Eight workers’ compensation boards (WCBs) across Canada – bodies that set mandatory employer premiums for workplace injury insurance – ended 2025 holding a combined $4.5 billion above their own funding targets, with direct implications for what employer clients pay at renewal. The count has risen from seven overfunded boards in 2024, and now spans British Columbia, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, Quebec, and Yukon, according to the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB)’s November 2026 research snapshot, Funding Fairness: State of Workers’ Compensation Funding.
Where boards hold surplus funds without a legal obligation to return them, employer clients may be paying more into the system than it currently requires. WCB premiums are one of several mandatory employer payroll costs rising simultaneously – Insurance Business Canada’s September 2026 analysis of Canada’s rising Employment Insurance premium rate and its impact on employer cost bases covers the broader payroll pressure context brokers are advising clients on heading into 2027.
Read more: Canada lifts Employment Insurance premium rate, maximum insurable earnings for 2027
The CFIB estimates that redistributing those excess funds could yield an average rebate of approximately $2,600 for a small business with five employees, rising to as much as $8,600 in Yukon. The same November 2026 snapshot found 84% of small businesses surveyed support a legal requirement for boards to return surplus funds.
Ontario remains the only province with a legal obligation to return workers’ compensation surpluses to employers. Under its framework, the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB) must issue rebates when its funding level reaches at least 125%, with discretionary distributions permitted from 115%.
That model produced two $2 billion distributions in 2025 – the second credited to employer accounts by October 31, 2025 – bringing Ontario’s total returned to employers that year to $4 billion, according to the CFIB. In a November 3, 2025, press release, the WSIB stated that premium reductions over the past decade have saved Ontario employers approximately $21.5 billion in cumulative costs.
Kalith Nanayakkara, senior policy analyst for British Columbia at the CFIB, said the rationale for legislative change applies nationally.
“With rising costs and economic uncertainty, now is not the time for boards to hold onto money that belongs to the employers who paid it. Returning surplus funds to employers won’t cost taxpayers a cent or jeopardize boards’ financial health, but it would give much-needed relief to small firms,” Nanayakkara said.
Since November 2025, four boards – in Manitoba, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, and Yukon – announced a combined $270 million in new distributions, according to the CFIB’s Funding Fairness snapshot. All four acted through board policy rather than legislation. Ontario’s approach – and the WSIB’s 2026 premium rate reduction for Ontario businesses – illustrates what mandated returns look like in practice.
Read more: WSIB cuts average premium rate for Ontario businesses in 2026
A concurrent rise in psychological injury claims is adding pressure to board finances – and to the employer premium rates that follow.
In British Columbia, WorkSafeBC’s report Psychological Injury Claims (Mental Disorder Claims) 2021 to 2025 shows accepted psychological injury-only claims rose from 1,736 in 2021 to 2,613 in 2025 – a 51% increase. These are claims where a psychological injury is the only accepted injury, adjudicated under section 135 of the Workers Compensation Act. New Brunswick recorded a 26% decline in traumatic psychological injury claims in 2025, which WorkSafeNB linked to its expanded focus on prevention and mental health supports, according to the CFIB.
Nationally, by 2022, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) accounted for 45% of all mental injury lost-time claims across Canada, with 3,291 accepted cases – up from approximately 1,200 in around 2012. Those figures come from the AWCBC’s 2025 report PTSD in Canada: Trends, Federal Framework, and Implications for Workers’ Compensation, published by the Association of Workers’ Compensation Boards of Canada (AWCBC) and confirmed accessible from the AWCBC website. The same report identified medical cost inflation and rising psychological injury claims as primary pressures on board finances heading into 2026.
Psychological injury claims tend to carry longer durations and higher per-claim costs than physical injuries. As volumes grow, their effect on the cost base boards use to calculate employer rates is disproportionate – a trend with direct implications for clients in sectors with high exposure, such as health care, emergency services, and public administration.
Premium rates across Canada vary considerably, reflecting how differently boards have managed their financial positions. Nova Scotia charges the highest average employer premiums of any province despite holding an underfunded position of 93% of target, according to the AWCBC. Manitoba, by contrast, maintains one of the lowest average rates in the country.
That divergence points to the absence of any national standard for how boards handle surpluses or disclose their funding levels – the gap the CFIB is asking governments to close through mandatory distribution policies, published timelines, and transparent reporting of psychological injury claim volumes.
Jonathan Galgay, CFIB director for Newfoundland and Labrador, said the lack of a clear framework leaves businesses without reliable planning information.
“Boards should set out a clear plan to return surpluses to the employers who paid into the system, so small businesses aren’t left guessing when they’ll get their money back. A rebate of a few thousand dollars can make a real difference – owners could put that money toward workplace safety, wages, or simply keeping their doors open,” Galgay said.
For brokers, the practical step is to ask employer clients whether they know their provincial board’s current funding position and whether any surplus distribution is planned. That question, raised before renewal, opens a conversation about whether a client’s premium assessment reflects a system holding more than it needs. The competing pressures that arise when a board moves to return money – including employer relief versus benefit-level concerns – are detailed in Insurance Business Canada’s report on the WSIB’s 2027 premium cut and the union response it triggered, which reported on the WSIB’s October 2026 announcement.