What happened: The Privy Council ruled that a Gibraltar insurer's former managing director cannot reduce his damages liability by pointing to £32.3 million in capital recycled from the insurer's own stolen funds.
Who's involved: Enterprise Insurance Company Plc (in liquidation), its parent Enterprise Holdings Ltd, and the former managing director
What's at stake: A £200 million insolvency deficit and whether £32.3 million in capital injections should reduce the director's liability
Why it matters: Liquidators pursuing dishonest directors cannot be forced to give credit for money that was stolen and recycled as share capital - even if it technically arrived as a subscription for new shares
Where it stands: Decided by the Privy Council on November 17, 2026 - appeal allowed, cross-appeal dismissed
For 12 years, an insurer's own premium income was quietly siphoned through fake service agreements, cycled through a parent company, and pumped back in as what looked like fresh share capital. The Privy Council has now confirmed: none of that money counts as a credit against the director who orchestrated the scheme.
The ruling, handed down on November 17, lands in what remains one of the UK insurance market's largest collapses. Enterprise Insurance Company Plc (EIC), a Gibraltar-incorporated insurer that wrote business across the UK and other European markets, went into provisional liquidation in July 2016. Its deficit was estimated by the liquidator at around £200 million. The judgment - from the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council ([2026] UKPC 40) — resolves the final appeals between EIC's liquidator and the company's former managing director.
The scheme, as found by the trial court in Gibraltar and upheld on appeal, worked like this. EIC paid its sister company, EIG Services Ltd, 8% of its gross premiums - roughly 40% of its net premiums - under an agreement for marketing services that were never actually provided. Further payments were made for a software system (an arrangement the court found was initially genuine but became another means of diverting funds from about 2009) and for a reinsurance arrangement fee that had no proper justification.
Over 12 years between 2005 and 2016, large sums were extracted from EIC and handed to an unregulated sister company. The court found the former managing director was dishonestly involved in these payments and knew they were gratuitous.
EIG used part of those funds to pay £12.3 million to shareholders of the group's parent company, Enterprise Holdings Ltd (EHL), as supposed remuneration for services. The invoices were fictitious. EIG paid another £16.6 million to EHL as dividends.
EHL then used some of this money - along with £24 million borrowed by issuing bonds on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange - to subscribe for new shares in EIC. In total, £32.3 million went back into the insurer as share capital.
The result was a loop. Money flowed out of EIC through sham agreements, up through EIG, across to EHL, and back down into EIC as capital - which helped the insurer fend off regulatory intervention, at least some of the time. On other occasions, the Gibraltar Financial Services Commission imposed restrictions that were simply disregarded.
Alongside the circular money trail, the judgment addressed a second major failing. EIC underwrote insurance policies for investors in a tax avoidance scheme called Icebreaker. Investors joined limited liability partnerships (LLPs) that invested in intellectual property - films, books, music - and claimed tax relief on their losses. EIC insured them against losing the 20% of their investment that came from their own money, charging premiums of 2.75% of the amount at risk.
The gross premiums EIC collected were less than £1 million. The estimated liabilities: £31.4 million. No reserves were set aside. No reinsurance was arranged.
The former managing director argued that an exclusion clause in the policy - which let EIC off the hook if it reasonably believed the insured had "colluded" with the LLP to "engineer" its failure - meant EIC was never actually on risk. The Privy Council disagreed. Investors could not affect how the scheme operated, there was no evidence any policyholder tried to engineer the failure of their LLP, and reading the clause that way would mean the policy could never come into effect. That would negate the policy's entire purpose.
His fallback argument - that the policies were void because they related to a tax avoidance scheme - also failed. Tax avoidance schemes are not unlawful, the court held, and there is no common law principle that arrangements designed to avoid tax are void on public policy grounds.
On the central damages question, the former managing director argued that the £32.3 million injected by EHL should be offset against his liability. The Gibraltar Court of Appeal had agreed with him, finding those payments were closely linked to the events that caused EIC's loss.
The Privy Council reversed that decision on two grounds.
First, EIC was not actually better off for receiving the money. The trial court found the capital injections "allowed [EIC] to stagger on as a business (albeit largely unprofitably)" and "allowed it to keep writing further premium, for greater losses to be incurred, whilst allowing for ongoing substantial payments to be made out." Fresh capital meant more policies written without adequate reserves and more money available to be siphoned. The defendant had not proved EIC received a genuine benefit.
Second, even if there had been a benefit, it would not have been deductible. EHL's intention was to increase EIC's working capital so it could keep trading - not to shield a dishonest director from liability. The court drew an analogy with cases where charitable or family payments to a victim of loss are not credited to the wrongdoer, and held it would be "unjust and unreasonable" for the payments to reduce the director's bill for the very problems he had caused.
The case sets out how courts should approach damages in complex group-structure insolvencies - particularly where the same dishonest conduct that created the losses also generated the supposed offsets. For liquidators, claims managers and coverage counsel handling insurer failures with intercompany fund flows, the message is clear: recycling stolen money as capital does not buy a discount on liability.