Cold pavement triggers the auto discount clients miss

A mandated reduction sits unclaimed on most Ontario personal auto renewals
Cold pavement triggers the auto discount clients miss
MOTOR & FLEET
By Roxanne San Jose
Nov 18, 2026

CAA South Central Ontario (CAA SCO) issued guidance on November 17, 2026, reminding Ontario drivers that winter tires should go on when temperatures consistently fall at or below 7°C – well before the first snowfall. The advisory is routine. The commercial implication for personal lines brokers is not.

Every insurer operating in Ontario is required by regulation to offer a premium discount to private-passenger vehicle owners who install qualifying winter tires. Despite that, the Tire and Rubber Association of Canada’s (TRAC) 2025 Winter Tire Report found that lower auto insurance premiums are cited as a motivator by roughly one in four Canadian drivers – well behind safety, which seven in 10 cite as their primary reason for installing winter tires.

That gap is a client conversation most brokers are not having – and in a year when personal auto premiums rose across every province, it is one worth opening.

Read more: Tire choice now a key factor in winter auto premiums, experts say

Cold roads, not just snow

CAA SCO’s advisory makes a point that cuts directly to the coverage risk: cold pavement alone degrades the performance of all-season tires before any snow falls. The rubber compound stiffens as temperatures drop, reducing grip, braking responsiveness, and vehicle control. Winter tires are engineered to stay flexible in those conditions.

According to CAA SCO, winter tires can reduce braking distance by up to 25% – roughly two vehicle lengths – compared with all-season tires, depending on speed and conditions.

The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRAO) requires all Ontario insurers to offer the discount. The specific amount and eligibility dates vary by insurer.

“Winter driving isn’t only about snow. Cold pavement, slush, freezing rain, and ice can all affect how your vehicle responds. Preparing early means you’re ready for the conditions, whatever they may be,” said Nadia Matos, manager of communications and content at CAA South Central Ontario, in Thornhill, Ontario.

Provincial rules are not uniform

Outside Ontario, the regulatory picture varies. Quebec mandates winter tire installation on all passenger vehicles between December 1 and March 15. Newfoundland and Labrador requires all insurers to offer a premium reduction to drivers with four qualifying winter tires installed, under legislation that took effect January 1, 2020, according to the TRAC 2025 Winter Tire Report. In Manitoba, Manitoba Public Insurance offers low-interest financing for winter tire purchase rather than a mandated premium discount. The TRAC report identifies no equivalent legislative requirement in any other province.

British Columbia requires winter tires on certain designated highways between October 1 and March 31 but has no legislated insurance premium discount.

For brokers with clients across multiple provinces, the absence of a mandated discount elsewhere does not mean the saving is unavailable. It means clients do not know to request it.

A worsening loss backdrop

The renewal conversation carries additional weight this season. Environment and Climate Change Canada’s Canadian Centre for Climate Services assessed the current El Niño as virtually certain to be a “very strong” event, with more than 99% probability, peaking in late fall or early winter 2026. For Eastern Canada, that pattern historically raises the frequency of freeze-thaw cycles and the likelihood of freezing rain events.

The loss environment is already elevated. Severe weather drove more than $2.4 billion in insured losses across Canada in 2025, ranking it the 10th costliest year on record, according to Catastrophe Indices and Quantification Inc. (CatIQ) under licence to the Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC). The late-March 2025 ice storm in Ontario and Quebec was the single largest weather event of the year, accounting for $466 million in insured damages according to updated IBC figures.

Personal auto premiums rose across every province in Q1 2026, with the national average up year-over-year, according to the Applied Rating Index published by Applied Systems.

Read more: Canadian personal lines still in rate-rise mode –  Applied Index

Intact Financial Corporation issued a parallel home preparedness advisory on the same day as CAA SCO’s, citing the El Niño forecast and referencing the March 2025 storm losses. Its guidance for homeowners covered roof inspections, pipe insulation, and power outage preparation – relevant context for brokers advising on property exposure as well.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB CA.