The Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) have published their first joint thematic report on insurance claims handling - a document that is not a one-off exercise but the opening edition of a recurring series that will define what both bodies look for when they examine how insurers manage claims.
Published on November 19, 2026, the report covers home, motor, travel and pet insurance and focuses on claim delays, administration and customer service - which together accounted for around 66,000 of the 215,000 insurance complaints investigated by the FOS between 2021/22 and 2025/26, or 31% of all cases.
The headline figure is stark. Across all insurance complaints investigated over the five years, the FOS upheld 34% in the consumer’s favour. For claim delay complaints specifically, the uphold rate was 50% - consistently above average in every year reviewed. For travel insurance, it was 61%. These are not marginal outcomes. They represent a systematic pattern of insurers losing disputes that, in many cases, could have been avoided.
The report arrives against a backdrop of active enforcement. In its December 2025 response to the Which? super-complaint, the FCA confirmed it had opened two enforcement investigations into claims handling, commissioned three independent skilled person reports into firms’ claims handling systems and controls under section 166 powers, required three firms’ senior managers to formally attest to strengthening their systems and controls, and asked 13 of the 15 home insurers in its sample to review how they had handled storm claims and cash settlements. These are not warnings. Some firms are already under regulatory jeopardy.
The report is a product of wider reforms to the redress system under the Financial Services and Markets Bill, which - subject to Royal Assent - will introduce a new statutory framework requiring the FCA and FOS to publish regular joint thematic reports. Individual FOS decisions will continue to be published but are not intended to operate as precedent. Firms seeking to understand how the FOS will approach a recurring issue should look to the thematic reports first.
In practical terms, this report is the new framework. It sets out what the FOS considers, which regulatory rules it applies - including ICOBS 8.1.1R on prompt and fair claims handling and the Consumer Duty under PRIN 2A - and what evidence firms must be able to produce to demonstrate compliance.
Read more: Lords tell FCA to move faster on home and travel insurance
The report is explicit on a point that brokers and insurers should read carefully: delay complaints are rarely just about the passage of time. The FOS finds they most often reflect whether the firm kept the claim moving, explained what was happening, managed its appointed agents - loss adjusters, repairers, medical assistance providers - and took responsibility for the overall customer journey.
For home insurance, the FOS investigated 10,200 claim delay cases over the five years, upholding 53%. That rate peaked at 57% in 2023/24 and remained above 50% in every year. The report attributes this to the complexity of home claims - flood, storm, fire, escape of water and subsidence - and their dependence on loss adjusters, surveyors, contractors and specialist reports. Where one part of the process stalls, the whole claim loses momentum.
For travel insurance, the claim delay uphold rate of 61% - the highest of the four product areas - reflects a specific and serious risk: customers who are abroad, unwell or stranded, left to coordinate between insurers, medical providers and assistance companies without adequate support. The report emphasises that where a customer is recovering from surgery or dealing with a medical emergency, delay and unclear ownership can cause disproportionate and foreseeable harm. For motor insurance, claim delay complaints had a 46% uphold rate across the five years, with administration and customer service generating more than 13,000 investigations - the highest volume of any product area in the report. Pet insurance recorded a 52% claim delay uphold rate, with the main recurring concern being clarity of policy exclusions and pre-existing condition terms rather than delay volumes.
One of the report’s most direct messages concerns oversight of appointed agents. The FOS is not only examining whether the insurer made the right decision on the claim. It is also looking at what the insurer can evidence about its oversight of outsourced activity - how responsibilities and service standards were set, how third-party performance was monitored, how issues were escalated, and whether the insurer had sufficient access to claims data to identify risks to customers.
A recurring pattern emerges across all four product areas: customers left to coordinate between multiple parties, unsure whether to contact the insurer, the loss adjuster or the repairer, receiving generic updates or being asked to repeat information as the claim passes through a chain of hand-offs. An insurer cannot absolve itself of responsibility by pointing to an appointed agent. Where claims handling is outsourced or delegated, the firm remains responsible for compliance and customer outcomes.
Phil Smith, head of redress at independent insurance consultancy Broadstone, said the findings reinforced a point that is easy to state and harder to deliver consistently.
“The findings of this regulatory review reinforce the importance of insurers delivering a consistently high standard of service throughout the claims process, particularly when customers are relying on their insurance cover at difficult or stressful times.
“While the complexity of some claims inevitably creates challenges, insurers must ensure that customers are kept informed, delays are minimised and third-party providers are subject to effective oversight. Particular care must also be taken to identify and support vulnerable customers.
“Ultimately, responsibility for delivering good customer outcomes rests with insurers, regardless of the involvement of intermediaries or other third parties. The FCA’s Consumer Duty places clear obligations on insurers around customer outcomes, and insurers will need to demonstrate that these principles are embedded throughout their claims operations. Improving claims handling should be viewed as an opportunity to strengthen customer trust by improving operational efficiency and reducing the volume of complaints escalated to the Ombudsman.”
Read more: Insurance complaints fall - but one line bucks the trend
The report devotes significant attention to vulnerable customers. In 2025/26, around a quarter of the insurance complaints the FOS resolved involved a consumer in vulnerable circumstances - a figure the report notes is likely to understate the full extent of customer need, since it only captures vulnerability where it was identified and recorded. For medical insurance, the proportion was 41%.
The FCA’s expectation is that vulnerability is identified early in the claims journey and actively - not by waiting for a customer to self-identify. Claims teams and appointed agents should adapt communications, escalate urgent cases and avoid repeated evidence requests where a customer’s circumstances require a more careful approach.
The claims handling data it contains - broken down by product and complaint type - provides a basis for asking harder questions about how a prospective insurer manages delays, oversees its appointed agents and identifies vulnerable customers in its claims population. A firm with a consistently high uphold rate against it in a particular product line has a claims handling problem that renewal pricing does not reflect.
Where a broker assists a client through a claim - chasing progress, escalating delays or helping navigate a third-party adjuster - their own Consumer Duty obligations are engaged. The report’s emphasis on clear communication, active management and evidenced oversight applies to intermediaries as well as insurers.
The FCA expects firms to monitor claims outcomes using management information - duration, acceptance and rejection rates, settlements, complaints, repeat contact and supplier performance - and to compare outcomes for customers with characteristics of vulnerability against the broader population. Firms should be able to explain what that information shows, what risks they identified and what action they took.
Read more: Motor cover drives complaints rise despite broader FOS improvement
The FCA has committed to providing a public update on its claims handling work - including progress on the Which? super-complaint response - in December 2026, within weeks of this report’s publication. That update is expected to cover the outcomes of the enforcement investigations and skilled person reviews confirmed in December 2025, the FCA’s analysis of how sales processes affect consumer outcomes, and further work on consumer understanding of cover.
Future editions of the joint report are expected to include information on referrals made by the FOS to the FCA under the new statutory framework - once the Financial Services and Markets Bill receives Royal Assent - and to feature lead complaints involving novel or significant issues that provide a clearer framework for how the FOS approaches recurring problems.