehicles instead of leaving it to aftermarket devices and insurers.

Don't expect this to show up in premiums yet

Brokers fielding questions about why falling theft hasn't lowered premiums will find the answer hasn't changed much from last year.

When 2025's numbers came in, IBC's director of auto policy, Hanna Beydoun, was direct about the disconnect – repair costs had risen 22% since the pandemic began, partly due to tariffs on auto parts, and theft was only one of several pressures keeping premiums elevated. Full-year 2025 theft-related claim losses still hit an estimated $900 million, the first year since 2021 that total losses stayed under $1 billion, but that's a high floor to fall from.

With Alberta in the middle of a contested auto insurance overhaul and national personal auto premiums still climbing on the Applied Rating Index, a two-year theft decline alone won't turn rates around.

The manufacturer standard Équité has wanted since 2023

This isn't a new ask. Équité first called on Transport Canada to overhaul motor vehicle safety regulations back in 2023, at the height of the theft crisis, arguing consumers shouldn't pay out of pocket for aftermarket immobilizers when manufacturers could build in better protection from the factory.

A harmonized Canada-US theft deterrent standard has moved further along than its 1998-to-2007 predecessor, but it's still not in place.

Until it is, the vehicles most attractive to organized theft rings, and the policyholders who own them, stay more exposed than a modernized standard would allow.

What brokers can act on now

Two findings from Équité's 2026 Canadian Auto Theft Impact Survey are worth sharing with clients directly. Nearly 75% of Canadians want mandatory anti-theft technology built into vehicles, suggesting little resistance if insurers or manufacturers make it standard. More usefully, 82% of thefts happen at or next to the victim's home.

That means driveway and garage security matters more than parking habits away from home. For clients asking about comprehensive coverage or discount-qualifying anti-theft devices, the conversation should centre on steering wheel locks, GPS trackers, and driveway lighting or cameras, not where they park at work or while shopping.

Gast also tied theft proceeds to broader organized crime financing, saying criminal networks use auto theft and related insurance fraud to fund activities including international terrorism and drug and weapons trafficking.

Whether that framing builds political will behind a modernized vehicle safety standard, something insurers have now sought for close to three years, will likely matter more to Canada's long-term theft trajectory than any single half-year decline.

Related Stories

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!